The Relational Origins of Rules in Online Communities
Charles Kiene, Sohyeon Hwang, Nathan TeBlunthuis, Carl Colglazier, Aaron Shaw, Benjamin Mako Hill · 2025
Read The Relational Origins of Rules in Online Communities by Charles Kiene, Sohyeon Hwang, Nathan TeBlunthuis, Carl Colglazier, Aaron Shaw, Benjamin Mako Hill (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-18318.txt.
Introduction
Charles Kiene and co-authors ask where the rules of online communities come from. Their 2025 study draws on forty long interviews with leaders of subreddits, fan wikis, and Fediverse servers. A grounded theory approach let seven processes of rule adoption emerge from the leaders' own accounts, rather than from a preset scheme.
Rules, it turns out, are not only tools for order. Leaders also adopt or change them to signal legitimacy and identity to other communities. Growth or decline often forced change, but whether change happened also hinged on volunteer time, ways for members to give feedback, and trust between leaders and members. The findings widen older theories of how groups govern themselves.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Charles Kiene, Sohyeon Hwang, Nathan TeBlunthuis, Carl Colglazier, Aaron Shaw, Benjamin Mako Hill |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 98 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-18318
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Relational Origins of Rules in Online Communities Charles Kiene, Sohyeon Hwang, Nathan TeBlunthuis, Carl Colglazier, Aaron Shaw, Benjamin Mako Hill Abstract . Where do rules come from in online communities? This study investigates how and why online communities adopt and change their rules. We conducted a grounded theory-based analysis of 40 in-depth interviews with community leaders from subreddits, Fandom wikis, and Fediverse servers, and identified seven processes involved in the adoption of online community rules. Our findings reveal that, beyond operational reasons like regulating behavior and solving problems, rules are also adopted and changed for relational reasons, such as signaling or reinforcing community legitimacy and identity to other communities. While rule change was often prompted by challenges during community growth or decline, change also depended on volunteer leaders’ work capacity, the presence of member feedback mechanisms, and relational dynamics between leaders and members. Our findings extend prior theories from social computing and organizational research, illustrating how institutionalist and ecological explanations of the relational origins of rules complement operational accounts. Finally, we build on these explanations to offer a set of design propositions that reflect the relational aspects of rules and rulemaking across communities’ lifecycles. Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 10 6 CSCW167 10 DOI: 10.1145/3817015 † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Rules serve many purposes in online communities. Rules codify social norms ( Chandrasekharan et al., 2018 ; Fiesler et al., 2018 ) , signal appropriate behavior ( Matias, 2019b ) , and become sites of contesting values ( Gillespie, 2018 ; Stockinger et al., 2023 ; Jhaver et al., 2019c ; Crawford and Gillespie, 2016 ) . Prior studies in social computing characterize extant rules ( Fiesler et al., 2018 ; Nicholson et al., 2023 ; Hwang and Shaw, 2022 ; Keegan and Fiesler, 2017 ; Reddy and Chandrasekharan, 2023 , e.g.,) as well as how they are enforced ( Dosono and Semaan, 2019 ; Wohn, 2019 ; Cullen and Kairam, 2022 ; Matias, 2019b , e.g.,) , including the impacts of automated moderation and enforcement tools ( Chandrasekharan et al., 2019 ; TeBlunthuis et al., 2021 ; Halfaker and Geiger, 2020 , e.g.,) . However, most studies take for granted that rules must also be designed and adopted . How and why do rules come to be? What challenges do leaders face in creating and changing them? Prior work in social computing offers two explanations of the origins of community rules. The first emphasizes decision-making by platform owners or designers who assume rulemaking authority and seek to engineer or govern social interaction in particular ways ( Kraut et al., 2012 ; Gillespie, 2018 , e.g.,) . The second emphasizes localized rule development in response to specific challenges, conflicts, or constraints ( Frey et al., 2019 ; Seering and Kairam, 2022 , e.g.,) . While these approaches differ in their objects of study, both treat rules as primarily operational —i.e., created to solve practical problems and structure day-to-day activity within communities. Previous empirical work has shown that many online communities have similar rules ( Reddy and Chandrasekharan, 2023 ; Fiesler et al., 2018 ; Nicholson et al., 2023 ; Hwang and Shaw, 2022 ; Chandrasekharan et al., 2018 ) . Both approaches would thus assume that similar rules arise from similar problems. However, other prior work casts doubt on this and suggests that rules originate for non-operational reasons as well ( Hwang et al., 2024 ; Hwang and Shaw, 2022 ; TeBlunthuis et al., 2022 , e.g.,) . Although there is substantial theoretical, descriptive, and quantitative research into online community rules, we lack a grounded understanding of how rule similarity arises from the processes by which communities adopt or change their rules. To understand the origins of rules in online communities, we conducted 40 in-depth, open-ended interviews with leaders of communities from three different sociotechnical systems: subreddits on Reddit, wikis on Fandom, and servers in the Fediverse. In order to investigate the sources of rule similarity, we recruited interviewees from clusters of communities with similar rules in each setting. We report findings based on a comparative, grounded theory analysis ( Charmaz, 2015 ) , identifying seven distinct processes involved in rulemaking in online communities. Across these processes, we find that a community’s rules and rulemaking are not only operational, governing their internal affairs, but are also importantly relational , navigating their external constituencies and constraints. 1 1 1 Our use of the term “relational” is distinct from the way it is used within sociology to describe, for example, theories of relationalism versus substantivalism. To community leaders, rules help draw distinctions between communities, manage issues of community growth as well as decline, and legitimize their status among other communities—in addition to providing a basis for enforcement decisions or conveying community goals and norms. Our findings resonate with work from organizational sociology—including new institutionalism ( Meyer and Rowan, 1977 ; DiMaggio and Powell, 1983 ; Tolbert and Zucker, 1983 , e.g.,) and organizational ecology ( Hannan and Freeman, 1984 ; Carroll, 1985 ) —which has argued that similarities in organizational structures can be explained by accounting for external social pressures, rather than common internal problems alone. In this work, we extend these insights to the dynamics of rules in online communities, treating them as sensitizing theories to interpret our findings. Our paper makes several contributions to social computing research on governance. First, our account of the origins of rules fills a critical qualitative gap in the origins and practices of rule creation and change in online communities. Using comparative evidence across three different systems, we show how rules mediate online communities’ relationships to other communities, platform rules and affordances, and audiences of potential and current members. Second, we argue that a relational account of rulemaking extends prior operational accounts, expanding the design space of digital institutions and community self-governance by synthesizing concepts from new institutionalism and organizational ecology to explain how rules communicate niche identity and legitimacy. Finally, we present a set of design propositions that highlight rule adoption strategies across community lifecycle phases and show how technological design may influence rule adoption and change. 2. Background Governance is the social processes that shape behavior within and between institutions ( Bednar, 2023 ) . As part of governance, rules are the explicit “norms, regulations, and expectations that regulate the behavior of individuals and interactions among them” ( March et al., 2000 , p. 5) . Although rules are central to governance in online communities, past research takes for granted how rules are initially adopted and how they evolve. Our paper investigates why and how rules in online communities are created and changed. While our theorizing largely happened during and after data collection and is reflected in our Discussion (§ 6 ), we follow influential advice from Giles et al. ’s ( Giles et al., 2013 ) to maintain “an open mind versus an empty head” ( Giles et al., 2013 ) by conducting a literature review both ex ante , to ensure that our work was in conversation with existing theoretical perspectives, and during analysis and writing, to help situate and frame our findings. In particular, two lines of scholarship informed our study. The first includes two paradigms in prior social computing