Comment on “Politicizing science funding undermines public trust in science, academic freedom, and the unbiased generation of knowledge”
John M. Herbert · 2025
Read Comment on “Politicizing science funding undermines public trust in science, academic freedom, and the unbiased generation of knowledge” by John M. Herbert (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-18196.txt.
Introduction
John Herbert writes a comment that answers a 2024 commentary on science funding in the United States, in a paper from 2025. The earlier piece claimed that funding agencies had politicized grant awards in the name of workforce diversity. Herbert argues that its claims rest on opinion essays by the same circle of authors, dressed up as scholarship.
He checks the sources behind the claims and reports that many are unsupported or plainly debunked. The comment also documents how inclusion and diversity plans for grant proposals to US agencies actually stood at the end of 2024. Herbert frames the record as a guard against false retellings in a hostile policy climate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | John M. Herbert |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-18196
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comment on “Politicizing science funding undermines public trust in science, academic freedom, and the unbiased generation of knowledge” John M. Herbert Abstract In a commentary published in mid-2024 (to which the present work is a direct response), a number of scientists argue that U.S. funding agencies have “politicized” the process by which grants are awarded, in service of diversifying the scientific workforce. The commentary in question, however, makes numerous unfounded assertions while recycling citations to a fusillade of opinion essays written by the same cabal of authors, in an effort to resemble a work of serious scholarship. Basic fact-checking is provided here, demonstrating numerous claims that are unsupported by the source material and readily debunked. The present work also serves to document the reality of inclusion and diversity plans for scientific grant proposals to U.S. funding agencies, as they existed at the end of 2024. It is intended as a bulwark against retroactive false narratives, as the U.S. moves into a period of intense antagonism towards diversity, equity, and inclusion activities. 1 Introduction A recent commentary by Efimov et al. 1 argues that U.S. funding agencies have “politicized” the process by which grants are awarded, in service of diversifying the scientific workforce. The commentary makes numerous unfounded assertions while recycling citations to a fusillade of opinion essays written by the same cabal of authors. A list of problematic claims, unsupported by the source material, is presented in Table 1 . The most egregious errors are discussed below. Table 1: Summary of key errors and misrepresentations in Efimov et al. 1 Error or misrepresentation {}^{\textit{a}} Explanation and rebuttal The scientific enterprise is strictly meritocratic “Claims, such as ‘The presence of disparities is proof of systemic racism’ and ‘Meritocracy is a myth’ are propagated widely despite the vagueness of the claims and their lack of support by concrete data”. Nevertheless, applicants for federal funding “must profess the belief (one not itself supported by science) that certain systemic barriers exist”. There is overwhelming, well-documented evidence for systemic bias and unmeritocratic hiring practices in academic science. 5 DEI activities are required for STEM funding “[F]unding agencies are requiring applicants \ldots to dedicate a part of the research budget to [DEI] implementation”, and this is “[d]iverting funding from science into activities unrelated to the production of knowledge”. Few (if any) program solicitations ever had explicit requirements for DEI activities. “Inclusion Plans” and similar documents need not have funds attached. Furthermore, who is allowed to serve as a scientific investigator is a crucial aspect of the scientific process. Funding agencies are increasingly favoring DEI over scientific merit The “merit-based approach… is now being deemphasized”. Some agencies do require a discussion of broadening participation but the review process continues to prioritize scientific merit. Grant proposals require extravagant spending on DEI activities Using rhetorical artifice, Efimov et al. imply that 5–10% of a NSF budget, or perhaps $50,000, constitutes typical spending for DEI activities. They insinuate that this is mandated by funding agencies. The 5–10% figure is taken out of context and the $50,000 value comes from the website of an industry consulting firm, provided without context. Funding agencies seldom (if ever) micromanage budgets in the manner that is suggested, nor do peer reviewers. Applicants from “inclusive” institutions or research groups must prevaricate to obtain funding “If an applicant’s institution has already overcome any systemic barriers it may have had (or the applicant believes it has done so), then the applicant must lie or the proposal is doomed to fail. \ldots [I]f access to an applicant’s research team is already fair and non-discriminatory, why should an applicant be required to write an inclusion plan[?]”. This is an intentional feint that equates “treating everyone the same” with “removing systemic barriers”, a fallacy that is specifically addressed elsewhere. 6 It is difficult to imagine that any institution has truly “overcome” such barriers; that’s what makes them systemic . In any case, these comments overstate the role of Inclusion Plans and PIER plans in assessing a proposal’s scientific merit. DEI activities are unrelated to funding agencies’ scientific mission Funding agencies are “participating in activities that are arguably unrelated to their stated missions”. Scientific workforce development is an important part of these agencies’ mission. Training a workforce whose demographics reflect the U.S. population is one aspect of that pursuit. Diversity initiatives by the funding agencies originate with U.S. President Biden It is insinuated that no such initiatives existed until a recent pair of Executive Orders from President Biden. The NSF’s “Broader Impacts” mandate has existed since 1997 and persisted through presidential administrations from both political parties. 7 Broader Impacts may (but need not) include activities related to broadening participation. 2 , 7 President Biden demands that scientific funding be distributed evenly according to race A recent directive from President Biden 8 is purported to “mandate that research funding be distributed ‘equitably’—i.e., proportionally to demographic representation—among identity groups.” The directive in question aims to ensure that federal programs are delivering equitable outcomes. It calls for creation of “Equity Teams” that will “coordinate the implementation of equity initiatives and ensure that their respective agencies are delivering equitable outcomes for the American people”. Nowhere are funds allocated for any “identity groups”. Demographic data are requested by funding agencies for nefarious purposes Investigators are obligated to fulfill “ de facto DEI quotas” as a condition of grant renewal, so that awards are “allocated according to identity metrics”. Submission of this information to the NSF is voluntary, 9 and awards are not made using identity metrics. In support of this assertion, the only citation that is provided pertains to a NIH program specifically targeted at inclusion and diversity, 10 for which demographic data are a natural part of the reporting requirements. DEI requirements amount to illegal compelled speech “The First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States strictly forbids compelling people to say things they do not believe are true.” This is a gross misrepresentation of the First Amendment. There is no Constitutional right to federal support for research. Funding agencies circumvent discrimination laws through subterfuge “Funding agencies attempt to circumvent the laws prohibiting them from basing funding decisions on race or ethnicity by cloaking DEI requirements in nebulous language [citation omitted] and by disguising racial preferences”. The NASA slide deck that is cited 11 actually warns that “[t]okenizing diverse team members” is a common weakness of Inclusion Plans. • a All text in quotation marks in the left column is from Ref. 1 . 2 Fact-Checking The fundamental claim in Efimov et al. 1 is that U.S. funding agencies are prioritizing diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) over scientific merit in the review process for research funding. This is debunked in detail elsewhere. 2 In fact, few (if any) program solicitations require DEI activities. Activities that are not mandated by the solicitation are not required elements for the purpose of merit review. If DEI activities are not required, then no portion of the budget needs to be set aside for them. To support the accusation that DEI activities are “[d]iverting funding from science”, all the authors can muster is a slide deck 3 from a principal investigator (PI) whose work focuses specifically on public outreach. 4