How does noise protection affect the accuracy of life expectancy and other demographic indicators

Fabian Bach · 2025

Read How does noise protection affect the accuracy of life expectancy and other demographic indicators by Fabian Bach (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17963.txt.

Introduction

Fabian Bach, writing alone in 2025, asked how adding noise to census counts affects the accuracy of key population rates. Statistical offices add such noise to guard the privacy of the people counted. Raw counts of births and deaths by age, sex, and place feed rates for fertility, death, and life expectancy.

Bach set the noise against the natural spread in the counts, using a standard model for rare events. He derived a closed formula for the spread in life expectancy based on the spread in death counts, and checked it with numbers. The work helps offices judge how much privacy noise costs in accuracy, before they lock in a method.

Catalog record

CREATORFabian Bach
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17963

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How does noise protection affect the accuracy of life expectancy and other demographic indicators? Thanks: The views expressed are purely those of the author and may not in any circumstances be regarded as stating an official position of the European Commission. Fabian Bach Abstract New and efficient methods based on noise addition to protect the confidentiality in population statistics have been developed, tested and applied in census production by various members of the European Statistical System over the past years. Basic demographic statistics—such as population stocks, live births and deaths by age, sex and region—may be protected in a similar way, but also form the raw input to calculate various demographic indicators. This paper analyses the impact on the accuracy of some selected indicators, namely fertility and mortality rates and life expectancies, under the assumption that the raw input counts are protected with a generic noise method with fixed variance parameter, by comparing the size of noise uncertainties with intrinsic statistical uncertainties using a Poisson model. As a by-product, we derive and validate numerically a closed analytical expression for the variance of life expectancies in a certain class of calculation models as a function of the variance of input mortality data. This expression also allows to calculate analytically the statistical uncertainty of life expectancies using the mentioned Poisson model for the input death counts. 1 Introduction After the 2011 EU census, European Statistical System (ESS) 1 1 1 The joint body of Eurostat and the national statistical institutes of all EU countries and Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland. It is responsible for the development and quality assurance of social European statistics. experts realised that traditional statistical disclosure control (SDC) methods like cell suppression become inefficient when applied to very detailed cross-tabulations. Moreover, these methods do not protect outputs effectively when disseminated on non-nested geographical breakdowns like administrative regions and grids (geographic differencing) [ 1 ] . Mainly for these two reasons, ESS efforts began from 2015 onwards to explore new SDC methods that avoid excessive information loss and also protect against geographic differencing. As a result, two methods based on adding some noise to the statistics were tested and recommended for the 2021 EU census ( 1 , 2 , 3 ) , where a significant number of ESS members eventually decided to use one or a combination of these methods for their census outputs. In the wake of the modernisation of social statistics in the ESS, it is likely that also the annual demographic statistics would become more detailed and eventually integrated with multi-annual population statistics like censuses. This would entail some new questions, e.g. whether some of these annual demographic statistics would require confidentiality protection; how the consistency with census-like (protected) statistics would be ensured; and finally how the key use cases of demographic statistics can be sufficiently ensured (cf. ( 4 ) ). For instance, basic demographic statistics including population stocks, live births and deaths by age, sex and region are needed to calculate various demographic indicators at regional level. If the protection methods originally developed for census outputs were to be applied to these demographic statistics, the question arises how the additional noise-induced uncertainty propagates to the resulting indicator values. This paper analyses the effects of a generic noise protection method with a fixed variance parameter on some selected demographic indicators. 2 Noise setup and uncertainty propagation It is one of the features of the cell key method (CKM) ( 5 , 6 , 7 ) —one of the two methods recommended for census ouputs in the ESS—that the variance of the noise added to the output counts is a fixed input parameter, here denoted V . Moreover, the detailed noise distributions of the CKM typically follow a discretised bell curve (as all noise terms must be integers to retain integer outputs) that is very close to a Gaussian ( 8 , 9 ) . Through these properties, the CKM is considered a reference example for a generic noise protection method in the sense mentioned above. Furthermore, the standard theory of error propagation based on linear response of a measurement function f(\mathbf{x}) to a set of uncorrelated input measurements \mathbf{x} can be applied: \Delta_{f}=\sqrt{\sum_{i}\left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_{i}}\right)^{2}\Delta_{i}^{2}}\;, (1) where i runs over the elements of \mathbf{x} and \Delta denotes the standard deviation. From Eq. 1 it is straightforward to derive two simple but handy special cases: when f is a simple sum of independent input measurements, the squares of the absolute uncertainties are added; and when f is a simple product (or ratio) of independent input measurements, the squares of relative uncertainties are added—i.e. \displaystyle f\left(\mathbf{x}\right)=\sum_{i}x_{i}\quad \displaystyle\Rightarrow\quad\Delta_{f}=\sqrt{\sum_{i}\Delta_{i}^{2}} (2a) \displaystyle f\left(\mathbf{x}\right)=\prod_{i}x_{i}^{\pm 1}\quad \displaystyle\Rightarrow\quad\delta_{f}=\sqrt{\sum_{i}\delta_{i}^{2}} (2b) with relative uncertainties of the input measurements denoted \delta_{i}=\Delta_{i}/x_{i} . As a further simplification, in the specific setup analysed here where only the CKM effect is to be considered, the standard deviation of all the input measurements x_{i} is constant: \Delta_{i}\equiv\Delta=\sqrt{V}\quad\forall i. (3) 3 Results for selected demographic indicators For the quantitative analysis we select three demographic indicators that are generally very important for all kinds of demographic analysis: crude fertility and death rates, and life expectancy. These indicators depend on three distinct sets of raw input counts for a given region and time period: population stocks by sex and single years of age at the beginning and at the end of a given time period (typically a calendar year), as well as the number of live births (by mother’s single year of age) and the number of deaths (by sex and single year of age) during the same time period. To add some geographical granularity, we analyse all NUTS 2 regions of all ESS members for the latest available reference year 2023, as published in the data sets demo_r_d2jan 2 2 2 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/DEMO_R_D2JAN/default , demo_r_fagec 3 3 3 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/DEMO_R_FAGEC/default and demo_r_magec 4 4 4 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/DEMO_R_MAGEC/default . 3.1 Fertility rates The age-specific crude fertility rate is defined as f_{x}=\frac{b_{x}}{w_{x}} (4) with x the relevant age in single years, b_{x} the number of live births by mothers aged x and w_{x} the average female population stock aged x during the reference time period. Then the relative error on f_{x} is given by Eq. 2b as \delta_{f_{x}}\equiv\frac{\Delta_{f_{x}}}{f_{x}}=\Delta\sqrt{\frac{1}{b_{x}^{2}}+\frac{1}{w_{x}^{2}}}\simeq\frac{\Delta}{b_{x}}\;, (5) where in the last step we neglect for simplicity a possible CKM uncertainty on w_{x} , because b_{x}\ll w_{x} in general. In this approximation, the absolute uncertainty on f_{x} from Eq. 5 is \Delta_{f_{x}}=f_{x}\delta_{f_{x}}\simeq\Delta/w_{x} . Setting V=1 and plugging in the numbers from the data sets, one finds that in the majority of cases the relative CKM uncertainty on the age-specific fertility rates is moderate, with a median relative uncertainty of 0.37\% and more than 88\% of all relative uncertainties ( 10\,854 of 12\,287 calculated) <10\% . Nevertheless, 33\% of the uncertainties found ( 4\,061 of 12\,287 ) are >1\% . In line with Eq. 5 , it is not surprising that the largest relative uncertainties, up to 100\% for V=1 , are found where the numbers of live births are very small, i.e. b_{x}<10 down to b_{x}=1 . This is illustrated in Fig. 1 showing the parametric plot of Eq. ( 5 ) over the entire relevant w_{x} – f_{x} plane. Figure 1: Relative uncertainty on the

Read the complete text