On the fragility of laminar flow
Theodore D. Drivas, Daniel Ginsberg, Marc Nualart · 2025
Read On the fragility of laminar flow by Theodore D. Drivas, Daniel Ginsberg, Marc Nualart (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17817.txt.
Introduction
Theodore Drivas, Daniel Ginsberg, and Marc Nualart study when smooth, layered fluid flow breaks into swirling islands, in a paper from 2025. Such laminar flow is a steady solution of the classic equations for a fluid with no friction. On symmetric domains its shape is rigid: straight channels force shear flow and round rings force circular flow.
Small bends of the domain can keep the flow laminar if the base flow is stable and never stalls. Flows that do stall, though, grow islands of closed streamlines on almost any bent channel. The authors prove that stable steady flows which stall must have islands on generic domains. When the domain sits close to a symmetric one, the island size grows with the square root of the bend. Stable flow, in short, is itself fragile.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Theodore D. Drivas, Daniel Ginsberg, Marc Nualart |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17817
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the fragility of laminar flow Theodore D. Drivas, Daniel Ginsberg, Marc Nualart Abstract . Inviscid laminar flow is a stationary solution of the incompressible Euler equations whose streamlines foliate the fluid domain. Their structure on symmetric domains is rigid: all laminar flows occupying straight periodic channels are shear and on regular annuli they are circular [ 9 ] . Laminarity can persist to slight deformations of these domains provided the base flow is Arnold stable and non-stagnant (non-vanishing velocity) [ 4 ] . On the other hand, flows with trivial net momentum (and thus stagnate) break laminarity by developing islands (regions of contractible streamlines) on all non-flat periodic channels with up/down reflection symmetry [ 8 ] . Here, we show that stable steady states occupying generic channels or annuli and stagnate must have islands. Additionally, when the domain is close to symmetric, we characterize the size of the islands, showing that they scale as the square root of the boundary’s deviation from flat. Taken together, these results show that dynamically stable laminar flows are structurally unstable whenever they stagnate. 1. Introduction In this paper, we are interested in the existence of islands (regions of contractible streamlines) for steady fluid flow confined in periodic domains (1.1) D_{G,H}:=\{(x,y):\,x\in\mathbb{T},\,G(x)\leq y\leq H(x)\}. Here, G,H\in C^{2,\alpha}(\mathbb{T},\mathbb{R}) for \alpha\in(0,1) are any two boundary defining functions, with G(x)<H(x) , for all x\in\mathbb{T} . The steady incompressible Euler equations (perfect fluids) read (1.2) \begin{cases}&\nabla^{\perp}\psi\cdot\nabla\omega=0\qquad\text{in}\qquad D_{G,H}\\ &\Delta\psi=\omega\qquad\qquad\ \ \text{in}\qquad D_{G,H}\\ &\partial_{\tau}\psi=0\qquad\qquad\ \ \text{on}\qquad\partial D_{G,H}\end{cases} and \partial_{\tau} denotes the derivative tangent to \partial D_{G,H} . There is a one parameter freedom in the above formulation which is fixed by prescribing \int_{\partial D_{G,H}^{\mathsf{t}op}}\partial_{n}\psi{\rm d}\ell=\gamma where \gamma\in\mathbb{R} is a prescribed circulation, which is preserved on dynamical solutions in view of the Kelvin theorem. The circulation condition determines the cohomological character of the solution, e.g. the projection of \psi onto harmonic functions on the domain D_{G,H} . See [ 7 ] . A special but important class of solutions to ( 1.2 ) are those with a specified functional relationship between vorticity and streamfunction. Specifically, for any F\in C^{1} , and c_{G},c_{H}\in\mathbb{R} , solutions \psi to the following semi-linear elliptic problem (1.3) \begin{cases}\Delta\psi=F(\psi)&\text{ in }D_{G,H},\\ \psi(x,H(x))=c_{H}&\text{ for }x\in\mathbb{T},\\ \psi(x,G(x))=c_{G}&\text{ for }x\in\mathbb{T},\end{cases} give rise to stationary configurations of the Euler equations in D_{G,H} , for some circulation \gamma . We are interested in the structure of these steady states. In some cases, their streamlines \{\psi={\rm const}\} laminate the domain (see [ 4 ] and also [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 9 ] ). In others, islands of contractible streamlines must exist (see [ 8 ] and also [ 6 , 16 ] ). The purpose of this paper is to show that stable stationary solutions \psi of the Euler equations confined to generic domains D_{G,H} possess islands. Theorem 1.1 . Fix \alpha\in(0,1) and F\in C^{4}(\mathbb{R};\mathbb{R}) satisfying F^{\prime}>-\lambda_{1} , where \lambda_{1} is the first eigenvalue of the Dirichlet Laplacian in D_{G,H} . There exists an open dense set \mathcal{B}\subset(C^{2,\alpha}(\mathbb{T}))^{2} so that for each (G,H)\in\mathcal{B} , any solution \psi to ( 1.3 ) on D_{G,H} having stagnation points possess islands. Thus, either the flow is laminar because the flow is non-stagnant [ 4 ] , or – if stagnation sets exist – then generically they must be centers of islands separated by hyperbolic stagnation points. We remark that the complement of \mathcal{B} is non-empty. Indeed, for any analytic F and analytic non-flat non-contractible curve \Gamma_{0} in \mathbb{T}\times\mathbb{R} , one can produce, by means of Cauchy-Kovalevskaya, laminar solutions \psi to ( 1.3 ) in D_{\Gamma_{G},\Gamma_{H}} such that \nabla\psi=0 on \Gamma_{0} and \Gamma_{G} and \Gamma_{H} are non-flat level sets of \psi_{0} . Such a domain may be very thin but nevertheless provides examples of channels which support laminar flows with essentially any geometry. See also [ 10 , Theorem 4.12] for such a construction for special F of finite regularity. An important class of steady states for which Theorem 1.1 applies are Arnold stable steady states (see [ 2 , 1 ] ) and highlights the drastic consequences of small boundary perturbations in stable fluid equilibria. Indeed, while any Arnold stable steady state in \mathbb{T}\times[-1,1] is a shear flow with closed non-contractible fluid trajectories, we show that arbitrarily small disturbances of the boundary induce a break in the streamline topology of Arnold stable equilibria with the appearance of islands. Note also that the existence of a stagnation point is guaranteed by Poincare’s last geometric theorem as soon as the boundary velocities point in different directions. The ideas presented in this paper allow us also to conclude the appearance of islands for steady Euler solutions in generic annular domains posed in \mathbb{T}\times\mathbb{R} or also in \mathbb{R}^{2} , no longer assuming that the boundaries are graphs in the periodic variable. Namely, steady Euler solutions that stagnate on generic annular domains must have islands. This extension is described briefly at the end of § 2 . In some perturbative settings, we can understand more about the structure of the set \mathcal{B} . For instance, we consider small perturbations of the straight channel (1.4) G=-1+\varepsilon g,\quad H=1+\varepsilon h. If furthermore c_{H}=c_{G} , then the set \mathcal{B} locally contains (1.5) \mathcal{B}^{\prime}=\{(-1+\varepsilon g,1+\varepsilon h)\ :(g,h)\in(C^{2,\alpha}(\mathbb{T}))^{2},\quad h^{\prime}(x)+g^{\prime}(x)\not\equiv 0\}, which is clearly open and dense in (C^{2,\alpha}(\mathbb{T}))^{2} nearby (G,H)=(-1,1) . Once the existence of islands is ensured, a natural problem is to quantify their size in terms of the size of the boundary perturbation, which is of order \varepsilon . Since islands appear nearby local critical points of \psi_{\varepsilon} , they can be found to be arbitrarily small. Instead, we are interested in describing the maximal size they can reach in terms of \varepsilon . This is the purpose of our next result, which describes the maximal size of islands appearing in perturbations of the periodic channel D_{-1,1}=\mathbb{T}\times(-1,1) . Theorem 1.2 . Under the assumptions of Theorem 1.1 , there exists an open and dense set \mathcal{B}_{0}\subset\mathcal{B}^{\prime} so that for all (g,h)\in\mathcal{B}_{0} there exists \varepsilon_{*}>0 such that the solution \psi_{\varepsilon} to ( 1.3 ) in D_{-1+\varepsilon g,1+\varepsilon h} possess islands whose maximal height is at least of order \sqrt{\varepsilon} , for all 0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_{*} . The set \mathcal{B}_{0} contains boundary perturbations for which solutions to some elliptic equation have non-degenerate local maxima, and its precise description is postponed until Section 4 . We now explain the heuristic reason for the generic existence of islands. Consider any steady Euler solution u=\nabla^{\perp}\psi in D_{G,H} which has an interior critical point. If \psi does not have islands, then it is laminar and by Proposition A.2 , its set of critical points is connected and belongs to some closed non-contractible level set \Gamma_{0} . In particular, \nabla\psi=0 and \psi=c on \Gamma_{0} . If \omega=F(\psi) where F is analytic, then \psi is uniquely determined by \Gamma_{0} by the Cauchy-Kovalevskaya theorem. See [ 10 ] where such a construction is carried out to obtain laminar steady Euler solutions emanating from a singular streamline. Since the level sets of \psi are assumed to foliate the domain, they must do so monotonically on each side of \Gamma_{0} and at some point they must meet the top and bottom boundaries. If the boundaries do not coincide with level sets of \psi , then