Estimating infall times of galaxies around clusters: how accurately can it be done with observational data?

Haoran Dou, Heng Yu · 2025

Read Estimating infall times of galaxies around clusters: how accurately can it be done with observational data? by Haoran Dou, Heng Yu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17775.txt.

Introduction

Haoran Dou and Heng Yu test how well astronomers can date a galaxy's fall into a cluster, in this 2025 paper. A galaxy's surroundings shape how it grows, and the time since it fell in matters for reading that story. Observers infer the date from a chart of position and speed.

The pair built the same chart from a large cosmic simulation where true dates are known. They then graded four common methods plus a simple straight-line split. All methods missed by more than two and a half billion years on average. Accuracy improved for calm clusters and when two estimates were joined, but a hard floor set by the chart's own spread remains.

Catalog record

CREATORHaoran Dou, Heng Yu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17775

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimating infall times of galaxies around clusters: how accurately can it be done with observational data? Haoran Dou, Heng Yu Abstract Context. The environment plays a crucial role in galaxy evolution, particularly for galaxies infalling into clusters. Accurately estimating the infall times of galaxies from observations can significantly enhance our understanding of the environmental effects on galaxy evolution. Aims. This paper aims to evaluate existing methods for estimating infall times via the R − V R-V diagram, explore possible strategies to improve accuracy in estimating infall times, and discuss fundamental limitations. Methods. We utilize a TNG300-1 simulation and construct the R − V R-V diagram that is directly comparable to the observations. Using the same dataset, we systematically compare four commonly used methods, including the projected radii, caustic profiles, and two discrete methods. A simple linear partition is also considered as a reference. Results. Each method exhibits distinct characteristics. While the linear partition slightly outperforms other methods, all methods suffer from limited accuracy ( ≳ 2.6 \gtrsim 2.6 Gyr), constrained by the intrinsic dispersion ( 2.53 2.53 Gyr) of infall times in the R − V R-V diagram. Given this limit, we explore two potential approaches that can improve accuracy: (1) the infall time dispersion is smaller in more dynamically relaxed clusters, and (2) employing two estimates of infall times instead of one reduces the dispersion to ≲ 1.5 \lesssim 1.5 Gyr. We further demonstrate that the intrinsic dispersion primarily arises from orbital overlap: galaxies in different orbital phases overlap with each other in the R − V R-V diagram and thus appear indistinguishable. Conclusions. Orbital overlap fundamentally limits the accuracy of infall time estimation. The linear partition approach could be a simple and robust estimation. 1 Introduction The evolution of galaxies is one of the fundamental questions in astrophysics. It is widely known that the environment plays an important role in galactic evolution ( Dressler 1980 ; Dressler et al. 1997 ; Goto et al. 2003 ; Kauffmann et al. 2004 ; Alpaslan et al. 2015 ; Chen et al. 2017 ; Taylor et al. 2023 ; Shi et al. 2024 ; Zheng et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Galaxies residing in denser environments, such as clusters and groups, tend to be red, gas-depleted, metal-rich, of early-type morphology, and with lower star formation rates (SFRs), in contrast to field galaxies, which typically exhibit opposite properties. Tracing the infall process of galaxies into clusters offers a promising way to understand how the environment drives galaxy evolution. In simulations, full six-dimensional kinematic information and complete motion histories allow for accurate reconstruction of the orbits of galaxies ( Mahajan et al. 2011 ; Oman et al. 2013 ; Oman & Hudson 2016 ; Rhee et al. 2017 ; Pasquali et al. 2019 ; Rhee et al. 2020 , e.g.,) . However, observational data provide only three dimensions of kinematic information: two projected positions on the sky and one line-of-sight (LOS) velocity. Therefore, the galaxy infall process is commonly analysed via the R-V diagram, also referred to as the projected phase space (PPS) in simulation studies. This diagram comprises the projected cluster-centric radius ( R_{\rm 2D} ) and the LOS velocity relative to the cluster centre ( V_{\rm los} ). Several studies have explored the potential of the R-V diagram for tracing the infall process and have proposed various methods for estimating galaxy infall times. Noble et al. 2013 ; Noble et al. 2016 employed caustic profiles to delineate regions corresponding to different infall stages. Oman et al. 2013 and Oman & Hudson 2016 used the Multidark Run 1 dark matter-only simulation to construct orbital libraries and calculated probability density functions of infall times at each location in the diagram. Rhee et al. 2017 divided the R-V diagram into five zones designed to maximize the fraction of galaxies belonging to a specific infall population in each zone. Pasquali et al. 2019 introduced a set of quadratic curves to partition the R-V diagram into eight zones, achieving improved alignment with the mean infall time distribution compared with caustic profiles. These methods have been widely adopted in observational studies ( Kim et al. 2023 ; Sampaio et al. 2021 ; Brambila et al. 2023 ; Oxland et al. 2024 ; Sampaio et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . However, these methods have not been systematically evaluated under the same conditions. It remains unclear which method provides the most reasonable estimates of infall times or to what extent infall times can be accurately estimated from observational R-V diagrams. Although some works have reported accuracy levels, such as 2.58 Gyr in Oman et al. 2013 and 1.49\sim 2.60 Gyr in Pasquali et al. 2019 , there is no easy way to combine the intrinsic uncertainties with the observational data. This study aims to address that question through a consistent and comparative evaluation of different methods while also exploring possible improvements. The simulation data used for this study are presented in Section 2 , followed by a detailed description of the infall time distribution in the R-V diagram in Section 3 . Section 4 compares four commonly used methods for infall time estimation alongside a simple linear partition method for reference. In Section 5 , we explore possible approaches to improve accuracy, and in particular, we discuss the orbital overlap issue that contributes to the main dispersion in Section 5.3 . Finally, we summarize the results in Section 6 . 2 Data Figure 1: Number distributions of the galaxies in the phase space and the R-V diagram at five different lookback times. The vertical lines in the leftmost panels represent the 3R_{200} boundary for member galaxies. 2.1 Simulations IllustrisTNG (hereafter, TNG) is a suite of large-volume, cosmological, gravo-magnetohydrodynamic simulations that includes a comprehensive model for galaxy formation physics ( Springel et al. 2018 ; Pillepich et al. 2018 ; Naiman et al. 2018 ; Nelson et al. 2018 ; Marinacci et al. 2018 ) . TNG 300 has the largest volume ( {205\ h^{-1}{\rm Mpc}}^{3} ) of TNG, and TNG 300-1 has the highest resolution level of TNG 300, including initial 2\times 2500^{3} particles, with a dark matter cell mass of 4.0\times 10^{7}h^{-1}{\rm M}_{\odot} , and a baryonic matter cell mass of 7.6\times 10^{6}h^{-1}{\rm M}_{\odot} . The public release of TNG 300 provides 100 snapshots between z=20 and z=0 , and a group catalogue is provided for each snapshot. These catalogues contain halos (groups or clusters) identified with the standard Friends-of-Friends algorithm ( Davis et al. 1985 ) , as well as subhalos (galaxies) identified with the Subfind algorithm ( Springel et al. 2001 ; Dolag et al. 2009 ) . The merger histories of subhalos are constructed via SubLink ( Rodriguez-Gomez et al. 2015 ) and LHaloTree ( Springel et al. 2005 ) . Hereafter, we use ”clusters” and ”galaxies” to refer to halos and subhalos, respectively. 2.2 Cluster sample We select clusters from the redshift z=0 snapshot, applying a lower mass threshold of M_{200}>10^{14}{\rm M}_{\odot} . As Rhee et al. 2017 demonstrated that galaxy behaviour in the R-V diagram shows negligible dependence on cluster mass, we exclude systems with M_{200}<10^{14}{\rm M}_{\odot} , which are typically classified as ’groups’. To minimize the impact of cluster mergers, which can

Read the complete text