Feasible Action Space Reduction for Quantifying Causal Responsibility in Continuous Spatial Interactions

Ashwin George, Luciano Cavalcante Siebert, David Abbink, Arkady Zgonnikov · 2025

Read Feasible Action Space Reduction for Quantifying Causal Responsibility in Continuous Spatial Interactions by Ashwin George, Luciano Cavalcante Siebert, David Abbink, Arkady Zgonnikov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17739.txt.

Introduction

When two drivers squeeze through a narrow gap, who caused what? George, Siebert, Abbink, and Zgonnikov build a measure of causal responsibility for such space-sharing encounters. Their earlier version worked on grid worlds with step-by-step choices. Real driving, though, flows through continuous space, so they extend the measure to smooth action spaces.

The idea is to compare what an agent did with the full set of actions it could feasibly have taken, and see how the outcome would change. The team shows the measure at work on classic conflict scenes. It can assign blame after an event and also guide decisions before one happens. The authors aim the tool at designers of self-driving systems and robots that must share space with people, and at anyone judging responsibility after close calls.

Catalog record

CREATORAshwin George, Luciano Cavalcante Siebert, David Abbink, Arkady Zgonnikov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17739

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Feasible Action Space Reduction for Quantifying Causal Responsibility in Continuous Spatial Interactions Ashwin George, Luciano Cavalcante Siebert, David Abbink, Arkady Zgonnikov Abstract Understanding the causal influence of one agent on another agent is crucial for safely deploying artificially intelligent systems such as automated vehicles and mobile robots into human-inhabited environments. Existing models of causal responsibility deal with simplified abstractions of scenarios with discrete actions, thus, limiting real-world use when understanding responsibility in spatial interactions. Based on the assumption that spatially interacting agents are embedded in a scene and must follow an action at each instant, Feasible Action-Space Reduction (FeAR) was proposed as a metric for causal responsibility in a grid-world setting with discrete actions. Since real-world interactions involve continuous action spaces, this paper proposes a formulation of the FeAR metric for measuring causal responsibility in space-continuous interactions. We illustrate the utility of the metric in prototypical space-sharing conflicts, and showcase its applications for analysing backward-looking responsibility and in estimating forward-looking responsibility to guide agent decision making. Our results highlight the potential of the FeAR metric for designing and engineering artificial agents, as well as for assessing the responsibility of agents around humans. keywords Responsibility, AI-Ethics, Multi-Agent Systems, Automated Vehicles, Human-Robot Interaction 1 Introduction Automated agents interacting with humans in safety-critical scenarios must behave responsibly and in accordance with ethical principles [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Measuring how responsibility is distributed in such human-agent interactions is crucial for the users, designers, policy-makers, and regulators of automated systems to ensure that these systems are beneficial for the society [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . In particular, if artificial agents could quantify responsibility, they would be able to reason better about their behaviours in terms of responsibilities towards other agents [ 8 , 9 ] . Backward-looking responsibility, which concerns the responsibility of agents for past actions, is useful for reinforcing desirable behaviours of automated agents. Forward-looking responsibility, which concerns responsibility of agents for future actions, is useful for automated agents while planning actions. Among multiple established notions of responsibility [ 10 ] , causal responsibility is especially relevant for human-agent interaction. Specifically, causal responsibility can be a prerequisite for other forms of responsibility like liability, blame, praise, and moral responsibility [ 11 , 10 , 12 ] , so quantifying it can aid both humans and artificial agents to reason about responsibility. In this work, we aim to define a metric for causal responsibility that is applicable to spatial interactions. Responsibility-aware navigation in mixed traffic (where humans and automated vehicles share the same space) has garnered much interest in recent years [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] . Works on responsibility sensitive navigation have incorporated a term for responsibility in the cost function of the automation which is either derived from traffic rules, physical constraints and risk to other road users [ 15 ] , or is learned from data [ 14 , 16 ] . These pragmatic approaches to model responsibility are rooted in existing traffic rules and how humans currently behave in spatial interactions, and, the introduction of automated driving systems with different sensing, cognitive and actuation capabilities necessitate the creation of a new ethics for transportation [ 6 ] . In this direction, the responsibility-sensitive safety (RSS) approach [ 13 , 17 ] formalises rules based on “duty of care” and prescribes “proper responses” for all vehicles, which, if followed would ensure safety. As per RSS, agents that deviate from their “proper response” are held responsible for collisions. These models of responsibility do not explicitly consider causality which is an important condition for ascribing responsibility, especially in legal settings [ 11 ] . As such, there is a need for fundamentally rooted models of responsibility that can be applied to spatial navigation. In the domain of formal reasoning, several computational frameworks relating to 1) the enforcement of an outcome, 2) being pivotal for an outcome or, 3) affecting the probability of an outcome have been used to operationalise causal responsibility. Logical frameworks related to the capacity of agents and groups of agents to cause or preclude an outcome have been used to evaluate whether agents are causally responsible for outcomes [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] and to determine to what degree they are responsible [ 21 , 22 ] . Another approach to model causal responsibility uses counterfactual reasoning to discern whether an agent’s action is pivotal for an outcome — that is, whether the outcome would have happened if the agent had not performed the action [ 23 , 24 ] . Some of these approaches also use probabilistic reasoning about how distant an agent’s action is from being pivotal for an outcome to quantify responsibility of agents and groups of agents [ 23 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 ] . Furthermore, specifically in the context of interactions between humans and artificial agents, information-theoretic metrics have been used to quantify causal responsibility of humans [ 30 , 31 ] . The aforementioned formal methods can deal with general descriptions of events, but this expressivity comes at a higher computational cost which limits their application to relatively simple cases with few actions and states. Spatial interactions, on the other hand, involve continuous action and state spaces, which necessitates the formulation of a new metric for causal responsibility. Thus, there is a gap between the more fundamental but computationally expensive models of causal responsibility and the more pragmatic approaches to model responsibility in spatial interactions that lack fundamental rigour. A recent approach to bridge this gap proposed Fe asible A ction-Space R eduction ( FeAR ) as a metric for causal responsibility in spatial interactions [ 32 ] . However, that work is limited to toy scenarios with discrete and finite action spaces, restricting its applicability to real-life human-agent interactions 1 1 1 For a detailed discussion on existing models of responsibility, please see Section 5 . Contributions: Here we (i) develop the Feasible Action-Space Reduction (FeAR) metric for causal responsibility in spatial interactions with continuous action spaces , (ii) evaluate the properties of the FeAR metric in case studies representing prototypical space-sharing conflicts , and (iii) illustrate the application of FeAR for analysing backward-looking responsibility in past interactions and estimating forward-looking responsibility for future actions of agents . 2 Feasible Action-Space Reduction (FeAR) The FeAR metric is based on the intuition that agents that reduce the feasible action space of another agent have a degree of causal responsibility for the trajectory of the latter. Consider a robot cutting across the path of a pedestrian and the pedestrian slowing down to make room for the robot (as in Fig. 1 ). The action of the robot reduces the feasible alternatives available to the pedestrian and we intuitively feel that the robot is causally responsible for the trajectory of the pedestrian. In this section, we elaborate how we model spatial interactions ( Section 2.1 ) and calculate the feasible action space of agents ( Section 2.2 ). We use move de rigueur to account for normative expectations ( Section 2.3 ) while computing the FeAR metric ( Section 2.4 ). (a) The interaction. (b) Bounding boxes

Read the complete text