Experimental study of multiple-shot unitary channels discrimination using the IBM Q computers
Adam Bílek 1,2, Jan Hlisnikovský ∗,1,2, Tomáš Bezděk 1, Ryszard Kukulski 2, Paulina Lewandowska 2 · 2025
Read Experimental study of multiple-shot unitary channels discrimination using the IBM Q computers by Adam Bílek 1,2, Jan Hlisnikovský ∗,1,2, Tomáš Bezděk 1, Ryszard Kukulski 2, Paulina Lewandowska 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17731.txt.
Introduction
Adam Bílek and co-authors run tests on a real quantum chip to tell two quantum channels apart. The work dates to 2025. Such tell-apart tasks with black boxes show up a lot in quantum work. The team used many shots per call on a named IBM chip.
Past math work sets how well the calls can be split in a clean world. Chip data fell short of those clean bounds in set ways. Deep chains of steps hurt the task, and so did chains that wove the bits too much. Builds that kept weave low and depth in bounds held up best to chip noise.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adam Bílek 1,2, Jan Hlisnikovský ∗,1,2, Tomáš Bezděk 1, Ryszard Kukulski 2, Paulina Lewandowska 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17731
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Experimental study of multiple-shot unitary channels discrimination using the IBM Q computers Adam Bílek 1,2, Jan Hlisnikovský ∗,1,2, Tomáš Bezděk 1, Ryszard Kukulski 2, Paulina Lewandowska 2 Abstract 1. Abstract Tasks involving black boxes appear frequently in quantum computer science. An example that has been deeply studied is quantum channel discrimination. In this work, we study the discrimination between two quantum unitary channels in the multiple-shot scenario. We challenge the theoretical results concerning the probability of correct discrimination with the results collected from experiments performed on the IBM Quantum processor Brisbane. Our analysis shows that neither too deep quantum circuits nor circuits that create too much entanglement are suitable for the discrimination task. We conclude that circuit architectures which minimize entanglement overhead while preserving discrimination power are significantly more resilient to hardware noise if their depth does not overpass threshold value. 2. Introduction In the last decade, quantum computing has become a reality. Quantum algorithms of increasing degree of complexity are currently being implemented on more and more complex quantum devices. In effect, high-quality solutions to some real-world problems are expected to be forthcoming soon. This situation motivates the need for the certification and benchmarking of various quantum devices [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . The discrimination task of quantum operators constitutes one of the certification methods and quality metrics for benchmarking quantum architectures [ 4 ] . The theoretical background of the quantum discrimination task has been widely developed. The primary task of discrimination involves a one-shot scenario of discrimination between quantum operators. We can imagine that we have an unknown quantum device, a black-box. The only information we have is that it performs one of two quantum operators, say \mathcal{T} and \mathcal{S} . Our goal is two-fold. First, we want to determine the highest possible probability of correct guessing. Secondly, we need to devise an optimal strategy that maximizes the probability of success. The problem of single-shot discrimination of quantum states was solved analytically by Helstrom a few decades ago in [ 5 , 6 ] . The authors have calculated the probability of correct discrimination between two quantum states using the notion of a trace norm. Next, there are many modifications of the origin problem for quantum states that were also considered [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . For the discrimination tasks of the quantum channels [ 6 ] , the probability of success of the discrimination can be formulated by the diamond norm [ 12 , 13 ] , which can be computed by semidefinite programming [ 14 , 12 ] . However, for increasing the dimension of quantum channels in the diamond norm, the size of the problem does not allow efficient computation [ 15 ] . In general, for general quantum channels, entanglement is necessary for optimal discrimination [ 6 ] . The exception is, for example, the discrimination task between unitary channels [ 6 , 16 ] . Furthermore, the probability of correct discrimination between two unitary channels can be expressed in the notion of the numerical range [ 17 ] . The discrimination tasks for general quantum measurements, von Neumann measurements, or SIC POVMs were also considered in the literature [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Lastly, the theory of an indefinite causal structure is one of the attractive topics. This approach uses the notion of process matrices [ 24 , 25 ] , which can be seen as a generalization of quantum combs. The single-shot discrimination of the process matrices was introduced [ 26 ] . What if we have multiple copies of quantum operators? The most general discrimination approach is known as adaptive strategy [ 27 ] . This strategy can be described by using the term quantum combs. Here, we assume freedom in choosing the setting of quantum operations and any processing between them. In addition, numerical investigation of quantum channel discrimination showed that using indefinite causal order, we can achieve greater success discrimination [ 28 , 29 ] . However, determining an optimal strategy to realize such tasks is a significant challenge in practice. This is why we often limit ourselves to parallel [ 30 ] and sequential [ 31 ] schemes. The parallel scheme assumes N copies of a given quantum operation distributed over N entangled systems and final measurement with no additional processing, whereas the sequential scheme assumes the implementation of N copies of the quantum operation on one system, allowing additional processing between them. One of the first theoretical results was the study of discrimination of multipartite unitary operations [ 28 ] . The authors were shown that perfect discrimination can be achieved using a parallel scheme [ 30 ] . Simultaneously, it is also possible to create a perfect discrimination scheme of unitary channels without creating the entanglement with the auxiliary system [ 32 ] . It can be done by using the sequential approach and specific processing at the end of the circuit. On the other hand, for general quantum channels, neither parallel nor sequential strategy guarantees optimal solutions [ 33 , 34 ] . The advantage of adaptive strategies became apparent for a task concerning entanglement-breaking channels [ 33 ] . The discrimination tasks in which adaptive scenarios were also investigated in [ 31 ] , [ 35 , 21 ] . In the work [ 36 ] , the authors have formulated the necessary and sufficient conditions under which quantum channels can be perfectly discriminated, while in [ 21 ] , the authors have formulated conditions for the perfect discrimination of two measurements. Furthermore, in [ 37 ] , the authors have shown that any possible adaptive method does not offer any advantage over the parallel scheme for von Neumann measurements. One of the first experimental results for the parallel and sequential discrimination scheme of unitary channels was presented [ 38 ] . In the era of NISQ devices, we need to take into account certain limitations. Due to the existing decoherence, sequential schemes could not be practical for larger numbers of copies. At the same time, parallel schemes for NISQ architectures are also not possible to implement because of the limited number of qubits. Perhaps intermediate schemes called sequentially-paralleled will prove to solve both of these obstacles. This scheme assumes that we have N=w\cdot d , copies of a quantum operator, where k and l are natural numbers. The sequentially-paralleled scheme of width w and depth d consists of d applications of w copies of the quantum operator applied simultaneously to the quantum state. The initial state \rho evolves through these layers, combining parallelism within each layer and a sequential structure across layers. In general, one could consider incorporating additional intermediate processing operations between layers. In this work, we present a comprehensive study of various scenarios of multiple-shot discrimination of quantum unitary channels. We consider parallel, sequential, and sequentially-paralleled quantum networks for discrimination between two qubit unitary channels. We challenge the theoretical results concerning the probability of correct discrimination with the results collected from experiments performed on the IBM Quantum processor Brisbane. Based on several examples, the analysis shows that neither too deep quantum