Chase-and-Run and Chirality in Nonlocal Models of Pattern Formation

Thomas Jun Jewell, Andrew L. Krause, Philip K. Maini, Eamonn A. Gaffney · 2025

Read Chase-and-Run and Chirality in Nonlocal Models of Pattern Formation by Thomas Jun Jewell, Andrew L. Krause, Philip K. Maini, Eamonn A. Gaffney (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17372.txt.

Introduction

Thomas Jewell and co-authors model pursuers and fleers that do not run straight in this 2025 paper. Chase-and-run motion appears in predator and prey, and in cells moving during growth. Often the runner veers at an angle, and the veer favors one side, a trait called chirality.

The team extended models where each mover reacts to others at a distance, letting the chase angle vary freely. A sideways bias could spark patterns, calm wobbling, or create rotating pulses of chasers and runners. It could also mix the two groups or pull them apart. Their math explains some effects but misses others, marking where new theory is needed.

Catalog record

CREATORThomas Jun Jewell, Andrew L. Krause, Philip K. Maini, Eamonn A. Gaffney
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17372

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Chase-and-Run and Chirality in Nonlocal Models of Pattern Formation Thomas Jun Jewell, Andrew L. Krause, Philip K. Maini, Eamonn A. Gaffney Abstract Chase-and-run dynamics, in which one population pursues another that flees from it, are found throughout nature, from predator-prey interactions in ecosystems to the collective motion of cells during development. Intriguingly, in many of these systems, the movement is not straight; instead, ‘runners’ veer off at an angle from their pursuers. This angled movement often exhibits a consistent left–right asymmetry, known as lateralisation or chirality. Inspired by such phenomena in zebrafish skin patterns and evasive animal motion, we explore how chirality shapes the emergence of patterns in nonlocal (integro-differential) advection-diffusion models. We extend such models to allow movement at arbitrary angles, uncovering a rich landscape of behaviours. We find that chirality can enhance pattern formation, suppress oscillations, and give rise to entirely new dynamical structures, such as rotating pulses of chasers and runners. We also uncover how chase-and-run dynamics can cause populations to mix or separate. Through linear stability analysis, we identify physical mechanisms that drive some of these effects, whilst also exposing striking limitations of this theory in capturing more complex dynamics. Our findings suggest that chirality could have roles in ecological and cellular patterning beyond simply breaking left-right symmetry. keywords chirality, chase-and-run, nonlocal, integro-differential equation, pattern formation, left-right asymmetry, behavioural lateralisation 1 Introduction Across biology, organisms and cells alike move in response to others around them, giving rise to striking population-level patterns. From territorial ranges ( Potts and Lewis 2014 ) to swarming locusts ( Bazazi et al. 2008 ) to the development of tissues and organs ( Hillen and Painter 2009 ; Armstrong et al. 2006 ) , these dynamics emerge from simple rules of interaction. Theoretical models can bridge these scales, revealing when and how individual-level behaviours give rise to macroscopic structure. Yet our understanding is far from complete. Even between just two species, there is a wide variety of possible interaction dynamics. For example, movement-inducing interactions between different species can be mutually attracting, mutually avoidant, or ‘chase-and-run’, in which individuals of the first species are attracted towards individuals of the second species, whilst individuals of the second species are repelled away from individuals of the first. Chase-and-run dynamics, also called ‘pursue-and-avoid’, ‘cops-and-robbers’, or ‘chase-and-escape’, are often studied in the context of ecosystems with predators and prey ( Moore and Biewener 2015 ) . One example includes North American elk, which have been observed to alter their browsing patterns and spatial distribution to avoid wolves ( White et al. 1998 ; Ripple and Larsen 2000 ) . Over the last two decades, ecologists have adopted the idea that predator-avoidant movement in prey and prey-seeking movement in predators can drive spatial patterning across a landscape ( Gaynor et al. 2019 ) . Additionally, chase-and-run dynamics can occur at cellular scales, where they are also thought to contribute to pattern formation. Examples include stripe formation in zebrafish ( Yamanaka and Kondo 2014 ) and cell migration for neural crest development ( Theveneau et al. 2013 ) . Szabó and Mayor 2015 argue that chase-and-run may be a common mechanism present in many cellular pattern forming processes, possibly including kidney morphogenesis, development of the lateral line in zebrafish, and cancer invasion. In response to this growing interest, Painter et al. 2024 recently studied chase-and-run interactions within a nonlocal advection-diffusion model. They showed that these interactions can generate a rich range of behaviour, including stationary patterns, spatio-temporal oscillations, and ‘population chase-and-run’ – where an aggregate of chasers continually chases an aggregate of runners. This work is part of a broader field examining nonlocal advection-diffusion models, which use integro-partial differential equations to describe agents that interact across a distance to induce movement. Such models have been applied to various biological phenomena, including swarms of animals, which rely on visual cues across a distance ( Mogilner and Edelstein-Keshet 1999 ) ; cell aggregation, where adhesion occurs across the length of a cell diameter and longer ranged interactions can be mediated by pseudopodia ( Armstrong et al. 2006 ; Carrillo et al. 2019 ; Painter et al. 2015 ; Jewell et al. 2023 ) ; and territorial patterns formed by animals communicating through scent markings across an ecosystem ( Potts and Lewis 2019 ) . For a recent review of these models, see Painter et al. 2024 . An assumption present in all the models mentioned above is that agents only move directly towards or directly away from each other – advection is only induced parallel to their separation or parallel to their concentration gradient. What happens when we relax this assumption? What happens when interactions generate advection at some general angle from the source of the signal? These questions are relevant to chase-and-run mechanisms within both ecology and developmental biology. In animal behaviour, escape responses often involve movement at an angle rather than directly away from a threat. In many vertebrates, such behaviour can exhibit consistent left–right biases, a phenomenon known as ‘behavioural lateralisation’. Such asymmetries are well-documented in fish species, both at the individual and population level, and extend beyond escape responses to include foraging, social interactions, and mating behaviours ( Miletto Petrazzini et al. 2020 ; Gobbo et al. 2025 ) . For example, Cantalupo et al. 1995 observed that individual immature girardinus falcatus displayed a preference for escaping either rightwards or leftwards, with rightwards bias being more common. Ghirlanda and Vallortigara 2004 suggest such population-level bias could offer an evolutionary advantage by improving coordination. In our work, we will use the term ‘chirality’ to describe consistent left–right asymmetries in movement. A notable example of chiral movement from developmental biology is that of the pigment cells of zebrafish skin. The characteristic stripes of zebrafish are thought to arise from interactions between pigment cells, which migrate in response to contact with pseudopodia from other pigment cells ( Kondo et al. 2021 ) . In vitro experiments by Yamanaka and Kondo 2014 showed that melanophores (black pigment cells) move away from xanthophores (yellow pigment cells), whilst xanthophores move towards melanophores. Interestingly, their movements are not parallel to their separation. Melanophores move consistently anticlockwise at an average angle of roughly 70^{\circ} relative to xanthophores, whilst xanthophores move clockwise roughly 20^{\circ} relative to melanophores. Fig. 1 illustrates this chiral chase-and-run mechanism. The function of chirality in this cellular system and its impact on self-organisation remains an open question. In some biological systems, cell chirality can lead to the emergence of left-right asymmetry in a body plan ( Nonaka et al. 1998 ; Shibazaki et al. 2004 ; Taniguchi et al. 2011 ) ; however, zebrafish stripes are essentially left-right symmetric ( Yamanaka and Kondo 2021 ) . Yamanaka and Kondo 2021 argue that chirality is a property common to many cell types and may have functions beyond creating an asymmetric body plan. They further hypothesise that chirality may contribute to the alignment of parallel zebrafish stripes, although this has not been tested with experiment or modelling. Models by Chen et al. 2012 have shown that anisotropy relative to fixed directions on a domain is sufficient for creating aligned stripes rather than labyrinthine patterns. However, this type of anisotropy is distinct from the chirality

Read the complete text