Fast and Accurate Charge Transfer Excitations via Nested Aufbau Suppressed Coupled Cluster

Harrison Tuckman, Eric Neuscamman · 2025

Read Fast and Accurate Charge Transfer Excitations via Nested Aufbau Suppressed Coupled Cluster by Harrison Tuckman, Eric Neuscamman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17299.txt.

Introduction

Tuckman and Neuscamman speed up calculations of charge transfer excitations in twenty twenty-five. Charge transfer, where an electron moves between parts of a molecule, is hard to model well. A coupled cluster method with orbital relaxation is accurate but scales poorly. Large molecules in real environments strain it further.

They derive a cheaper second order perturbation variant of the method. A small coupled cluster treatment is nested inside it to restore accuracy. Formal cost drops sharply compared with the parent method. An early implementation handles about one hundred atoms on a single node. Errors in excitation energies were typically below a tenth of an electron volt. That beats a standard method of higher cost by a clear margin.

Catalog record

CREATORHarrison Tuckman, Eric Neuscamman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17299

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fast and Accurate Charge Transfer Excitations via Nested Aufbau Suppressed Coupled Cluster Harrison Tuckman, Eric Neuscamman Abstract Modeling charge transfer well can require treating post-excitation orbital relaxations and handling medium to large molecules in realistic environments. By combining a state-specific correlation treatment with such orbital relaxations, Aufbau suppressed coupled cluster has proven accurate for charge transfer, but, like many coupled cluster methods, it struggles with large system sizes. We derive a low-cost Aufbau suppressed second order perturbation theory and show that, by nesting a small coupled cluster treatment inside of it, computational cost and scaling are reduced while accuracy is maintained. Formal asymptotic costs are dropped from iterative N 6 N^{6} to non-iterative N 5 N^{5} plus iterative N 3 N^{3} , and we test an initial implementation that can handle about 100 atoms and 800 orbitals on a single computational node. Charge transfer excitation energy errors are typically below 0.1 eV, with an average 0.25 eV improvement over N 6 N^{6} -cost equation of motion coupled cluster with singles and doubles. Preprint: AIP/123-QED Charge transfer (CT) excitations are at the crux of photochemical efficacy across a wide range of current scientific interests, including photovoltaics, [ 1 ] photosynthetic complexes, [ 2 ] and photocatalysis. [ 3 ] However, traditional linear response approaches such as time dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] and equation of motion coupled cluster (EOM-CCSD) [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] produce significant errors for these excitations [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] due in part to their limited ability to capture nonlinear orbital relaxation effects. [ 16 , 17 ] The challenge of modeling CT is further exacerbated by system size: these excitations often occur in medium to large donor-bridge-acceptor molecules [ 18 ] and can be strongly influenced by solvent and other environmental effects. [ 19 ] To model charge transfer well, a method must capture orbital relaxations and their effects on electron correlation while maintaining a low computational cost. Our recently introduced Aufbau suppressed coupled cluster (ASCC) approach [ 20 , 21 ] captures both orbital relaxation and its correlation effects, but, with a cost like the ground state singles and doubles theory (CCSD), its applicability to CT was initially somewhat limited. In this study, we develop a second order perturbative counterpart to ASCC and, by nesting a small coupled cluster evaluation inside of it, reduce the cost and scaling of the approach while maintaining its accuracy for valence, Rydberg, and CT excitations. ASCC and its partially linearized cousin (PLASCC) have a two-fold advantage in handling post-excitation orbital relaxations that makes them particularly well positioned to model CT. [ 20 , 21 ] First, they can be constructed on top of a reference wave function that already captures orbital relaxation effects at the mean field level. Second, their full \hat{T}_{1} singles operators allow them to fine tune orbital relaxations in the presence of correlation effects. [ 22 ] The ability to deliver a CCSD-like weak correlation treatment alongside and informed by these orbital relaxations has allowed PLASCC to deliver \sim 0.1 eV excitation energy errors across a wide variety of excited states, including Rydberg and CT states. [ 21 ] While this accuracy is especially noteworthy for CT, where EOM-CCSD’s errors are \sim 0.375 eV, the N^{6} cost scaling with system size N has so far limited the applicability of ASCC and PLASCC to relatively small systems. To lower cost while maintaining accuracy, we propose to exploit ASCC theory’s strong connections to perturbation theory (PT) to avoid wasting effort perfecting the treatment of correlation effects that are simply going to cancel out when evaluating the excitation energy difference. Just as ground state CCSD is motivated by PT and intimately linked to second order Møller–Plesset (MP2) theory, [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] ASCC and especially PLASCC are motivated by PT arguments [ 21 ] and, as we will show, share an analogous link to an excited state second order Aufbau suppressed PT. Exploiting this link, we will construct a nested ASCC approach in which the low cost PT determines which orbitals’ correlation effects are most strongly influenced by the excitation, and which orbitals’ correlations are sufficiently insensitive to the excitation that leaving their treatment at the PT level should be safe. A subsequent ASCC or PLASCC treatment of only the strongly affected orbitals will then be used to refine the correlation effects that most strongly influence the excitation energy. In order to arrive at a second order excited-state-specific PT, we will begin with the ASCC equations and systematically remove terms contributing at higher perturbative orders, similarly to how MP2 can be derived from ground state CCSD. [ 23 ] The ASCC ansatz is exponentially parameterized using both an excitation operator \hat{T} and a one-body deexcitation operator \hat{S}^{\dagger} that act on a closed-shell Aufbau determinant, \ket{\phi_{0}} . [ 20 ] \ket{\Psi_{\text{ASCC}}}=e^{-\hat{S}^{\dagger}}e^{\hat{T}}\ket{\phi_{0}} (1) With this choice of ansatz, remarkably simple initializations of \hat{T} and \hat{S^{\dagger}} allow us to transform \ket{\phi_{0}} into a qualitatively correct open-shell excited state, at which point \hat{T} can be further optimized to capture weak correlation effects. [ 20 ] We move towards working equations in the same manner as traditional CC, which leads to similarity transformations of the Hamiltonian. \displaystyle\bar{H} \displaystyle=e^{-\hat{T}}e^{\hat{S}^{\dagger}}\hat{H}e^{-\hat{S}^{\dagger}}e^{\hat{T}} (2) Since \hat{S}^{\dagger} is a one-body operator, the inner transformation amounts to a two-electron integral transform. Working with the outer transformation leads to tensor contractions similar to those in CCSD, but which are evaluated using the modified integrals resulting from the inner transform. As in ground state CC, the ASCC energy is evaluated as the expectation value with respect to \ket{\phi_{0}} , while projections with excited determinants \bra{\phi_{\mu}} yield the amplitude equations that we solve to optimize \hat{T} . \displaystyle E \displaystyle=\bra{\phi_{0}}\bar{H}\ket{\phi_{0}} (3) \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=\bra{\phi_{\mu}}\bar{H}\ket{\phi_{0}} (4) Considering these equations now from a perturbative perspective, the initialization that both \hat{S}^{\dagger} and \hat{T} require to arrive at a qualitatively correct starting point implies that they both contain nontrivial zeroth order pieces. [ 21 ] Note, however, that \hat{S}^{\dagger} remains fixed after initialization, with only \hat{T} varying and thus containing higher order contributions. \displaystyle\hat{S}^{\dagger} \displaystyle=\hat{S}^{\dagger(0)} (5) \displaystyle\hat{T} \displaystyle=\hat{T}^{(0)}+\hat{T}^{(1)}+\hat{T}^{(2)}+\cdots (6) After perturbatively partitioning the Hamiltonian — see the Supporting Information (SI) — its double similarity transform can also be partitioned by perturbative order. \displaystyle\hat{H} \displaystyle=\hat{H}^{(0)}+\hat{H}^{(1)} (7) \displaystyle\bar{H} \displaystyle=\bar{H}^{(0)}+\bar{H}^{(1)}+\bar{H}^{(2)}+\cdots (8) Substituting this expansion of \bar{H} into the energy and residual equations (Eqns. 3 and 4 ) allows us to evaluate cluster amplitude and energy contributions order by order. By adding together all energetic contributions up to second order, we are thus able to determine the cluster amplitudes necessary to achieve a second order excited-state-specific energy, thus arriving at the second order PT we will need for our nested approach. \displaystyle E_{\text{PT2}} \displaystyle=E^{(0)}+E^{(1)}+E^{(2)} (9) \displaystyle E^{(n)} \displaystyle=\bra{\phi_{0}}\bar{H}^{(n)}\ket{\phi_{0}} (10) \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=\bra{\phi_{\mu}}\bar{H}^{(n)}\ket{\phi_{0}}\rightarrow\hat{T}_{\mu}^{(n)} (11) While the working equations for this PT are a bit more complicated than for MP2 due to the presence of \hat{T}^{(0)} , they do closely mirror MP2’s computational cost. Once the two-electron integrals are available in the molecular orbital (MO) basis, every term in the working equations scales as O(N^{4}) or less, as is

Read the complete text