Membrane-Associated Self-Assembly for Cellular Decision Making

Samuel L. Foley, Margaret E. Johnson · 2025

Read Membrane-Associated Self-Assembly for Cellular Decision Making by Samuel L. Foley, Margaret E. Johnson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17290.txt.

Introduction

Samuel L Foley and Margaret E Johnson show, in a 2025 paper, how cells might make switch-like decisions by letting molecular parts assemble themselves on a membrane, with no energy spent. Receptors on the cell surface usually pass signals inward through chains of costly, one-way reactions. That active route gives sharp responses, but it burns fuel. The authors model a passive rival: three-dimensional subunits drifting in the cell spontaneously gather on the two-dimensional membrane once receptor density passes a threshold.

Their formulas predict that critical density closely, matching computer simulations of the random process. The passive switch proves far more sensitive than other energy-free detection schemes. Lipids, subunits, and receptors can each tune where the decision boundary sits and how big the response grows. The theory gives experimentalists clear predictions to test in living systems.

Catalog record

CREATORSamuel L. Foley, Margaret E. Johnson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17290

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Membrane-Associated Self-Assembly for Cellular Decision Making Samuel L. Foley, Margaret E. Johnson Abstract Cellular decision-making based on information received from the external environment is frequently initiated by transmembrane receptors. These receptors are known to propagate such information by triggering a series of irreversible, energy-consuming reactions. While this active mechanism ensures switch-like responses, here we show how spontaneous self-assembly of native 3D subunits on a two-dimensional substrate can similarly act as a tunable and robust switch for detecting receptors at physiological concentrations. This mechanism is much more sensitive than other passive mechanisms for receptor detection. We derive analytical expressions for the critical receptor density driving stable subunit assembly, in close agreement with stochastic reaction-diffusion simulations. The theory provides testable predictions for how lipids, subunits, and receptors each can control decision boundaries and magnitude of response. I Introduction Living systems receive diverse inputs from their surrounding environment, including neighboring cells, via a variety of molecules. These molecules, including essential nutrients [ 3 ] , growth factors [ 40 ] , and surface adhesion proteins [ 10 ] , interact directly with transmembrane receptors bridging the outside of the cell to the cell interior [ 29 ] . To initiate the appropriate output response, the familiar form of information processing is for these local interactions to initiate a series of irreversible reactions triggered by enzymes, generating a selective and switch-like transition [ 15 , 43 , 17 , 44 ] . However, given the diversity of inputs and subsequent decisions (e.g. nutrient uptake), can alternate molecular paradigms for receptor detection at a threshold density decouple sensing from energy expenditure while retaining the switch-like response? Endocytosis [ 34 , 35 ] , adhesion formation [ 32 , 47 ] , and immune cell-antigen binding [ 33 ] may not be classically considered “information processing”, but each require detection of receptors at controlled times and places for proper function. Because each of these processes combine receptor binding with self-assembly of cytosolic proteins, we propose that the assembly itself offers a reliable way to encode a decisive, localized response. We show here that equilibrium binding of subunits to receptors, which does not induce a sharp sensitivity to density changes, can be pushed to a switch-like response via self-assembly of subunits benefiting from a 2D search space. The equilibrium self-assembly of subunits with a sufficient valency Z>1 and topology can transition sharply from free to assembled over small changes in concentration or binding free energy \Delta G . This stems from reduction in the probability of subunit dissociation by \exp(\Delta G/k_{\mathrm{B}}T) , where k_{\mathrm{B}}T is the thermal energy, following the formation of a closed loop of subunits [ 25 , 13 , 57 ] . This cooperativity is emergent rather than explicitly built-in through allostery, which we exclude from the assembly [ 23 , 24 , 57 , 56 , 14 ] . We exploit this sensitivity to concentration changes by coupling lattice assembly to dimensional reduction on the surface [ 1 ] and subsequent receptor binding. Receptor detection thresholds thus emerge in our theory and simulation from reversible bimolecular interactions via the participation of discrete, multi-valent subunits, without the chemical feedback common in pattern formation [ 51 ] . The role of the receptor is related to, but distinguishable from, membrane adsorption. By providing a second anchor to the surface following adsorption, receptors increase 2D subunit densities, promoting assembly that feeds back into reduced desorption via closed loops with the surface; hence there is an accumulation of effective cooperativity. Our framework makes the dependence on the volume-to-surface-area ratio \ell\equiv\mathcal{V}/\mathcal{A} transparent, as together with the changes to \Delta G from 3D to 2D [ 52 ] , these factors set the maximal gain in assembly yield from concentrating subunits in 2D [ 53 ] . Patterns and nucleation observed in models [ 51 , 20 ] and experiments [ 45 , 7 ] are strongly coupled to \ell . Achieving assembly-driven sensing and discrimination of receptor densities without activation or energy input requires proper tuning of interaction strengths relative to concentrations. Subunits should be native 3D species with concentrations below the critical threshold for nucleation. Adsorption and confinement to the membrane [ 2 ] will move them towards the critical concentration [ 53 ] , but to be effective sensors, they should remain below this concentration in the absence of receptors. We derive a free energy function that predicts the fraction of subunits in ordered lattices for a finite pool of subunits. Without receptors, our model resembles pre-wetting frameworks [ 37 , 55 , 27 ] , albeit with the dense (lattice) phase restricted to 2D topologically. A primary difference (in addition to finite size) is that our free energy derives from specific discrete pairwise interactions, such that our parameters then map directly to experimental measureables like binding affinities; the continuum nature of pre-wetting [ 11 , 19 ] renders physiologic relevance of phase-separating regimes hard to test. We derive an accurate closed-form approximation to the critical receptor threshold from our theory and quantitatively test it via stochastic simulations. Our results show that receptor sensing by 2D self-assembly is broadly achievable in living systems at realistic timescales. a membrane b s [formula] c Figure 1: ( a ) Schematic illustration of lattice theory of receptor-coupled surface self-assembly. The membrane surface area (bottom) is discretized into a lattice ( Z=3 shown) which may be occupied by A subunits either in the free phase (blue) or lattice phase (grey). Surface subunits bound to a receptor R are indicated with hashed shading. ( b ) Schematic diagram of the coarse-grained model used in reaction-diffusion (RD) simulations. ( c ) Simulation snapshot of an assembled coat 60 seconds after unassembled initiation in solution. II Models and Methods II.1 Equilibrium Theory We construct a minimal model of equilibrium self-assembly coupled to membrane localization and transmembrane receptor binding, deriving our surface free energy from a lattice model. Our assembly-competent subunits A can bind to a single membrane site L and may also bind to a transmembrane receptor R once bound to the membrane (Fig 1b) [ 46 ] . The subunit valence Z specifies how many contacts subunits can make to other subunits. The key energetic parameters are the subunit-lipid association constant K_{\mathrm{a}}^{\mathrm{AL}} , the subunit-receptor association constant K_{\mathrm{a}}^{\mathrm{AR}} , and the subunit-subunit bond (free) energy \varepsilon . The procedure can be summarized as finding the simultaneous solution of the coupled equilibria that govern the state of the assembled structure on the membrane: subunit-membrane equilibrium, subunit-receptor equilibrium, and subunit-subunit surface equilibrium. The first of these equilibria, for the binding of A and L to form AL, follows simply from the 3-dimensional bimolecular equilibrium constant, K_{\mathrm{a}}^{\mathrm{AL}}=\frac{c_{\text{AL}}}{c_{\text{A}}c_{\text{L}}}. (1) We treat the concentration c_{\text{L}} as a constant under the reasonable assumption that lipid copies far exceed subunit copies [ 53 ] . Throughout this work we will use c_{\text{X}}\equiv N_{\text{X}}/\mathcal{V} to denote the volume concentration of species X, where N_{\text{X}} is the copy number. For species which are restricted to move along the 2-dimensional membrane, c_{\text{X}} refers to the effective 3-dimensional concentration, related to the 2-dimensional concentration \rho_{\text{X}}\equiv N_{\text{X}}/\mathcal{A} by \ell . The second equilibrium equation is similar, but slightly modified due to the subunit-receptor reaction

Read the complete text