Oort Cloud Formation and Evolution in Star Clusters
Justine C. Obidowski, Jeremy J. Webb, Simon Portegies Zwart, Maxwell X. Cai · 2025
Read Oort Cloud Formation and Evolution in Star Clusters by Justine C. Obidowski, Jeremy J. Webb, Simon Portegies Zwart, Maxwell X. Cai (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17246.txt.
Introduction
Justine Obidowski and three co-authors simulate the birth and loss of comet clouds around young stars in a 2025 study. Every Sun-like star may host a distant shell of comets, the Oort cloud, but no one knows whether it fills while the star still sits in its birth cluster or long after. Passing stars can strip comets away, so timing matters.
The team picked 50 Sun-mass stars in a modeled cluster and gave each a cloud of 1,000 comets. They varied when the cloud reached full mass: at once, 50 million years in, or 250 million years in. Each cloud was then tracked until its star left the cluster. Only a share of comets stayed bound, and that share rose for later-forming clouds, reaching about a third in the latest case.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Justine C. Obidowski, Jeremy J. Webb, Simon Portegies Zwart, Maxwell X. Cai |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17246
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Oort Cloud Formation and Evolution in Star Clusters Justine C. Obidowski, Jeremy J. Webb, Simon Portegies Zwart, Maxwell X. Cai Abstract It is unknown if an Oort cloud reaches its maximum mass within its star’s birth cluster or millions of years later. Complicating the Oort cloud evolution process is the fact that comets can be stripped from orbit due to perturbations from passing stars. We explore how a star’s cluster escape time (t esc ) and the time its Oort cloud reaches maximum mass (t max ) affect the Oort cloud’s ability to survive via N N -body simulations. In a 14 M ⊙ /pc 3 cluster, we identify 50 stars of 1 M ⊙ with a range of t esc to host Oort clouds, each with 1000 comets at t max . For each host, we consider Oort clouds that reach maximum mass 0, 50, and 250 Myr after the cluster’s formation. Each Oort cloud’s evolution is simulated in the cluster from t max to t esc . Only a fraction of comets tend to remain in orbit, with this amount depending on t max and t esc . We observe that 12%, 22%, and 32% of Oort clouds with a t max of 0, 50 and 250 Myr retain > > 50% of their comets at t esc , respectively. We find that the fraction of comets stripped has the relationship, f = m log 10 ( t esc − t max Myr ) \rm f=m\log_{10}(\frac{t_{\rm esc}-t_{\rm max}}{Myr}) where m = 0.32 ± \pm 0.04, indicating that the longer the Oort cloud remains in the cluster, the more comets are stripped, with this fraction increasing logarithmically at approximately the same rate for each t max . I Introduction In the outermost regions of a planetary system, a spherical cloud of millions of cometary objects is likely to exist in orbit around the star. This distant cloud is known as the Oort cloud, named after Dutch astronomer Jan Hendrik Oort, who first hypothesized its existence in the Solar System in 1950 [ 38 ] . Although no confirmed direct observations of the Solar System’s Oort cloud or any exo-Oort cloud have been made, there are strong indications that one exists around the Sun. One important piece of evidence of the Oort cloud’s existence in the Solar System is long-period comets, which are predicted to have been perturbed from the Oort cloud and sent on highly elliptical orbital paths that pass close to the Sun. Long-period comets have periods of hundreds or thousands of years and have been observed throughout history, but more of them have been observed and classified in recent decades due to improvements in observing technology [ 31 ] . Another sign of the existence of the Oort cloud is the discovery of distant transneptunian objects (TNOs) that have aphelions near the inner Oort cloud. For example, several TNOs have been observed to have highly eccentric orbits with a perihelion beyond the Kuiper cliff at 47.8 AU [ 5 , 45 , 4 ] , such as Sedna [ 13 ] and 2012 VP113 [ 47 ] . The Oort cloud of the Sun is split into an inner and outer region. The inner Oort cloud is considered to be the region beyond the Kuiper belt that extends from approximately 2,000 to 10,000 AU while the outer Oort cloud ranges from approximately 10,000 to 200,000 AU. The outer boundary of an Oort cloud defines the cosmographic boundary of the planetary system and the extent of the Hill sphere of the host star [ 27 ] . For the Sun, the outer boundary of the Oort cloud is the distance equal to the Sun’s Hill sphere radius in the Galactic potential ( \sim 200,000 AU) [ 17 ] . The inner boundary of an Oort cloud is defined less clearly and is still debated for the Solar System [ 28 , 34 , 11 ] . Stars do not form in isolation, but in clustered environments of gas and dust within a galaxy [ 33 , 41 , 1 ] . Within these clustered environments, star formation can occur and result in the birth of a large group of stars known as a star cluster. The evolution of bodies in orbit around a star within a star cluster such as cometary objects in an Oort cloud can be affected by perturbations from other stars passing close to the system. A field star can also experience perturbations caused by another star, but they are different than those experienced in a cluster. Perturbations from passing stars depend on both the stellar density of their environment and the effective cross-section for the perturbation to occur [ 29 ] . This cross-section decreases rapidly with increasing interaction speed, which is different in the cluster (a few km/s) than in the field ( \sim 40 km/s). If a star is located in a dense cluster of stars, it will likely experience a high number of close encounters with other stars that can cause perturbations. Objects in orbit close to their host star are usually less affected by perturbations from passing stars as they are more strongly held by their star’s gravity compared to objects that are further away. Studies of planetary systems in star clusters [ 10 , 11 , 14 , 12 ] have shown that perturbations from passing stars can change the orbits of objects in a system and can even cause some objects, such as comets in an Oort cloud, to be stripped from orbit entirely. Objects stripped from their orbits around the Sun that do not get captured by another body become free-floating interstellar objects as they are ejected from the Solar System. There are two popular scenarios for the formation of the Oort cloud. The first one explains that the Oort cloud is formed mainly by ejecting inner Solar System material through planet–disk interactions [ 19 , 20 ] , and the other involves formation through two separate processes: local disk asteroids getting ejected into an inner region at around 3,000-20,000 AU and free-floating debris from the birth star cluster accreting in an outer region ( > 20,000 AU) [ 51 , 48 , 8 , 9 , 7 ] . The timescale of an Oort cloud’s formation is strongly connected to its star’s birth environment [ 10 ] and there are several possible timescales depending on the chosen formation model. Estimates of the timescale of the Oort cloud’s formation range from almost instantaneously after the formation of the Sun [ 23 ] , synchronously with Jupiter’s formation [ 46 , 24 , 20 ] , after Jupiter’s formation and migration [ 44 ] , slowly growing over several hundred Myr [ 30 , 37 ] , and growing over Gyr timescales [ 21 ] . [ 40 ] performed a numerical investigation that showed that during the Sun’s infancy, the Oort cloud could have formed from complex interactions between the Sun and nearby stars, free-floating debris, the Galactic tidal field, and planetary scattering. Specifically, they found that the Solar System’s birth environment prevents the gas giant planets from forming the Oort cloud, but still stimulates