LLM-Powered Agents for Navigating Venice’s Historical Cadastre
Tristan Karch, Jakhongir Saydaliev, Isabella di Lenardo, Frédéric Kaplan · 2025
Read LLM-Powered Agents for Navigating Venice’s Historical Cadastre by Tristan Karch, Jakhongir Saydaliev, Isabella di Lenardo, Frédéric Kaplan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-17148.txt.
Introduction
Tristan Karch, Frédéric Kaplan and their co-authors use large language model agents to query Venice land records from long ago. Their 2025 case covers the years after the old Republic fell, when records were large and far from uniform.
Their system turns plain questions into programs that run on the records. One agent handles structured database queries, while a coding agent does harder custom work. The team sorts research questions by difficulty and maps each type to the right agent. Checks on consistency and answer quality support the approach. Results rebuilt past data on people, property and change over time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tristan Karch, Jakhongir Saydaliev, Isabella di Lenardo, Frédéric Kaplan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-17148
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
LLM-Powered Agents for Navigating Venice’s Historical Cadastre Tristan Karch, Jakhongir Saydaliev, Isabella di Lenardo, Frédéric Kaplan Abstract Cadastral data reveal key information about the historical organization of cities but are often non-standardized due to diverse formats and human annotations, complicating large-scale analysis. We explore as a case study Venice’s urban history during the critical period from 1740 to 1808, capturing the transition following the fall of the ancient Republic and the Ancien Régime. This era’s complex cadastral data, marked by its volume and lack of uniform structure, presents unique challenges that our approach adeptly navigates, enabling us to generate spatial queries that bridge past and present urban landscapes. We present a text-to-programs framework that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to translate natural language queries into executable code for processing historical cadastral records. Our methodology implements two complementary techniques: a text-to-SQL approach for handling structured queries about specific cadastral information, and a text-to-Python approach for complex analytical operations requiring custom data manipulation. We propose a taxonomy that classifies historical research questions based on their complexity and analytical requirements, mapping them to the most appropriate technical approach. This framework is supported by an investigation into the execution consistency of the system, alongside a qualitative analysis of the answers it produces. By ensuring interpretability and minimizing hallucination through verifiable program outputs, we demonstrate the system’s effectiveness in reconstructing past population information, property features, and spatiotemporal comparisons in Venice. keywords open-ended learning, developmental AI, language, culture, socio-cultural situatedness, reinforcement learning, autotelic agents, cognitive tools, natural language processing, large language models, culture models 1 Introduction 1.1 Context Historical cadastral records, widely distributed throughout Europe, serve as invaluable documents to reconstruct past urban and territorial information [ 1 ] . These records document property ownership, usage functions, and other essential elements for taxation, offering high confidence in their reliability due to their administrative purpose [ 2 ] . Often paired with cartographic mappings, these dual systems combine textual descriptions with geographic representations following standardized visual and ontological codes to minimize subjective interpretation and enhance utility for taxation [ 3 ] . The evolution of cadastral sources has been extensively studied, with analyses spanning specific case studies to comparative frameworks. Associated cartography, particularly before and after the Napoleonic introduction of geometric-parcel cadastres, reflects a shift towards standardized cartographic practices [ 4 ] . These sources are critical for reconstructing historical population data, property functions, and urban spatial dynamics. These historical cadastral records offer rich opportunities for understanding urban development, social structures, and economic patterns. Researchers can investigate diverse questions ranging from property ownership dynamics (e.g., identifying dominant landholders or tracking wealth concentration) to spatial-functional analyses (e.g., mapping commercial activities in specific districts). While digitization has made these documents more accessible, the challenge lies in efficiently queryinh and analyzing this wealth of information to answer such research questions. Traditional manual methods of data extraction and analysis are time-consuming and limit the scale at which these historical insights can be pursued, creating a need for computational approaches that can systematically process these records while maintaining the nuanced understanding required for historical research. To address these analytical challenges, this paper explores the application of Large Language Model (LLM)-based agents to analyze historical cadastre datasets, specifically focusing on two digitized Venetian cadastres: the 1740 Catastici from the Republic of Venice and the 1808 Sommarioni from the Napoleonic Kingdom of Italy [ 5 ] . These historical records present significant processing challenges, including orthographic variations, transcription errors, and non-standardized formats, as illustrated in Figure 1 . To effectively query the cadastral data, we propose a text-to-program approach that translates natural language queries into executable code. Within this strategy, we explore two complementary techniques. The first employs text-to-SQL translation, which is optimal for precise, structured queries about specific cadastral information (e.g., "Who owned property X in 1740?" or "What was the value of properties in district Y?"). The second utilizes text-to-Python translation, enabling more complex analytical operations and pattern recognition through custom code generation. This technique is particularly suitable for broader research questions requiring data manipulation and statistical analysis (e.g., "How did property ownership patterns change between 1740 and 1808?" or "What were the spatial distribution trends of different property types?"). Figure 1: The role of LLMs in processing historical Cadastres. Processing historical records with orthographic variations and complex transcription details through text-to-SQL and text-to-Python approaches for systematic data analysis. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. In the next section, we present the cadastral data of Venice that forms the foundation of our study. Section 3 introduces a typology of historical questions relevant to this cadastral data, addressing different analytical needs and query complexities. Sections 5 and 6 detail our text-to-programs systems, demonstrating the implementation and capabilities of both text-to-SQL and text-to-Python approaches. We conclude by evaluating the accuracy and reliability of these systems, offering a typology of their error types and consistency metrics to ensure answer trustworthiness. 2 Cadastral data of the city of venice The first geometric cadastre in Venice was established in 1808, adhering to French administrative standards [ 6 ] . As displayed in figure 2 , it operates as a dual system, combining cartographic maps of parcels with textual records that document ownership, location, function, and area. Each parcel is assigned a unique number, which is cross-referenced with the records that catalog owners, toponyms, uses, and dimensions (see Figure 3 b). Ownership records include individual names, family relationships, and institutions, while functions are classified using a codified Italian ontology from 1808 [ 7 ] . In particular, the terms reflect historical usage; for instance, a “shop” is referred to as ’bottega’, rather than the modern Italian term ’negozio’. Figure 2: The dual information system of the 1808 cadaster. Each parcel mention in the textual document is geolocalized on the cadastral map through the same ID code Otherwise, the 1740 Catastico represents a textual survey system managed by the Collegio dei Dieci Savi at Rialto, designed to administer the Venetian tithe—a 10% property tax introduced in 1463. Property owners submitted self-declared ’Condizioni di Decima’ or ’Polizze’ which detailed property type, location, status, and income. These submissions were organized by district and sequentially numbered based on submission order, with taxation calculated from declared rents [ 8 ] . The overall informational structure of the document is displayed in figure 3 a. Following a major archival fire in 1514, redecimation efforts occurred sporadically, with significant collections in 1514, 1537, 1566, 1581, 1661, 1711, and 1740. Unlike the 1808 cadastre, the Catastico did not integrate cartographic representation. Instead, records were generated through door-to-door surveys conducted by censors, who documented owners, tenants, toponyms, property functions, and rents (see Fig. 2-A). These systems reflect complementary approaches to surveying. The 1808 cadastre is cartographic, parcel-based, and systematic, while the Catastico is textual, household-focused, and income-oriented. Despite these differences, both systems exhibit stable informational structures [ 8 ] . Both have been digitized and transcribed: in the 1808 cadastre, parcel identifiers, codes, and toponyms were automatically transcribed and subsequently verified manually [ 9 , 10 ] . For the 1740 Catastico, geolocation was achieved by correlating toponyms with contemporary maps, reconstructing the censors’ survey paths, and identifying shared features between parcels recorded in