Slow convergence of ergodic averages for actions of amenable groups

Valery V. Ryzhikov · 2025

Read Slow convergence of ergodic averages for actions of amenable groups by Valery V. Ryzhikov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16987.txt.

Introduction

Valery Ryzhikov proves that averaged measurements in systems driven by amenable groups can converge as slowly as one likes, in a mathematics paper from 2025. Ergodic theory studies long-run averages along the motion of a system. Amenable groups are those tame enough to carry an averaging scheme at all. The result covers weighted ergodic averages, for both flows and actions of countable amenable groups. It places a hard limit on what ergodic theorems can promise. No universal speed of convergence follows from amenability alone.

Catalog record

CREATORValery V. Ryzhikov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16987

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Slow convergence of ergodic averages for actions of amenable groups Valery V. Ryzhikov Abstract For an ergodic automorphism T of the probability space (X,m) and a function f\in L_{1}(X,m) theaverages P_{N}f:=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}T^{i}f converge in the norm of L_{1}(X,m) to a constant \int fdm . If f\neq 0 , then \|P_{N}f-\int fdm\| cannot be o(1/N) , since \|(N+1)P_{N}f/N-P_{N+1}f\|=\|f\|/(N+1) . But for suitable weighted averages such a rate of convergence is realized (see, for example, the work of Tong and Li [ 1 ] ). Krengel [ 2 ] showed for an ergodic automorphism that the rate of convergence of uniform averages for suitable f\in L_{1}(X,m) is arbitrarily slow. In the present communication, a similar result is established in the case of weighted averages for flows and actions of countable amenable groups. Modifying the arguments from [ 3 ] , we find a sequence of small in measure increasingly invariant sets V_{k} such that the weighted averages for the indicator of a set lying outside the union of V_{k} of the deviation in norm from a constant are not majorized by a predetermined sequence tending to zero. To construct such a set V_{k} , we use Rudolph’s theorem on a special representation of flows (see [ 4 ] , Chapter 11) and the Ornstein-Weiss result [ 5 ] (II, §2, Theorem 5) on actions of amenable groups (an analogue of Rokhlin’s lemma). Slow convergence of ergodic averages for flows. In the paper by Kozlov and Treschev [ 6 ] , weighted averages of the form P_{t}f(x)=\int_{R}h(r)f(T_{rt}x)dr , where \int_{R}h\,dr=1 , h\geq 0 , are considered for ergodic flows. For f\in L_{1}(X,m) we prove the convergence \|P_{t}f-\int f\,dm\|\to 0 as t\to\infty . We will show the absence of a universal estimate for the rate of convergence for these and more general weighted averages. Theorem 1. Let T_{t} be an ergodic flow on the probability space (X,m) that preserves the measure m , and let P_{n}=\int_{R}T_{t}d\nu_{n}t be a sequence of operators, where \nu_{n} are normalized Borel measures on {\mathbb{R}} . For any sequence a_{n}\to+0 and a set A^{\prime} of positive measure, for any \varepsilon>0 there exists a set A , m(A^{\prime}\Delta A)<\varepsilon , such that \left|\left\{n\,:\ \left\|P_{n}{\bf 1}_{A}\ -\ m(A)\right\|\ >\ a_{n}\right\}\right|\ =\infty. Fix a small \varepsilon>0 and a sequence {n(k)} for which \sum_{k}a_{n(k)}<\varepsilon. The set A is constructed as follows. We find L_{k} such that \nu_{n(k)}([-L_{n},L_{n}])>1-\varepsilon a_{n(k)}. From the special representation of the flow (see Rudolph’s theorem in [ 4 ] ) it follows immediately that there exists a set V_{k} such that m(V_{k})=2a_{n(k)} and m\left(V_{k}\ \ \Delta\bigcap_{-L_{k}\leq t\leq L_{k}}T_{t}V_{k}\right)>(1-\varepsilon)m(V_{k}). We set A=A^{\prime}\setminus\bigcup_{k}V_{k} . For the operator Q_{k}=\int_{[-L_{k},L_{k}]}T_{t}d\nu_{n}(t) the function Q_{k}{\bf 1}_{A} is equal to 0 at the intersection \bigcap_{-L_{k}\leq t\leq L_{k}}T_{t}V_{k} . The measure of the intersection is greater than (1-\varepsilon)m(V_{k}) by construction. Also, due to the choice of L_{k} , \|P_{n(k)}{\bf 1}_{A}-Q_{k}{\bf 1}_{A}\|<\varepsilon a_{n(k)} is satisfied. Finally, from the above, we obtain \left\|P_{n(k)}{\bf 1}_{A}\ -\ m(A)\right\|\ >(1-\varepsilon)m(V_{k})-\varepsilon a_{n(k)}>a_{n(k)}, as required. Slow convergence ofaverages for actions of countable groups. Consider the free action \{T_{g}\,:\,g\in G\} of an infinite countable group G by automorphisms T_{g} of the standard probability space (X,m) . Let F and F_{j} denote finite subsets of G . We say that a set V\subset X is (F,c) -invariant for 0<c<1 if m\left(\bigcap_{g\in F}T_{g}V\right)>c\,m(V). Recall that G is amenable if there exists a (Follner) sequence of finite sets F_{j}\subset G that are asymptotically invariant under group shifts (see [ 5 ] ). Averages of the form \sum_{g\in F_{j}}T_{g}f/|F_{j}| over such sets F_{j} for ergodic actions converge in the norm in L_{1}(X,m) to a constant. Lemma. Let c\in(0,1) , a sequence of finite sets F_{k}\subset G , and a measure-preserving free action \{T_{g}\} of a countable amenable group G be given. If V_{k} are (F_{k},c) -invariant and \sum_{k}m(V_{k})<\infty , then for every \varepsilon>0 and a set A^{\prime} of positive measure there exists a set A such that m(A^{\prime}\Delta A)<\varepsilon and \left\|\sum_{g\in F_{k}}w_{g,k}T_{g}{\bf 1}_{A}\ -\ m(A)\right\|\ >c\,m(V_{k})m(A), for all non-negative w_{g,k} satisfying the condition \sum_{g\in F_{k}}w_{g,k}=1 . For sufficiently large N we set V=\bigcup_{k>N}V_{k}, A:=A^{\prime}\setminus V, so that for U=\cup_{g\in F_{k}}T_{g}A we have m(V_{k}\setminus U)>cm(V_{k})m(A) . But the function \sum_{g\in F_{k}}w_{g,k}T_{g}{\bf 1}_{A} is equal to 0 on V_{k}\setminus U , which yields the assertion of the lemma. A consequence of the above-mentioned result of Ornstein and Weiss for free actions of amenable groups is the (c,\varepsilon) -property of these actions: for any c,\varepsilon\in(0,1) and any finite F\subset G there exists an (F,c) -invariant set of measure \varepsilon . The (c,\varepsilon) -property of the actions under consideration and the lemma imply the following assertion. Theorem 2. Let a sequence a_{j}\to+0 , a free ergodic action \{T_{g}\} of an infinite countable amenable group G , and a sequence of finite sets F_{j}\subset G be given. Then for A^{\prime} , m(A^{\prime})>0 , there exists a set A arbitrarily close to it in measure such that for w_{g,j}\geq 0 and \sum_{g\in F_{j}}w_{g,j}=1 the following holds \left|\left\{j\,:\ \left\|\sum_{g\in F_{j}}w_{g,j}T_{g}{\bf 1}_{A}\ -\ m(A)\right\|\ >\ a_{j}\right\}\right|\ =\infty. In the case of a Follner sequence F_{j} we obtain the desired effect of slow convergence ofaverages to a constant function. Slow convergence almost everywhere. Theorem 3. Let T be an ergodic automorphism of the probability space (X,m) and f\in L_{1}(X,m) be a nonzero function. For any sequence a_{n}\to+0 and a set A^{\prime} of positive measure, for any \varepsilon>0 there exists a set Y , m(Y)>1-\varepsilon , such that for \tilde{f}=f{\bf 1}_{Y} for almost all x we have \left|\left\{n\,:\ \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\tilde{f}(T^{i}x)-\int\tilde{f}\,dm>\ a_{n}\,\right\}\right|\ =\infty. The proof again uses the existence of extremely high towers V_{k} of a given (small) measure. The choice of tower V_{k} is not arbitrary, but depends on the towers V_{1},\dots,V_{k-1} . The set Y has the form Y=X\setminus\bigcup_{k}V_{k} . Let us explain how the sets V_{k} are selected. Let \sum_{k}\varepsilon_{k}<\varepsilon , \varepsilon_{k}>0 and let the function f_{k}=f\,{\bf 1}_{Y_{k}},\ \ Y_{k}=X\setminus\bigcup_{i=1}^{k}V_{i}. By Birkhoff’s theorem, there exists n(k) such that for all N\geq n(k) we have m\left(x:\left|\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}f_{k}(T^{i}x)-\int f_{k}dm\right|<\varepsilon_{k}\right)\ >\ 1-\varepsilon_{k}. We fix such n(k) with the additional condition \varepsilon_{k}>a_{n(k)} . We choose a tower V_{k}=\bigsqcup_{i=1}^{h_{k}}T^{i}B_{k} provided that h_{k}\gg\ n(k) and m(V_{k})=3\varepsilon_{k}. When choosing sufficiently large h_{k} (we are free to choose arbitrarily high towers of a given measure), we have the inequality m\left(\ x:\ \ \left|\frac{1}{n(k)}\sum_{i=1}^{n(k)}\tilde{f}(T^{i}x)-\int\tilde{f}dm\right|\ >\varepsilon_{k}\,\right)>\ \ 1-\varepsilon_{k}. And this implies the assertion of the theorem, since \varepsilon_{k}>a_{n(k)} . The author thanks S.V. Tikhonov, J.-P. Thouvenot and B. Weiss for useful comments. Медленная сходимость эргодических средних для действий аменабельных групп. Для эргодического автоморфизма T вероятностного пространства (X,m) и функции f\in L_{1}(X,m) средние P_{N}f:=\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}T^{i}f сходятся по норме L_{1}(X,m) к константе \int fdm . Если f\neq 0 , то \|P_{N}f-\int fdm\| не может быть o(1/N) , так как \|(N+1)P_{N}f/N-P_{N+1}f\|=\|f\|/(N+1) . Но для подходящих весовых средних такая скорость сходимости реализуется (см., например, работу Тонга и Ли [ 1 ] ). Кренгелем [ 2 ] для эргодического автоморфизма показана сколь угодно медленная скорость сходимости равномерных средних для подходящих f\in L_{1}(X,m) . В предлагаемом сообщении аналогичный результат устанавливается в случае весовых усреднений для потоков и действий счетных аменабельных групп. Модифицируя рассуждения из [ 3 ] , мы найдем последовательность малых по мере все более инвариантных множеств V_{k} таких, что взвешенные средние для индикатора множества, лежащего вне объединения V_{k} отклонения по норме от константы не мажорируются заданной наперед

Read the complete text