Increased Hydrogen escape from Mars atmosphere during periods of high obliquity
Gabriella Gilli, Francisco González-Galindo, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Ehouarn Millour, François Forget, Franck Montmessin, Franck Lefèvre, Joseph Naar, Yangcheng Luo, Margaux Vals, Loïc Rossi, Miguel Ángel López-Valverde, Adrián Brines · 2025
Read Increased Hydrogen escape from Mars atmosphere during periods of high obliquity by Gabriella Gilli, Francisco González-Galindo, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Ehouarn Millour, François Forget, Franck Montmessin, Franck Lefèvre, Joseph Naar, Yangcheng Luo, Margaux Vals, Loïc Rossi, Miguel Ángel López-Valverde, Adrián Brines (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16692.txt.
Introduction
Gabriella Gilli and co-authors model in 2025 how the tilt of Mars changed the loss of hydrogen from its air over time. Mars once held large amounts of liquid water, yet loss rates seen today seem too low to explain that past. Hydrogen escape is thought to be a main path for drying the planet.
A full three-dimensional climate model shows loss rates could rise more than tenfold when the tilt was high. Such high tilt held on average in the last few million years. Added over time, the extra loss equals a global water layer of about eighty meters. That depth sits near the low end of rock-based estimates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriella Gilli, Francisco González-Galindo, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Ehouarn Millour, François Forget, Franck Montmessin, Franck Lefèvre, Joseph Naar, Yangcheng Luo, Margaux Vals, Loïc Rossi, Miguel Ángel López-Valverde, Adrián Brines |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16692
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Increased Hydrogen escape from Mars atmosphere during periods of high obliquity Gabriella Gilli, Francisco González-Galindo, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Ehouarn Millour, François Forget, Franck Montmessin, Franck Lefèvre, Joseph Naar, Yangcheng Luo, Margaux Vals, Loïc Rossi, Miguel Ángel López-Valverde, Adrián Brines Abstract It is still unknown how much water has escaped from Mars during its history. Hydrogen escape from Mars’ atmosphere probably played a major role in drying the planet, but present-day H-loss rates ( ∼ \sim 3x10 26 s -1 on average) cannot explain the geological evidence of the presence of large volumes of liquid water on ancient Mars. We use the 3D Mars-Planetary Climate Model to show that H-loss rates could have increased up to more than one order of magnitude (6x10 27 s -1 ) during higher spin axis obliquity periods, notably in the last millions of years when Mars’s obliquity was about 35° on average. The resulting accumulated H escape over Mars history translates into ∼ \sim 80 m Global Equivalent Layer, which is close to the lower limit of geological estimates. keywords Mars, escape, atmospheric evolution, water Main Mars was not always as dry as it is today: several geologic and mineralogical observations indicate the evidence of past liquid water, with valley networks and outflow channels still visible on the surface Carr1987 ; Bibring2004 . Much of its surface water is believed to have been lost in early Mars history, but the water loss mechanisms and the amounts that escaped into space or remained frozen in the crust today are not well known. Atmospheric thermal (Jeans) escape of atomic hydrogen (H) Anderson1971 ; McElroy1972 ; ParkinsonHunten1972 is considered as a dominant loss mechanism for water, at least in the last couple billion years Jakosky2018 . Present-day loss rates of H by Jeans escape were determined by the MAVEN (Mars Atmosphere and Volatile EvolutioN) mission, with values varying with seasons from 1 to 11×10 26 atoms/s Jakosky2018 ; Halekas2017 ; Mayyasi2023 . Similar results were found by observations made from spacecraft like Mariner 6, 7, and 9 Anderson1974 , Mars Express (MEx) Chaffin2014 , Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Clarke2014 and Rosetta flyby of Mars Feldman2011 . Unexpected variations of the H corona were observed in the exosphere of Mars using the ultraviolet H Ly-alpha emission by MEx Chaffin2014 and HST Clarke2014 . A link between the observed variations and the enhanced propagation of water vapour at perihelion during a global dust storm was suggested. Subsequently, a 1D photochemical model Chaffin2017 described that fast transfer of H 2 O to the upper atmosphere can produce fast enhancements of escape rates. This was later confirmed by observations from NGIMS (Neutral Gas and Ion Mass Spectrometer) on board MAVEN that showed how water is directly transported to the upper atmosphere of Mars during regional and global dust storms Stone2020 . The impact of regional dust storms on the middle atmosphere water content eventually resulting in enhanced H escape was also demonstrated by Heavens2018 and Chaffin2021 combining atmospheric retrievals from several spacecrafts: Mars Climate Sounder (MCS), Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO), MAVEN and Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO). All these results underlined the role of dust storms as an important factor allowing the penetration of water to the mesosphere and providing H-escape on Mars, although other studies showed the regular seasonal variability in absence of discrete dust storms to be the dominant supplying process of escaping hydrogen Montmessin2022 ; kleinbohl2024 . Altogether, a new paradigm has emerged in the last decade, supporting the hypothesis that direct intrusion of H 2 O in the upper atmosphere is the dominant provider of H escape instead of the slow vertical transport of molecular hydrogen (H 2 ) Stone2020 ; Chaffin2021 ; Montmessin2022 ; kleinbohl2024 . The new scenario takes into account the strong coupling with the processes and the state of the lower atmosphere, as mentioned above. Nevertheless, although the mechanism of water escape is now better understood, if we assume the estimated current H escape rates as representative of the whole Mars history, the accumulated water loss during the last 4 billion years is much lower (3-25 m, expressed in Global Equivalent Layer (GEL)) Jakosky2018 ; Chaufray2021 ; Chaffin2014 than the amount of water needed to form the flow channels observed on Mars ( \sim 100 to 1500 m GEL) Carr2003 ; Scheller2021 . Evidences of climate changes in recent Mars There are numerous evidences of climate changes in Mars in recent geological eras. Landforms resulting from the local accumulation of ice indicate that, even during the Amazonian period, large amounts of water (e.g. glaciers several hundred meters thick) formed and remained on the planet Forget2017 . These landforms reveal a different climate in which surface ice was mobilized and transferred across the planet during the last millions of years. The climate of a planet depends on its orbital and rotation parameters, in particular on the obliquity (i.e., inclination of its spin axis relative to the perpendicular to its orbital plane). The primary cause of these climate changes could have been the variation of Mars’ orbital and spin parameters Forget2017 . While for the Earth the oscillations of those parameters are small (± 1.3 ∘ for obliquity), in the past 250 Myrs Mars’ axis inclination covered a large range of variations, between 0 and 66 ∘ , with a mean obliquity of about 35 ∘ Laskar2004 . Different orbital configurations induce significant modifications in fundamental aspects of the Martian climate, such as the CO 2 cycle (and thus the surface pressure), the dust and water cycle, or the global circulation Forget2017 , mainly due to the differences in the distribution of the insolation. The north pole insolation is a key parameter controlling the stability of water ice of the northern polar cap and in the past 10 million years it could have varied from about 140 W m -2 to 400 W m -2 for an obliquity of 15 ∘ and 35 ∘ , respectively, resulting in a significant increase of the atmospheric water column Madeleine2014 . If part of this water was transferred to the upper atmosphere, a larger escape rate would be expected Jakosky2021 . This is consistent with estimations of larger escape in the past from the analysis of the D/H (deuterium to hydrogen) atmospheric enrichment Alsaeed2019 ; Cangi2020 ; Chaufray2024 . Previous theoretical studies focused on the impact of the obliquity changes in the lower atmosphere Madeleine2014 . However, to our knowledge, the effects of changes in the obliquity in the escape rate have not been quantified so far. In this study, we aim to provide a first order estimation of this variation in past epochs characterised by changes in the obliquity during the last 10-20 million years of Mars history. We focus only on the effect of changing obliquity on the water cycle and the H escape rate, neglecting all other atmospheric effects, i.e., we assume that the bulk atmosphere at different obliquities remained the same as of today. This is equivalent to studying how current Mars would react to sudden changes in the obliquity and must be understood as a first, rough approximation aimed at isolating the effect of the obliquity on the escape rate. 3D simulations of current H escape