The chromoelectric adjoint correlators in Euclidean space at next-to-leading order Preprint: TUM-EFT 190/24
Nora Brambilla, Panayiotis Panayiotou, Saga Säppi, and Antonio Vairo · 2025
Read The chromoelectric adjoint correlators in Euclidean space at next-to-leading order Preprint: TUM-EFT 190/24 by Nora Brambilla, Panayiotis Panayiotou, Saga Säppi, and Antonio Vairo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16604.txt.
Introduction
Nora Brambilla and co-authors compute chromoelectric adjoint correlators in Euclidean space at next-to-leading order in a 2025 paper. These correlators govern how quarkonium, bound heavy quark pairs, behaves in hot matter made in heavy-ion collisions.
The study works in a weak-coupling expansion for a thermal medium. Three distinct gauge-invariant correlators are identified and computed. Two come out asymmetric, a surprise traced to zero modes tied to Wilson lines. Results match recent lattice calculations well at high temperatures. The formulas give theory input for modeling quarkonium melting and motion in quark-gluon plasma, a core probe of the hottest matter made on Earth.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nora Brambilla, Panayiotis Panayiotou, Saga Säppi, and Antonio Vairo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 293 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16604
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The chromoelectric adjoint correlators in Euclidean space at next-to-leading order Preprint: TUM-EFT 190/24 Nora Brambilla, Panayiotis Panayiotou, Saga Säppi, and Antonio Vairo Abstract The physics of quarkonium created in heavy-ion collisions is intrinsically connected to the correlation functions of adjoint chromoelectric fields in quantum chromodynamics. We study such correlation functions in a weak-coupling expansion in a thermal medium. We identify three distinct gauge-invariant correlators, and evaluate them to next-to-leading order. Two of the resulting correlators turn out to be asymmetric. We pinpoint the source of this asymmetry to Matsubara zero modes associated with Wilson lines. The results are shown to agree well with recent lattice calculations at high temperatures. 1 Introduction Heavy quarkonium is a key probe of the quark–gluon plasma (QGP), the high-temperature, deconfined, phase of quantum chromodynamics (QCD). Due to the short lifetime of the QGP produced in heavy-ion collisions, quarkonium suppression offers an indirect yet clean probe to study the conditions found in relativistic heavy-ion collisions and, by extension, in the early universe. This was originally proposed by Matsui and Satz Matsui:1986dk , who suggested that in-medium colour-screening effects could reduce the yield of J/\psi , a charm–anticharm bound state, in heavy-ion collisions compared to proton–proton collisions. Relativistic heavy-ion experiments have provided a wealth of information on quarkonium suppression mechanisms PHENIX:2011img ; ALICE:2012jsl ; CMS:2016rpc ; ATLAS:2018hqe ; STAR:2019fge . These mechanisms are attributed to medium-induced effects such as plasma screening Karsch:1987pv , dissociation Kharzeev:1994pz ; Xu:1995eb ; Grandchamp:2001pf ; Grandchamp:2002wp ; Laine:2006ns ; Brambilla:2008cx ; Brambilla:2011sg ; Brambilla:2013dpa and regeneration Braun-Munzinger:2000csl ; Thews:2000rj ; Andronic:2007bi ; Zhao:2007hh ; Brambilla:2023hkw of quarkonium. We are primarily interested in furthering our understanding of the propagation of heavy quarkonium in the QGP. The scales involved in heavy bound systems are well-separated, which calls for the use of non-relativistic effective field theories to simplify the description of the system Caswell:1985ui ; Bodwin:1994jh ; Brambilla:2004jw . The typical hierarchy of scales in these systems is M\gg 1/a_{0}\gg E , where M is the mass of the heavy particle, 1/a_{0} is the inverse of the Bohr radius and E is the binding energy. Two additional scales are provided by the QGP itself, as it is the thermal medium in which the heavy bound state propagates. These scales are the temperature T and the associated Debye screening mass m_{D}\sim g_{s}T . Here, g_{s} is the strong coupling, which is small at large temperatures. A small value of the coupling also makes the thermal scales parametrically separated. Effective field theories are constructed by integrating out the separated energy scales in succession. For our case, the relevant effective field theory is potential non-relativistic quantum chromodynamics (pNRQCD) at finite temperature Brambilla:2008cx ; Escobedo:2008sy ; Brambilla:2010vq . Recent studies Akamatsu:2011se ; Akamatsu:2014qsa ; Brambilla:2016wgg ; Blaizot:2017ypk ; Brambilla:2017zei ; Yao:2018nmy ; Blaizot:2018oev ; Brambilla:2019tpt ; Brambilla:2020qwo ; Akamatsu:2020ypb ; Yao:2020eqy ; Miura:2022arv use effective field theories, such as pNRQCD, to model the propagation of quarkonium in a medium as an open quantum system, with the QGP acting as the environment. In this framework, the evolution of the quarkonium density matrix in the QGP is governed by a master equation that depends on some transport coefficients. It was first established in Brambilla:2016wgg that these transport coefficients could be extracted from the integrals of chromoelectric correlators connected by adjoint temporal Wilson lines. In the open quantum system framework, this emerges by tracing out the environmental degrees of freedom. 1 1 1 Similar correlators also appear in studies of dark matter Binder:2021otw ; Biondini:2023zcz . These chromoelectric correlators are the subject of this work. Previous works on the correlators Binder:2021otw ; Eller:2019spw have focussed on the real-time formulation of thermal QCD and/or dealt with the extraction of transport coefficients related to the propagation of a heavy quark in the plasma. Recently, the analytic continuation of one of the real-time correlators responsible for the singlet–octet transition in pNRQCD has been performed Scheihing-Hitschfeld:2023tuz . Here we use the imaginary-time formulation of perturbative QCD, and evaluate the correlators directly at weak coupling, instead of computing the spectral function. Our choice makes it easier to make contact with lattice QCD studies. Indeed, we are able to provide a perturbative explanation for the recent findings of the first lattice calculation of these correlators Brambilla:Lattice showing, in particular, that the correlator responsible for singlet–octet dipole transition exhibits asymmetry on the thermal circle. While not directly relevant to quarkonium, one should also keep in mind the well-established framework of heavy-quark diffusion valid for a weakly-coupled plasma with the hierarchy M\gg T\gg m_{D} . Analogously to pNRQCD and quarkonium, heavy-quark effective theory is used to study the diffusion of heavy quarks in a thermal medium. Within this approach, the authors of Caron-Huot:2009ncn derived an expression for the heavy quark diffusion coefficient in the QGP in terms of a gauge invariant correlator of chromoelectric fields connected by fundamental Wilson lines within the imaginary-time formalism. In Burnier:2010rp , the spectral function of the fundamental chromoelectric correlator was evaluated and subsequently a prediction for the heavy quark diffusion coefficient was made. This correlator containing fundamental Wilson lines coincides, up to Casimir scaling, with one of the three adjoint correlators considered in this work. The paper is structured as follows. First, we give precise definitions of the three gauge-invariant chromoelectric correlators that can be constructed from two chromoelectric fields and Wilson lines in the adjoint representation, and discuss their distinct physical meanings. Next, we evaluate the adjoint correlators up to next-to-leading order (NLO). We use modern integration-by-parts methodology to factorise the vast majority of the integrals into one-loop integrals with known closed forms. Lastly, we show our results and discuss their implications in view of recent lattice findings. The work is completed by a set of more technical appendices. 2 The chromoelectric correlators in the adjoint representation We define three distinct chromoelectric correlators in the adjoint representation: the upper correlator ( U ), the lower correlator ( L ), and the symmetric correlator ( S ), which are defined as \displaystyle\left\langle EE\right\rangle_{U}\equiv \displaystyle-\left\langle g_{s}E^{a}_{i}(0)U^{ab}(0,t)g_{s}E^{b}_{i}(t)\right\rangle T^{-4}, (1) \displaystyle\left\langle EE\right\rangle_{L}\equiv \displaystyle-\left\langle g_{s}E^{b}_{i}(0)g_{s}E^{a}_{i}(t)U^{ab}(t,1/T)\right\rangle T^{-4}, (2) \displaystyle\left\langle EE\right\rangle_{S}\equiv \displaystyle-\left\langle g_{s}E_{i}^{ab}(0)U^{bc}(0,t)g_{s}E_{i}^{cd}(t)U^{da}(t,1/T)\right\rangle T^{-4}, (3) respectively. We have divided the correlators by T^{4} in order to make them dimensionless. Above, E_{i}^{a}(t) are the components of the chromoelectric field, U^{ab}(t,t^{\prime}) are the components of a Wilson line in the adjoint representation connecting points on the Euclidean thermal circle (0,1/T) at times t and t^{\prime} , and E^{ab}_{i}(t)\equiv x_{abc}E^{c}_{i}(t) with x_{abc}\in\{f_{abc},d_{abc}\} , (f_{abc})\,d_{abc} being the (anti-)symmetric structure constants of \mathrm{SU}(N_{c}) . The angular brackets stand for thermal field theory averages. For precise definitions of the Wilson line and the chromoelectric field, see Appendix A . Here, we only consider quantities at the spatial origin, and because of that we suppress the dependence on the spatial coordinates. The three correlators have distinct interpretations. The upper correlator is a widely-studied quantity associated with quarkonium dissociation in pNRQCD Brambilla:2016wgg ; Brambilla:2017zei ; Binder:2021otw , while the lower correlator, or rather its real-time counterpart, is associated with recombination Yao:2020eqy . In Euclidean space, the two are related by \langle EE\rangle_{U}(t)=\langle EE\rangle_{L}(1/T-t) . The symmetric correlator with antisymmetric structure constants has no known simple physical application but appears to be related to the diffusion of adjoint heavy