Major issues in theory of Bose-Einstein condensation
2025
Read Major issues in theory of Bose-Einstein condensation (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16600.txt.
Introduction
Yukalov reviews stubborn confusions in the theory of Bose-Einstein condensation in a 2025 paper. In this state, many atoms fall into one quantum state at extreme cold. The review argues that one point decides the whole theory: global gauge symmetry must break for condensation to occur.
Ignoring that point breeds famous phantom problems, the author shows. One such phantom is a claimed catastrophe in a standard statistical scheme, which vanishes under the right treatment. Skipping stability checks is a second common flaw, yielding long studies of systems that cannot exist. Clearing these traps matters for cold-atom labs and theory alike.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2025 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16600
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Major issues in theory of Bose-Einstein condensation Abstract Major issues arising in the theory of Bose-Einstein condensation are reviewed. These issues, although being principally important, are very often misunderstood, which results in wrong conclusions. The basic point is global gauge symmetry breaking that is a necessary and sufficient condition for Bose-Einstein condensation. Paying no attention to this basic point is a common fallacy leading to a number of confusions. For instance, the attempt of describing Bose condensation without gauge symmetry breaking produces the so-called “grand canonical catastrophe” that actually does not exist in the correct description of Bose condensation accompanied by gauge symmetry breaking. The other common flaw is forgetting to consider the stability of the studied systems. One sometimes accomplishes lengthy calculations and discusses the properties of a system that in reality cannot exist being unstable. In some cases, the seeming instability is caused by the negligence of the simple mathematical reason teaching us that one should not go beyond the approximation applicability. An example of such an artificial instability is related to the appearance of the so-called “thermodynamically anomalous fluctuations” whose arising is due to the use of a second-order approximation for calculating fourth-order terms, in this way distorting the O ( 2 ) O(2) -class model of a Bose-condensed system to the Gaussian-class model. These and other principal points, important for the correct treatment of Bose-condensed systems, are reviewed, including the resolution of the Hohenberg-Martin dilemma of gapless versus conserving theories for Bose-condensed systems and the problem of statistical ensemble equivalence. V.I. Yukalov 1,2 1 Bogolubov Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna 141980, Russia 2 Instituto de Fisica de São Carlos, Universidade de São Paulo, CP 369, São Carlos 13560-970, São Paulo, Brazil E-mail : [email protected] Content I . Introduction II . Criterion of Bose-Einstein condensation III . Gauge symmetry breaking A. Gauge symmetry B. Method of quasi-averages C. Bogolubov theorem D. Condensate existence E. Ginibre theorem F. Roepstorff theorem G. Bogolubov shift IV . Unitary inequivalent representations V . Thermodynamic stability VI . Dynamic stability VII . Absence of “grand canonical catastrophe” VIII . Instability of ideal Bose gas IX . Role of dimensionality X . Power-law trapping potentials XI . Resolution of Hohenberg-Martin dilemma XII . Condensate wave function XIII . Self-consistent mean-field approach XIV . Normal versus symmetry-broken averages XV . Absence of thermodynamically anomalous fluctuations XVI . Fluctuation indices for composite observables XVII . Equivalence of statistical ensembles XVIII . Conclusion I Introduction Bose-Einstein statistics and the related Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) was advanced 100 years ago [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . The microscopic theory of weakly interacting Bose gases at low temperature was put forward by Bogolubov [ 4 ] in 1947 (see also the books [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] ). The Bogolubov theory proved to well agree with the experiments on BEC in very weakly interacting trapped Bose gases at low temperature, first observed in 1995 [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . However, in the theory of BEC at finite temperature and interactions till nowadays there remain several problems not well understood and resulting in a number of confusions that persuasively appear in many publications. This is the aim of the present review to discuss the major subtle points of the BEC theory at arbitrary interactions and temperature. The criterion for the occurrence of BEC is recalled in Sec. II. The principal starting point of the theoretical description of BEC is the understanding that for the very existence of BEC the global gauge symmetry breaking is necessary and sufficient, which is a rigorous mathematical fact (Sec. III). Forgetting this fact leads to various fallacies and wrong conclusions, as will be shown below. From the mathematical point of view, the systems with broken gauge symmetry and without its breaking live in different Fock spaces that are orthogonal to each other, so that, when BEC occurs, it is basically wrong to continue working in a gauge symmetric Fock space (Sec. IV). The other point, that is often forgotten, is the necessity of checking the stability of the studied system. Formally, in theory, the system may show BEC, although, being unstable, it actually cannot exist, which happens with the uniform ideal Bose gas in three dimensions. Sometimes, one distinguishes thermodynamic stability (Sec. V) and dynamic stability (Sec. VI), which for an equilibrium system result in the same stability conditions. In the current literature, to great surprise, there is a very widely spread myth on the existence of the so-called “great canonical catastrophe”, when particle fluctuations of BEC become catastrophically large. One even tries to observe them in experiment, forgetting that such catastrophic fluctuations would make the system extremely unstable, hence it would not be able to exist at al. Meanwhile, there is no any “great canonical catastrophe”, but its appearance is caused by the incorrect treatment of BEC without breaking gauge symmetry. In a system with broken gauge symmetry, no catastrophic condensate fluctuations arise, but moreover the condensate particle fluctuations are actually absent (Sec. VII). The catastrophic condensate fluctuations exist neither in an ideal gas nor in an interacting Bose gas. Nevertheless, in a uniform ideal Bose gas in three dimensions, there are large fluctuations of non-condensed particles, which implies the ideal-gas instability (Sec. VII). Fortunately, any infinitesimally small interactions stabilize the gas. Stability of Bose-condensed systems depends on the space dimensionality. Even ideal uniform Bose-condensed gas can be stabilized in dimensionality d>4 (Sec. IX). Stability of trapped Bose gases depends on the trap shape, which is shown for power-law trapping potentials (Sec. X). The description of realistic Bose-condensed systems of interacting atoms confronts the Hohenberg-Martin dilemma of conserving versus gapless theories. The problem is that, as soon as BEC occurs, hence global gauge symmetry becomes broken, the standard treatment of BEC leads either to the appearance of an unphysical gap in the spectrum of collective excitations or to the inconsistency of thermodynamic relations. The resolution of this dilemma requires the use of a representative ensemble, where all conditions uniquely characterizing the system are to be taken into account. Then we get a self-consistent theory that is conserving and gapless (Sec. XI). The difference between the condensate wave function and coherent vacuum field is elucidated (Sec. XII). The vacuum field, whose mathematical structure is that of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation, does not exhaust the conventional mean-field picture, but it is just a very particular case that can be applied to weakly interacting Bose gases at zero temperature. The overall mean-field approach is presented by the Hartree-Fock-Bogolubov approximation (Sec. XIII). The latter, being employed in the frame of a representative ensemble, is self-consistent, conserving, and gapless, at the same time taking account of gauge symmetry breaking. While the Hartree and Hartree-Fock approximations, not respecting gauge symmetry breaking, cannot be used for characterizing Bose-condensed systems. As soon as global gauge symmetry is broken, the theory has to take into account both the normal as well as symmetry-broken averages. The latter are termed as anomalous averages, although being not merely regular for a system with broken gauge symmetry, but moreover being compulsory for its correct description (Sec. XIV). The omission of the symmetry-broken averages makes