Spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers revisited
J. Klimeš, P. Soldán · 2025
Read Spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers revisited by J. Klimeš, P. Soldán (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16489.txt.
Introduction
Jiří Klimeš and Pavel Soldán revisit a theory question about clusters of three alkali metal atoms with their spins lined up. Such trimers, one for each of the five alkali metals, sit in their lowest energy state, and their shapes and binding strengths are key facts about them.
Using top grade quantum chemistry at three levels of care, the pair find the best bond length for each trimer, from lithium to cesium. They set the values next to past theory and to fresh lab results from laser based blasts that blow the clusters apart. They also name more theory work that could help read the lab data on two of the metals.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Klimeš, P. Soldán |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 16 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16489
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers revisited Preprint: AIP/123-QED J. Klimeš, P. Soldán Abstract Homonuclear spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers in their lowest-lying electronic state are investigated theoretically. Their equilibrium geometries and binding energies are determined with the state-of-the-art quantum chemical methods at three levels of approximation. The equilibrium geometries obtained R eq ( Li 3 ) = 3.100 R_{\rm eq}({\rm Li}_{3})=3.100 Å, R eq ( Na 3 ) = 4.353 R_{\rm eq}({\rm Na}_{3})=4.353 Å, R eq ( K 3 ) = 4.996 R_{\rm eq}({\rm K}_{3})=4.996 Å, R eq ( Rb 3 ) = 5.391 R_{\rm eq}({\rm Rb}_{3})=5.391 Å, and R eq ( Cs 3 ) = 5.730 R_{\rm eq}({\rm Cs}_{3})=5.730 Å are compared to the other theoretical results and also with the very recent experimental results obtained through the laser-induced Coulomb explosion. Further theoretical studies are proposed, which could help with better interpretation of the experimental results for the sodium and cesium trimers. Alkali metals have played pivotal roles in cold and ultracold physics studies. The successful production of alkali-metal dimers in specific states through photoassociation experiments together with the manipulation of scattering properties by exploiting Feshbach resonances opened doors for controlled ultracold chemistry. Langen-manipulation-2024 ; Karman-chemistry-2024 It also instigated extensive studies of alkali-metal atom+dimer collision processes, which in turn required good-quality alkali-metal trimer potential energy surfaces. First, the attention focused on the spin-polarized trimers, whose ground electronic states (1 4 A {}^{{}^{\prime}}_{2} ) are not subject to the Jahn-Teller effect, and their equilibrium geometries exhibit the D_{3h} symmetry (equilateral triangle). In these cases, the corresponding pair-wise additive potentials were not sufficient because in the alkali-metal trimers the three-body non-additive interactions are very strong. They are shortening the trimer equilibrium bond lengths by 0.5-1.0 Å with respect to the dimer equilibrium bond lengths and contributing 49-130 % to the binding energies. Higgins-Na3-1996 ; 3body-2003 ; Hetero-2010 Consequently, potential energy surfaces of the lowest spin-polarized states (1 4 A {}^{{}^{\prime}}_{2} ) were published for lithium, Colavecchia-Li3-2003 ; Li3-2007 sodium, Higgins-Na3-2000 ; Na3-2009 potassium, K3-2005 ; K3-2008 ; Hauser-K3-2010 rubidium, Rb3-2010 ; Schnabel-Rb3-2021 ; Bormotova-Rb3-2024 and cesium trimers. Cs3-2009 It has to be noted that except for Na 3 (ref. [ Higgins-Na3-1996 ]) there were no experimental data for spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers available prior 2000. Recently, the importance of three-body interactions in spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers was probed by explaining experimental measurements with theoretical modeling in ultracold spin-polarized NaLi+Na collisions. Park:2023 ; Karman:2023 Very recently, an experimental study focused on determining the structure of spin-polarized Na 3 , K 3 , Rb 3 , and Cs 3 on helium nanodroplets through the laser-induced Coulomb explosion. Experiment-2024 The equilibrium internuclear distances in the 1 4 A {}^{{}^{\prime}}_{2} electronic states determined from the experiment were compared with some of the available theoretical results. Very good agreement (well within the experimental uncertainties) was found for the potassium and rubidium trimers, while a larger discrepancy (0.2-0.3 Å) for the sodium trimer was attributed to a minor internuclear motion during the laser pulse. In the case of cesium, the observations did not lead to an unambiguous determination of its quantum state. As can be seen in Table 1 , where the experimental results (second column) and previous theoretical results (third column) are collected, the spread of the theoretical results is not small, with the exception of the lithium trimer. The goal of our study is to determine the equilibrium inter-nuclear bond lengths of the spin-polarized homonuclear alkali-metal trimers at the highest possible level of theory available to us with the aim of recovering as much of the correlation energy as possible. Our approach is based on the minimization of three trimer functions E^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}}(R) , E^{\rm T}(R) , and E^{({\rm Q})}(R) , which describe the interaction energy of homonuclear alkali-metal trimers in equilateral geometries (where all three bond lengths are equal to R ) with respect to the dissociation limit of three separated atoms and are calculated at three different levels of approximation. For the evaluation of the trimer functions we use the following formulae E^{\rm T}(R)=E^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}}(R)+\Delta E_{\rm T}(R), (1) E^{({\rm Q})}(R)=E^{\rm T}(R)+\Delta E_{({\rm Q})}(R), (2) where E^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}}(R) is the interaction energy calculated at the UCCSD-T level on the RHF reference Deegan:1994 extrapolated to the complete basis set limit Halkier:1998 (CBS) using the aug-cc-pwCVQZ and aug-cc-pwCV5Z basis sets. Prascher:2011 ; Hill:2017 \Delta E_{\rm T}(R) is the full-triples Kallay:2001 correction term \Delta E_{\rm T}(R)=E^{\rm T}(R)-E^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}}(R) (3) calculated using the aug-cc-pwCVQZ basis set for lithium and aug-cc-pwCVTZ for the rest of the elements. Prascher:2011 ; Hill:2017 \Delta E_{({\rm Q})}(R) is the perturbative-quadruples Kallay:2005 ; Kallay:2008 correction term \Delta E_{({\rm Q})}(R)=E^{({\rm Q})}(R)-E^{\rm T}(R). (4) calculated using aug-cc-pwCVTZ for lithium Prascher:2011 and aug-cc-pwCVDZ for the other alkali metals. Hill:2017 All the interaction energies calculated are counterpoise corrected for the basis set superposition error. BSSE In the case of lithium trimer all nine electrons were correlated. In the case of sodium trimer, 27 electrons were correlated, thus excluding six electrons in the three lowest molecular orbitals. In the cases of potassium, rubidium, and cesium trimers, small-core relativistic pseudopotentials Lim:2005 were used to describe inner-core electrons, and all 27 electrons remaining as the large valence were correlated. The UCCSD-T energies were calculated using the MOLPRO program suite MOLPRO-WIREs ; MOLPRO-JCP and the correction terms using the MRCC program suite. MRCC-JCP (Recently, a similar approach was used to study reactions of alkaline-earth-metal diatomic molecules Tomza-reactions:2023 and to determine the interaction potentials of diatomic molecules consisting of alkali-metal and alkaline-earth-metal atoms. Tomza-Dimers:2024 ) For each species, the CBS interaction energies E^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}}(R) and trimer functions E^{\rm T}(R) , and E^{({\rm Q})}(R) were evaluated on a grid of several points near the suspected minimum. From these, the actual minimum bond lengths R_{\rm eq}^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}} , R_{\rm eq}^{\rm T} , and R_{\rm eq}^{({\rm Q})} were determined. Then single-point calculations were performed at the minimum geometries ( R_{\rm eq}^{({\rm Q})} ) for each species to determine individual contributions to the interaction energies. Table 1: D_{3h} equilibrium bond lengths (Å) for the homonuclear spin-polarized alkali-metal trimers in the 1 4 A {}^{{}^{\prime}}_{2} electronic state. Experiment a Other theory R_{\rm eq}^{\mbox{-}{\rm T}} R_{\rm eq}^{\rm T} R_{\rm eq}^{({\rm Q})} T1 Li 3 - 3.103, {}^{b}\; 3.09, {}^{c}\; 3.1016, {}^{d}\; 3.102 {}^{e}\; 3.098 3.100 \mathbf{3.100} 0.025 Na 3 4.65 \pm 0.15 4.428, {}^{b}\; 4.33, {}^{c}\; 4.406, {}^{f}\; 4.34 g 4.369 4.352 \mathbf{4.353} 0.009 K 3 5.03 \pm 0.18 5.084, {}^{b}\; 4.95, {}^{c}\; 5.09, {}^{h}\; 5.05 i 5.007 5.000 \mathbf{4.996} 0.018 Rb 3 5.45 \pm 0.22 5.596, {}^{b}\; 5.35, {}^{c}\; 5.50, {}^{i}\; 5.45, {}^{j}\; 5.311 k,l 5.416 5.395 \mathbf{5.391} 0.020 Cs 3 - 5.992, {}^{b}\; 5.56, {}^{c}\; 5.92, {}^{m}\; 5.67, {}^{m}\; 5.708 5.734 \mathbf{5.730} 0.041 {}^{a}\; Ref. Experiment-2024 , {}^{b}\; Ref. 3body-2003 , {}^{c}\; Ref. Hetero-2010 , {}^{d}\; Ref. Colavecchia-Li3-2003 , {}^{e}\; Ref. Li3-2007 , {}^{f}\; Ref. Higgins-Na3-2000 , {}^{g}\; Ref. Na3-2009 , {}^{h}\; Ref. K3-2005 , {}^{i}\; Ref. Hauser-K3-2010 , {}^{j}\; Ref. Rb3-2010 , {}^{k}\; Ref. Schnabel-Rb3-2021 , {}^{l}\; Ref. Bormotova-Rb3-2024 , {}^{m}\; Ref. Cs3-2009 . Our resulting equilibrium bond lengths are collected in the fourth, fifth, and sixth columns of Table 1 , while the contributions to the corresponding interaction energies are collected in the second, third, and fifth columns of Table 2 . Generally, the effect of