Light Black Holes from Light

Don N. Page · 2025

Read Light Black Holes from Light by Don N. Page (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16202.txt.

Introduction

Don Page answers a claim that black holes cannot be made from light alone. A recent paper had argued that quantum effects, as light squeezes itself, bleed off energy fast enough to stop any event horizon from forming. Page's 2025 note grants that such black holes are wildly unlikely in our universe, whether by nature or by any human effort we can foresee.

He argues, though, that the ban is not absolute. In idealized setups, nearly flat pulses of light can be crashed together to form black holes of almost any size, down toward the Planck length. Only a small share of the energy escapes, as scattered light or as electron-positron pairs. The note draws a line between what physics forbids and what practice merely rules out. That line is the heart of the dispute over these light-born black holes, called kugelblitze.

Catalog record

CREATORDon N. Page
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16202

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Light Black Holes from Light Don N. Page Abstract Álvarez-Domínguez, Garay, Martin-Martínez, and Polo-Gómez [ 1 ] have suggested that “it is not possible to concentrate enough light to precipitate the formation of an event horizon. We argue that the dissipative quantum effects coming from the self-interaction of light (such as vacuum polarization) are enough to prevent any meaningful buildup of energy that could create a black hole in any realistic scenario,” and “the dissipation of energy via Schwinger effect alone is enough to prevent the formation of kugelblitze with radii ranging from 10 − 29 10^{-29} to 10 8 10^{8} m.” While I agree that it is indeed highly implausible that black holes will form mainly from light in our actual universe, either naturally or by any foreseeable human activity, there are many idealized theoretical processes for forming black holes of any size down to near the Planck length (about 10 − 35 10^{-35} m) purely from photons, such as from colliding approximately plane-wave pulses, with only a small fraction of the energy escaping the black hole as scattered light or electron-positron pairs. 1 Introduction Álvarez-Domínguez, Garay, Martin-Martínez, and Polo-Gómez [ 1 ] (see also [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] ) have noted that if one has a collapsing gas of photons of mass less than about 10^{5}M_{\odot} [which in Planck units is about 1.8\times 10^{43} , close to 1.6\times 10^{43}\approx q/(\pi m^{2}) that is one definition, when \pi is included, of the reciprocal of the critical electric field for the pair production of electrons and positrons of charge magnitude q=\sqrt{\alpha}\sim\sqrt{1/137} and mass m\approx 4.2\times 10^{-23} in Planck units], when it gets sufficiently compacted that it would form a black hole if the photons interacted purely gravitationally, actually the production of electron-positron pairs will lead to the dissipation of the energy before a black hole can form. Under realistic situations in our universe, such as their assumption of photons traveling largely in random directions at each location, their conclusion seems to be valid. However, I shall argue that their assumptions and conclusions are not so universally valid as many of their statements suggest. Instead, there certainly exist idealized situations (initial states with virtually all of the energy in photons) which can form black holes of any mass greater than approximately the minimum mass for a black hole, which is presumably near the Planck mass (about 2.2\times 10^{-8} kg or 1.1\times 10^{-38}M_{\odot} ), with a minimum size near the Planck length (about 1.6\times 10^{-35} m), nearly 43 orders of magnitude smaller than the lower limit proposed by Álvarez-Domínguez, Garay, Martin-Martínez, and Polo-Gómez [ 1 ] . To allow the photon energy to collapse into a black hole, the main situation to be avoided is for many different photons to be traveling in significantly different directions at the same location to produce many electron-positron pairs, until the photon energy gets concentrated enough to form a black hole that engulfs the electron-positron pairs and prevents them from escaping. For slowly varying classical electromagnetic fields, one generally needs to keep a combination of the Lorentz invariants \mathbf{E}^{2}-\mathbf{B}^{2} and \mathbf{E}\cdot\mathbf{B} from getting near the Schwinger critical value, say \sqrt{\mathbf{E}^{2}-\mathbf{B}^{2}}=m^{2}/q for m and q the mass and charge of the positron (now for brevity not including a factor of \pi ), for the rapid production of electron-positron pairs before the energy becomes sufficiently concentrated that it forms a black hole. These invariants are zero for plane electromagnetic waves, and if one keeps the energy nearly in plane waves (the photons traveling in nearly the same direction) in each region before that region becomes engulfed by a black hole, significant pair production to disperse the energy before it forms a black hole can be avoided. In the limit that one has a single photon, since it will be in a superposition of plane wave states, each of which will not interact with itself to form electron-positron pairs, the superposition state will also not form pairs. Of course, such a one-photon quantum state also cannot form a black hole. However, if one takes a two-photon state with total center-of-momentum (COM) energy M sufficiently larger than the minimum needed to form a black hole, then their collision can form a black hole, with a cross section that will be of the order of M^{2} in the Planck units that I am using, \hbar=c=G=4\pi\epsilon_{0}=1 (1) In contrast, the Breit-Wheeler cross section [ 7 , 8 ] for the formation of electron-positron pairs (each particle with the electron mass m and with charge magnitude q=\sqrt{\alpha} , using q instead of the more common e for the elementary charge to avoid confusion with the e that I use many times below as the exponential of 1) for M^{2}\sim 1 is \approx 16\pi\alpha^{2}\ln{(M/m)}M^{-2}\sim 0.14\,M^{-2} , which is less than the cross section to form a black hole for M>1 . Thus a pair of photons with COM total energy M sufficiently larger than the Planck energy will be significantly more probable to form a black hole than an electron-positron pair. Furthermore, since when M\gg 1 , in the COM frame the wavelength of each of the two highly energetic photons, being of the order of 1/M\ll 1 , is small enough so that in principle one can focus the two photons into a region smaller than the size \sim M . Thus the collapse into a black hole can not only be much more probable than pair production, but also can have a probability near unity. When one considers the case of many photons, each of angular frequency or energy \omega much less than the Planck energy (1 in my units here), the wavelength 2\pi/\omega\gg 1 puts a limit on how small a region the photons can be focused into before gravitational collapse can take over. This limit gives an order-of-magnitude limit M>1/\omega for the mass and hence linear size of the black hole, and therefore a minimum number of photons N>M/\omega>1/\omega^{2} of angular frequency \omega that can be focused to form a black hole. One can now take these N photons, each of angular frequency \omega\stackrel{{\scriptstyle>}}{{\sim}}1/\sqrt{N} , and put them into two truncated approximately parallel plane wave pulses approaching each other, with characteristic pulse length of the order of L along the direction of propagation (say along the z -axis) and radial size r in the transverse directions (parallel to the x - y plane, so \sqrt{x^{2}+y^{2}}<r ), obeying the following inequalities: \omega^{-1}\leq L<r/2<M=N\omega>\sqrt{N}>\omega^{-1}. (2) There is no obstruction to approximately saturating these inequalities and still avoiding dissipating the energy into electron-positron pairs that escape the black hole, so for a number of photons N that is not too large, one can form a black hole of mass M not much larger than \sqrt{N} and hence not much larger than the Planck mass. 2 Colliding Antiparallel Polarized Plane Wave Pulses To give a concrete model for forming a black hole of mass of any mass larger than some lower limit near the Planck mass, I shall put the electromagnetic energy into two colliding pulses, propagating in opposite directions, parallel and antiparallel to the z -axis, with the pulses being plane waves parallel to the x

Read the complete text