Persuasive Prediction via Decision Calibration

Jingwu Tang, Jiahao Zhang, Fei Fang, Zhiwei Steven Wu · 2025

Read Persuasive Prediction via Decision Calibration by Jingwu Tang, Jiahao Zhang, Fei Fang, Zhiwei Steven Wu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16141.txt.

Introduction

Jingwu Tang, Jiahao Zhang, Fei Fang, and Zhiwei Steven Wu study how predictions can persuade, in a 2025 paper. Classic theory on persuasion assumes the sender and the receiver share exact knowledge of how likely each state of the world is. With huge or endless state spaces, no one can learn that shared picture from data.

The authors set up a learning version of the problem. Here the sender watches features of each case, learns from past data, and publishes a prediction meant to steer a crowd of receivers. They define a fairness-like condition on the prediction: it must stay unbiased once the receiver's best reply is taken into account. Any receiver replying greedily then has no regrets. Under that condition, the authors give an efficient learning method that, for a single receiver, matches what a sender with full knowledge could win.

Catalog record

CREATORJingwu Tang, Jiahao Zhang, Fei Fang, Zhiwei Steven Wu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE278 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16141

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Persuasive Prediction via Decision Calibration Jingwu Tang, Jiahao Zhang, Fei Fang, Zhiwei Steven Wu Abstract Bayesian persuasion, a central model in information design, studies how a sender, who privately observes a state drawn from a prior distribution, strategically sends a signal to influence a receiver’s action. A key assumption is that both sender and receiver share the precise knowledge of the prior. Although this prior can be estimated from past data, such assumptions break down in high-dimensional or infinite state spaces, where learning an accurate prior may require a prohibitive amount of data. In this paper, we study a learning-based variant of persuasion, which we term persuasive prediction . This setting mirrors Bayesian persuasion with large state spaces, but crucially does not assume a common prior: the sender observes covariates X X , learns to predict a payoff-relevant outcome Y Y from past data, and releases a prediction to influence a population of receivers. To model rational receiver behavior without a common prior, we adopt a learnable proxy: decision calibration , which requires the prediction to be unbiased conditioned on the receiver’s best response to the prediction. This condition guarantees that myopically responding to the prediction yields no swap regret. Assuming the receivers best respond to decision-calibrated predictors, we design a computationally and statistically efficient algorithm that learns a decision-calibrated predictor within a randomized predictor class that optimizes the sender’s utility. In the commonly studied single-receiver case, our method matches the utility of a Bayesian sender who has full knowledge of the underlying prior distribution. Finally, we extend our algorithmic result to a setting where receivers respond stochastically to predictions and the sender may randomize over an infinite predictor class. 1 Introduction The strategic disclosure of information to influence downstream decisions—commonly studied under the information design literature (see e.g., Bergemann et al. (2023) )—has become a central topic in economic theory. A foundational model in this area is Bayesian persuasion , introduced by Kamenica and Gentzkow (2011) , which formalizes how a sender , who privately observes an underlying state unknown to the receiver , can send a signal to shape the receiver’s belief and ultimately influence their chosen action. Crucially, the sender is endowed with the power of commitment —the ability to credibly commit to a signaling scheme in advance. Based on the committed signaling scheme, the receiver updates their beliefs upon receiving the signal and selects an action accordingly. Both receivers have utility functions that depend on the state and the receiver’s action, but these utilities are typically misaligned, so that the sender needs to strategically design their scheme. A key assumption underpinning Bayesian persuasion—and much of information design—is the existence of a common prior : a probability distribution over the state space that both the sender and receiver have precise knowledge about. The most obvious source for such a probability distribution is past data. However, in many real-world environments, the state space may be high-dimensional or even infinite, which makes it challenging to estimate an accurate prior distribution from finite data. A natural example is the following setting of prediction for decision making. Persuasive prediction problem. The data (x,y)\in\mathcal{X}\times\mathcal{Y} are drawn from a joint distribution \mathcal{D} . The sender observes a realization x of \mathcal{X} , and seeks to predict the unobserved outcome y . Both the sender’s and the receiver’s utilities depend on the receiver’s action and the unknown outcome Y , but not directly on X . Upon observing x , the sender provides a prediction f(x) , which acts as a signal to inform the receiver’s decision. In the language of Bayesian persuasion, the sender’s observed state corresponds to the posterior distribution \mathbb{P}[Y\mid X=x] , and the prior is the marginal distribution over such posterior distributions, which is effectively \mathcal{D} . However, when \mathcal{X} is high-dimensional or infinite, learning the prior \mathcal{D} from finite past data can be infeasible. This persuasive prediction framework captures a wide range of real-world scenarios where the sender observes high-dimensional covariates describing the state of the world and aims to shape individual decisions toward a socially desirable outcome. For example, a government agency may forecast regional agriculture conditions based on global climate indicators to guide farmers’ crop choices, or a utility provider may issue grid stress forecasts using weather and demand data to encourage energy-saving behavior. In both cases, individuals act independently based on public predictions, and the sender seeks to optimize a global objective, such as food diversity or grid stability. When data are insufficient to recover the full prior, persuasive prediction presents two central challenges: How should receiver behavior be modeled in the absence of a common prior? And can the sender, using only finite data, achieve utility comparable to that of a fully informed Bayesian sender with exact knowledge of the distribution \mathcal{D} ? 1.1 Our Results and Techniques In persuasive prediction, a sender learns a predictor f from past data such that upon observing X=x , they will send the prediction f(x) to a population of receivers, who will then select their actions. The sender’s goal is to optimize their utility that depends jointly on the unknown outcome Y and the joint action chosen by the receivers. Our results establish a connection between (Bayesian) persuasion and decision calibration Zhao et al. (2021) , which allows a learning-based approach for modeling incentives without requiring full knowledge of the prior. Behavioral modeling via decision calibration. Informally, a (possibly randomized) predictor f\colon\mathcal{X}\rightarrow\mathcal{Y} is decision-calibrated if, for every receiver with utility function v_{i} and every action a_{i} , \mathbb{E}_{f,(X,Y)\sim\mathcal{D}}\left[Y-f(X)\mid\arg\max_{a}v_{i}(f(X),a)=a_{i}\right]=0. (1) Intuitively, decision calibration captures a natural notion of credibility: conditioned on any event defined by the receiver’s best response, the predictor f(X) must be an unbiased estimate of the true outcome Y . A predictor is approximately decision-calibrated if condition equation 1 holds up to a small additive error. We show that myopically best responding to an approximately decision-calibrated, receivers obtain low swap regret (Lemma 2.1 ). This motivates a clean behavioral assumption that receivers best respond to approximately decision calibrated predictions. Efficient optimal persuasive prediction. Suppose the sender is allowed to use a stochastic predictor f\in\Delta(\mathcal{H}) , that is, a distribution over deterministic predictors in some finite class \mathcal{H} . Our first main result is a statistically efficient algorithm that learns a predictor f that optimizes the sender’s utility within the class of decision-calibrated predictors in \Delta(\mathcal{H}) . The core technical idea is to formulate the learning problem as a zero-sum game between a min player , who updates the predictor, and an max player , who identifies the most violated calibration constraint. Simulating no-regret dynamics between the two players yields a minimax equilibrium, which recovers the optimal decision-calibrated predictor. The number of required samples scales polynomially in the number of receiver actions and the dimension of \mathcal{Y} , and is independent of the size |\mathcal{X}| . Our algorithm is also oracle-efficient in the sense that it runs in polynomial time when given access to an ERM oracle over \mathcal{H} . Matching the Bayesian benchmark. In the special case of a single receiver, we show that the sender utility achieved by our algorithm matches that of a fully informed Bayesian sender who is restricted to sending signals induced

Read the complete text