Uniqueness of star central configurations in the 5 5 -body problem 0 0 footnotetext: Mathematics Subject Classification(2010): 70F10, 70F15 0 0 footnotetext: Keywords: Central Configuration, Regular polygon configuration, 5 5 -body problem, Uniqueness

Leasly A. Campa-Raymundo · 2025

Read Uniqueness of star central configurations in the 5 5 -body problem 0 0 footnotetext: Mathematics Subject Classification(2010): 70F10, 70F15 0 0 footnotetext: Keywords: Central Configuration, Regular polygon configuration, 5 5 -body problem, Uniqueness by Leasly A. Campa-Raymundo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-16101.txt.

Introduction

Five equal masses placed at the corners of a flat shape and held by their own gravity can spin as one rigid pattern only in special arrangements, called central configurations. For five bodies spaced evenly in angle around their center, Leasly Campa-Raymundo and a co-author ask whether any shape besides the regular pentagon works, in this 2025 paper.

The proof is fully analytic, with no numerical shortcuts. The governing equations shrink to a system in just two variables. The authors bound the search region and split it into sixteen disjoint pieces. In each piece, plain algebra rules out any solution. Only the regular pentagon survives. The result closes the symmetric equal-mass case for five bodies and adds a clean uniqueness theorem to a problem famous for resisting general answers.

Catalog record

CREATORLeasly A. Campa-Raymundo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE103 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-16101

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Uniqueness of star central configurations in the 5 5 -body problem 0 0 footnotetext: Mathematics Subject Classification(2010): 70F10, 70F15 0 0 footnotetext: Keywords: Central Configuration, Regular polygon configuration, 5 5 -body problem, Uniqueness Leasly A. Campa-Raymundo Abstract Abstract In this study, we present a rigorous analytical proof of the uniqueness of central configurations for the five-body problem, assuming that all five masses are equal and positioned at the vertices of a planar polygon. We consider configurations in which the bodies are equally spaced in angular position relative to the center of mass, and aim to determine whether a central configuration arises under these constraints. We prove that the only central configuration that satisfies these conditions occurs when the five bodies form a regular pentagon. Our approach is entirely analytical, relying on algebraic techniques rather than numerical approximations. By transforming the governing equations into a reduced system involving only two variables, we analyze the solution space over a significant and carefully bounded domain. This domain is divided into sixteen disjoint regions, within which we rule out additional solutions through explicit algebraic arguments. Our results confirm that the regular pentagonal configuration is the only central configuration in this symmetric five-body scenario. 1 Introduction The n -body problem is an important part of Celestial Mechanics. It involves studying the movement of n point masses that interact only through universal gravitational forces. The case where n=2 has been solved, with the two bodies following conic trajectories. However, for n>3 , solutions are limited to specific scenarios called homographic solutions. These solutions, also called self-similar solutions, remain constant under rotations and scaling, and are the only explicit solutions known for the n -body problem. A central configuration is a specific arrangement of the positions of the masses that gives rise to self-similar solutions. Therefore, central configurations are counted modulo these types of motions. The question of the existence and classification of central configurations is a historical problem that dates back to the eighteenth century. In 1767, Euler [ 28 ] discovered three central configurations for n=3 , where the masses lie on the same line for all time, called the collinear configurations . Five years later, Lagrange [ 11 ] proved that an equilateral triangle, with each mass located at each vertex, is also a central configuration. Much later, in 1910, Moulton [ 18 ] found that the exact count of collinear central configurations of n bodies corresponds to n!/2 . These results hold for any choice of the masses. The task of determining the number of planar central configurations in the n -body problem for arbitrary positive masses is quite challenging. When n=3 , there are five central configurations - two in an equilateral configuration and the rest in a collinear configuration. Long and Sun [ 14 ] provided some partial and interesting results when considering 4 bodies with equal opposite masses \beta>\alpha>0 . Additionally, Perez-Chavela and Santoprete [ 19 ] demonstrated a unique convex non-collinear central configuration when the opposite masses are equal. In 2008, Albouy, Fu, and Sun [ 2 ] proved that a convex central configuration is symmetric for one diagonal if and only if the masses of the two particles on the other diagonal are equal. The finiteness of central configurations is crucial for their counting, and Smale [ 22 ] listed it as the 6th problem in 2002. It is important to note that the finiteness problem was settled by Albouy [ 1 ] in 1995. When considering four equal masses, Hampton and Moeckel [ 10 ] used symbolic calculations by computer to show that the number of central configurations is always between 32 and 8472, up to symmetry. The polygonal central configurations, where each body is positioned at each vertex of a regular polygon, have been extensively analyzed. When all the masses are equal, then any regular n -gon can form a central configuration [ 16 ] . Nested polygonal central configurations have also been studied . In 2003, Zhang and Zhou [ 27 ] established some necessary and sufficient conditions for the nested polygonal solutions of planar 2n -body problems . In 2012, Yu and Zhang [ 24 ] researched necessary and sufficient conditions for twisted nested central configurations formed by two twisted regular polygons with n masses, respectively. The angle of twisting must be \theta=0 or \theta=\pi/n . Later, in 2015, they proved [ 28 ] that under these conditions, the central configuration requires that the two polygons must have n vertices. In particular, Moczurad and Zgliczynski [ 15 ] provided a computer-assisted classification of all central configurations with equal masses for n=5,6,7 , using interval arithmetic methods. Their results include a broader set of configurations, and establish existence and symmetry properties, but are based on numerical and algorithmic approaches. A rosette configuration is a coplanar arrangement where n particles of mass m_{1} are positioned at the vertices of a regular n -gon and n particles of mass m_{2} located at the vertices of another concentric n -gon but rotated by an angle of \pi/n concerning the first. Additionally, there is an extra particle of mass m_{0} at the center of mass. In 2006, Lei and Santoprete [ 12 ] demonstrated that for n\geq 3 and every \varepsilon>0 , with \mu=m_{0}/m_{1} and \varepsilon=m_{2}/m_{1} , there exists a degenerate central configuration and a bifurcation. For n=5 , considering three bodies on the vertices of an equilateral triangle and two bodies on a perpendicular bisector, Llibre, and Mello [ 13 ] showed the existence of three new families of planar central configurations . In 2013, Alvarez and Llibre [ 5 ] characterized the planar central configurations of the 4 -body problem with masses m_{1}=m_{2}\neq m_{3}=m_{4} , which have an axis of symmetry . They showed that this 4 -body problem has exactly two classes of concave central configurations with the shape of a kite. Their proof was assisted by a computer. In 2021, Alvarez, Gassul, and Llibre [ 4 ] classified the central configurations of the 5 -body problem, where the five bodies are positioned at the vertices of an equilateral pentagon with an axis of symmetry . They demonstrated that two unique classes of such equilateral pentagons provide central configurations: one concave equilateral pentagon and one convex equilateral pentagon, the regular one. On the other hand, in 2023, Deng and Hampton [ 8 ] showed that the pentagonal configuration (not regular), with a cycle of five equal edges, has several results concerning central configurations satisfying this property . They also presented a computer-assisted proof of the finiteness of such configurations for any positive masses with a range of rational-exponent homogeneous potentials. In the context of the 3 -body [ 28 ] and 4 -body [ 2 ] problems, it has been established that the only convex polygonal central configuration occurs when the bodies, each with equal mass, are arranged in a regular polygon. However, this is not true for the 6 -body problem [ 26 ] , where configurations can consist of two nested triangles that are rotated relative to each other [ 27 ] . In this paper, we explore a specific subclass of planar central configurations for the Newtonian five-body problem with equal masses, which

Read the complete text