The invisible threat

V. Carruba, R. Sfair, R. A. N. Araujo, O. C. Winter, D. C. Mourão, S. Di Ruzza, S. Aljbaae, G. Caritá, R. C. Domingos, A. A. Alves · 2025

Read The invisible threat by V. Carruba, R. Sfair, R. A. N. Araujo, O. C. Winter, D. C. Mourão, S. Di Ruzza, S. Aljbaae, G. Caritá, R. C. Domingos, A. A. Alves (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15968.txt.

Introduction

Valter Carruba and co-authors hunt for invisible asteroids in a 2025 planetary defense study. Twenty asteroids are known to share Venus's orbit. Almost all are on stretched paths that swing near Earth, which makes them easy to spot; the rounder-orbit companions hide in the sun's glare.

Simulations of the resonance that locks these co-orbitals to Venus showed a family of low-eccentricity paths that can still drift into collision courses with Earth over time. Ground telescopes catch only brief windows on them, and even the coming Rubin Observatory will glimpse just some. The authors argue a Venus-orbiting sentinel mission may be needed to complete the census.

Catalog record

CREATORV. Carruba, R. Sfair, R. A. N. Araujo, O. C. Winter, D. C. Mourão, S. Di Ruzza, S. Aljbaae, G. Caritá, R. C. Domingos, A. A. Alves
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15968

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The invisible threat V. Carruba, R. Sfair, R. A. N. Araujo, O. C. Winter, D. C. Mourão, S. Di Ruzza, S. Aljbaae, G. Caritá, R. C. Domingos, A. A. Alves Abstract Context. Currently, 20 co-orbital asteroids of Venus are known, with only one with an eccentricity below 0.38. This is most likely caused by observational biases since asteroids with larger eccentricities may approach the Earth and are easier to detect. Aims. We aim to assess the possible threat that the yet undetected population of Venus co-orbitals may pose to Earth, and investigate their detectability from Earth and space observatories. Methods. We used semi-analytical models of the 1:1 mean-motion resonance with Venus and numerical simulations to monitor close encounters with Earth on several co-orbital cycles. We analyzed observability windows and brightness variations for potential Venus co-orbitals as viewed from ground-based telescopes to assess their future detection feasibility with next-generation survey capabilities. Results. There is a range of orbits with e < 0.38 e<0.38 , larger at lower inclinations, for which Venus’co-orbitals can pose a collisional hazard to Earth. Conclusions. Current ground-based observations are constrained by periodic observing windows and solar elongation limitations, though the Rubin Observatory may detect some of these objects during favorable configurations. Space missions based on Venus’orbits may be instrumental in detecting Venus’co-orbitals at low eccentricities. Assessing the collisional hazard posed by the undiscovered Venus co-orbital asteroids 1 Introduction Venus co-orbital asteroids are objects that are in a 1:1 mean-motion resonance with Venus. At low eccentricities, co-orbital configurations include tadpole orbits (T) around the triangular L_{4} and L_{5} Lagrangian equilibrium points (TL4 and TL5), and horseshoe orbits (H) ( Murray & Dermott 1999 ) . At higher eccentricities other types of orbits, like Retrograde Satellites (RS), H-RS compound orbits, which are mergers of RS and H, or H and RS, and T-RS compound orbits, resulting from a combination between Tadpoles and RS, as well as transitions between any of these configurations, are also possible ( ( Namouni 1999 ; Christou 2000 ; Morais & Morbidelli 2006 ) , see also Section ( 3 ) for a discussion of these concepts). The known Venus co-orbital asteroids typically spend 12000\pm 6000 years alternating between different co-orbital configurations, until transitioning to circulating or passing orbits in what Carruba et al. 2025 defined as a co-orbital cycle. Some asteroids may pass through several co-orbital cycles, and remain in circulating orbits in-between these cycles. These types of orbits are defined as “dormant” in Carruba et al. 2025 . Twenty co-orbital asteroids of Venus are currently known (see ( Carruba et al. 2024 ; Pan & Gallardo 2024 ) and references therein). Co-orbital status protects these asteroids from close approaches to Venus, but it does not protect them from encountering Earth ( Christou 2000 ) . A Potentially Hazardous Asteroid ( PHA ) must have a minimum diameter of about 140 meters and come within 0.05 astronomical units (au) of Earth’s orbit. The maximum absolute magnitude ( H ) for an asteroid to be classified as a PHA is typically around 22 ( Task Force on Potentially Hazardous Near Earth Objects 2000 ) . Carruba et al. 2025 identified six co-orbital asteroids that can become PHA s in the next \simeq 12000 years, with three asteroids, 2020 SB, 524522, and 2020 CL1, having a Minimum Orbital Intersection Distance (MOID), which is the distance between the closest points of two objects’ orbits, with Earth of less than 0.0005 au. I. Assuming a geometric albedo p_{V} of 0.12 and using the absolute magnitudes of these objects and standard methods to estimate asteroid sizes ( Bowell et al. 1989 ) , their diameters would be 330, 300, and 390 meters, respectively. Based on results from an impact simulator from Collins et al. 2005 , assuming a density of 1200 kg/m^{3} , typical of the common C-complex asteroids ( Carry 2012 ) , an impact angle of 45^{\circ} , a velocity equal to the escape velocity from Earth of 11.2 km/s, and impacts on sedimentary rocks, these objects could form craters with diameters from 2.2 to 3.4 Km, and release energies at impact from 1.5 to 4.1\times 10^{2} Megatons TNT, which is more than enough to destroy large cities. This corresponds to a level 8 in the Torino scale ( Binzel et al. 1998 ) , i.e., a collision capable of causing localized destruction for an impact over land or possibly a tsunami if close offshore. Currently, only one of the known Venus’co-orbitals has a value of eccentricity ( e ) slightly lower than 0.38, which is the limit for which the apocenter of the orbit of a Venus co-orbital is equal to the Earth pericenter. This phenomenon is not limited to just the co-orbitals of Venus, but is a characteristic of all asteroids in the region, as discussed in Section ( 2 ). Two possible mechanisms have been proposed to explain the lack of observations of asteroids at lower eccentricities. In the dynamical scenario, NEAs are created disproportionally at higher eccentricities, while in the observational bias model ( Pan & Gallardo 2024 ; Di Ruzza et al. 2023 ) , a large population of NEAs exists near Venus at low e , but it is not detected because of biases in observational data, that tend to privilege the discovery of faint objects that came closer to Earth and whose orbit could be external to the Earth’s one. Results from recent models of the production of NEAs from the main belt and other dynamical source regions ( Nesvorný et al. 2024 ) show that there is no observed bias for producing low- e asteroids near Venus. This means that it is very likely that a large population of Venus co-orbital asteroids at e<0.38 may exist, but it is yet undetected. In this work, we aim to assess the collisional hazard posed by undetected Venus Trojans. For this purpose, we use the semi-analytical model by Pan & Gallardo 2024 to set up initial conditions for long-term simulations of Venus’co-orbitals, in a grid of initial conditions in the (e,inc) plane, with inc being the inclination of the orbital plane of the orbits with respect to the orbital plane of Venus, that includes the possible undetected population of Venus co-orbital asteroids (see Sect. ( 3 )). Close encounters with Earth are then monitored using the method described in Carruba et al. 2025 , to provide information on the orbital location of the most dangerous undetected co-orbitals (see Sect. ( 4 )). Based on this analysis, in Sect. ( 5 ) we discuss the feasibility of observing these asteroids from Earth, with an emphasis on observations from the Vera C. Rubin Observatory, or Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST), while in Sect. ( 6 ) we review current proposals for space mission to observe asteroids from orbits near Venus. Finally, in Sect. ( 7 ) we present our conclusions. 2 The expected orbital distribution of NEAs near Venus: NEOMOD3 results Figure 1 : Left panel: the distribution in the (H,e) plane of known asteroids near Venus (blue full circles) and its co-orbital asteroids (red stars). The horizontal dashed line shows the limit for which the apocenter of Venus’ co-orbitals ( Q_{A} ) can

Read the complete text