The bearable inhomogeneity of the baryon asymmetry
Hengameh Bagherian, Majid Ekhterachian, Stefan Stelzl · 2025
Read The bearable inhomogeneity of the baryon asymmetry by Hengameh Bagherian, Majid Ekhterachian, Stefan Stelzl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15904.txt.
Introduction
Hengameh Bagherian, Majid Ekhterachian, and Stefan Stelzl show that the universe's first elements tightly limit how patchy the early cosmos could have been, in this 2025 arXiv paper. Some theories of matter's origin would leave the baryon density lumpy across space. Light-element abundances, read with the microwave background, say how much lumpiness survives.
Fluctuations above about twenty-five percent, on scales larger than the horizon when the universe was near three trillion electron-volt temperatures, clash with what we see. Lumps smooth out mainly by slow diffusion, which is why the fingerprint lasts. The bound cuts into electroweak baryogenesis ideas and into phase-transition stories told to explain pulsar timing signals.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hengameh Bagherian, Majid Ekhterachian, Stefan Stelzl |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 104 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15904
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The bearable inhomogeneity of the baryon asymmetry Hengameh Bagherian, Majid Ekhterachian, Stefan Stelzl Abstract We study the implications of precision measurements of light-element abundances, in combination with the Cosmic Microwave Background, for scenarios of physics beyond the Standard Model that generate large inhomogeneities in the baryon-to-photon ratio. We show that precision Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) places strong constraints on any mechanism that produces large-scale inhomogeneities at temperatures around or below the TeV scale. In particular, we find that fluctuations of order 25 % 25\% on comoving length scales larger than the horizon at T ≃ 3 TeV T\simeq 3~\mathrm{TeV} are incompatible with the observed light-element abundances. This sensitivity to early-universe physics arises because baryon-number inhomogeneities homogenize primarily through diffusion, a slow process. As a result, BBN serves as a novel probe of baryogenesis below the TeV scale, readily ruling out some proposed scenarios in the literature. We discuss the implications for electroweak baryogenesis, and further show that precision BBN provides a new probe of first-order phase transitions that generate gravitational waves in the pHz–mHz frequency range. This yields constraints on the electroweak phase transition, as well as first-order phase transitions that have been suggested as an explanation of the pulsar timing array signal. Finally, we comment on the future prospects for improving this probe. 1 Introduction In the era of precision cosmology, it is of great importance to leverage the available cosmological data as a new probe of physics beyond the standard model (BSM). The success of Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) in accurately predicting the observed abundances of light elements makes it one of the most powerful and precise probes of the early universe. By combining measurements of primordial light element abundances with our understanding of BBN physics and the measured nuclear reaction rates as input, the baryon-to-photon ratio \eta can be determined. Independently, a measurement of \eta to sub-percent precision is obtained from the angular power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) [ 1 , 2 ] . The most precise BBN-based determination, dominated by the deuterium-to-hydrogen abundance ratio ( D/H ), achieves approximately 2\% precision [ 3 ] and is consistent with the value extracted from the CMB. This close agreement between BBN and CMB determinations of \eta represents a significant success of modern cosmology. Currently, the dominant uncertainties in the prediction of the baryon-to-photon ratio in the BBN stem from that of nuclear reaction rates, making recent experimental advances, such as those of the LUNA collaboration [ 4 ] , particularly important to improve the uncertainty in the BBN predictions. The CMB is a powerful probe of early-universe inhomogeneities, in particular probing baryon isocurvature perturbations at the level of O(10^{-5}) [ 5 ] . In this work, we examine how BBN similarly probes baryon isocurvature perturbations, i.e., inhomogeneities in the baryon-to-photon ratio; for the effect of adiabatic modes on BBN, see e.g. [ 6 , 7 ] . The sensitivities of CMB and BBN to spatial inhomogeneities in \eta differ significantly, offering complementary insights into potential physics beyond the standard cosmological model. In particular, while the level of precision from BBN is much less than that of the CMB, it probes length scales much smaller than those probed by the CMB. As we will show, BBN can be sensitive to comoving length scales that were sub-horizon even at electroweak temperatures, while CMB is primarily sensitive at comoving length scales of the order of and larger than the Hubble length at the time of recombination (see [ 5 ] and e.g. [ 8 ] for a recent study). The deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio ( D/H ), being the most sensitive BBN probe for determining \eta , is particularly interesting in the context of sensitivity to inhomogeneities. Crucially, the final deuterium abundance depends non-linearly on the local value of \eta . Because of this non-linear dependence, two different spatial distributions of \eta with the same average value generally yield distinct predictions for the D/H ratio. That is, averaging deuterium and hydrogen abundances across regions with varying baryon densities does not eliminate the effects of small-scale fluctuations in \eta . For small fluctuations around its mean value, the final abundances can be expanded in terms of the relative size of these fluctuations. While the linear term averages out, higher-order terms yield predictions different from homogeneous BBN. As a rough estimate, assuming an O(1) coefficient for the second-order terms, a percent-level measurement of D/H can probe fluctuations in \eta of order 10\% . This sensitivity applies to fluctuations on all scales that persist until BBN, including those significantly smaller than the horizon size at that time. A remarkable observation emphasized in this work is that inhomogeneities introduced at times much earlier than BBN could survive until then and thus be probed. This applies not only to superhorizon fluctuations but also to fluctuations with length scales well within the horizon at the time of nucleosynthesis. To understand the reach of BBN as a probe of early times, we must therefore consider the evolution of sub-horizon inhomogeneities in \eta . For small fluctuations, diffusion is the dominant mechanism for homogenizing baryons. As the temperature T decreases in a radiation-dominated universe, the mean free path of particles (and thus the diffusion constants) grows, causing the diffusion timescale—set by the inverse Hubble scale H^{-1} —to increase. Consequently, the effects of diffusion are dominated by the latest times. The available time for diffusion is t\sim H^{-1}\sim M_{\text{Pl}}/T^{2} , whereas the typical interaction time and length scale for a strongly coupled system are \tau\sim l_{\text{mfp}}\sim 1/T . A particle thus undergoes approximately N\sim t/\tau scatterings, and its random walk results in a diffusion distance d\sim\sqrt{N}\,l_{\text{mfp}} . Comparing this diffusion distance to the Hubble length, l_{H}\sim H^{-1} , yields d/l_{H}\sim\sqrt{T/M_{\text{Pl}}}\ll 1 . This indicates that diffusion is inefficient at erasing inhomogeneities unless these fluctuations occur on length scales many orders of magnitude smaller than the horizon scale at late times. It is instructive to estimate the earliest time at which sub-horizon inhomogeneities can be produced and still survive until BBN. Consider perturbations generated at the horizon scale at some temperature T_{i} . Due to cosmic expansion, the length scale of these inhomogeneities grows by the factor (a_{\text{BBN}}/a_{i})\sim(T_{i}/T_{\text{BBN}}) by the time of BBN, becoming (T_{i}/T_{\text{BBN}})\cdot l_{H}(T_{i}) , where the a represents the corresponding scale factor. Comparing this length with the diffusion length at BBN, d\sim\sqrt{T_{\text{BBN}}/M_{\text{Pl}}}\cdot l_{H}(T_{\text{BBN}}) , we see that fluctuations survive provided T_{i}\lesssim\sqrt{T_{\text{BBN}}M_{\text{Pl}}}\sim 10^{4}\,\text{TeV} . This naive estimate assumes strong coupling of baryons to the plasma; however, at the relevant temperatures, neutrons are only weakly coupled and dominate baryon diffusion. A more refined treatment (see section 2 ) yields the condition T_{i}\lesssim 3~\mathrm{TeV} . Thus, horizon-scale inhomogeneities generated at temperatures around a few \mathrm{TeV} can just barely evade diffusion and survive until BBN, offering a tantalizing window into high-energy physics of the early universe. We find that inhomogeneities greater than \mathcal{O}(20-30\%) that are generated over distances larger than \mathcal{O}(H^{-1}) at temperatures of a few \mathrm{TeV} are incompatible with the measured light element abundances. This novel constraint on the early universe has exciting implications, some of which we briefly explore. It readily rules out a recently proposed baryogenesis mechanism [ 9 ] , which produces baryons with large spatial