LOOKING FOR STABILIZERS IN NSOP

1 · 2025

Read LOOKING FOR STABILIZERS IN NSOP by 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15573.txt.

Introduction

Yvon Bossut studies groups definable in NSOP1 theories, looking for stabilizers, published in 2025. Such theories sit beyond the simple theories where group behavior is best understood. Groups defined inside them can act in ways that differ from simple groups, so familiar tools need rethinking.

The paper defines a Kim-stabilizer and also uses a stabilizer notion from Hrushovsky. For a group definable in an NSOP1 field meeting some assumptions, the author shows there is a finite-to-one embedding of a large type-definable subgroup into an algebraic group over the field. Definable groups in omega-free PAC fields are shown to meet the assumptions. The work extends stabilizer methods from model theory into this wider setting, tying abstract definable groups to concrete algebraic ones.

Catalog record

CREATOR1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE126 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15573

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

LOOKING FOR STABILIZERS IN NSOP 1 Abstract Abstract: In this work we study some examples of groups definable and type-definable in NSOP 1 theories. We exhibit some behaviors of these groups that differ from the ones of simple groups. We take interest in the notions of generics and stabilizers, and define the Kim-stabilizer. We apply the notion of Kim-stabilizer and the stabilizer from [ Hru12 ] to the context of a group G definable in an NSOP 1 field F satisfying some assumptions to show that there is a finite to one embedding of a type definable subgroup of G of bounded index into an algebraic group over F . We then show that definable groups in \omega -free PAC fields of characteristic 0 satisfy these conditions. Acknowledgments: I thank Frank O. Wagner for his advices and Nick Ramsey for his helpful emails. 1 Introduction When we study a theory T we want to understand its definable sets. In particular we want to analyze definable groups. We mention in this regard the results of Dobrowolski in [ Dob23 ] on groups definable in the theory of the generic bilinear form over an algebraically closed field and of Chatzidakis and Ramsey in [ CR23 ] on groups definable in e -free PAC fields when e is finite. An effective result for this is the group configuration theorem, which Hrushovski proved in his thesis [ Hru86 ] . This result allows one to obtain a type-definable group from a certain configuration of independent elements in a stable theory. Typical applications of this result include: Theorem 1 . [ HP94 , Theorem C] Let G be a group definable in a pseudo-finite field F . Then G is virtually definably isogenous to the set of F -rational points of an algebraic group over F . There are two major notions in the study of groups in model theory that we will now present in a rather informal way: the notion of formula and generic type in a group, and that of stabilizer of a type in a group. Let G be a group definable in a model \mathbb{M} of a theory T . A definable subset X of G is said to be left-generic if a finite number of left translates of X cover G , similarly for right-generic. A type is said to be (left/right) generic if it implies only (left/right) generic formulas. In a stable theory there exist generic complete types on any set of parameters, but this is not true in general. There is a similar notion in the context of simple theories. Given a complete type p\in S_{G}(A) the stabilizer of p is a subgroup Stab(p)\leq G generated by elements ’stabilizing’ the type, in the following sense: g\in Stab(p) iff p\cup g\cdot p is consistent, where g\cdot p is the type p translated by g . The link between these two notions is that a generic type must have a ’large’ stabilizer - of bounded index for example. The typical strategy for studying a definable group G in a model F of a field theory is as follows: 1. Take a,b,x generic elements (meaning that their type is generic) independent in the group G , write c:=a\cdot b . 2. The group configuration theorem provides us with elements a^{\prime},b^{\prime},c^{\prime} in a group H definable in the algebraic closure of F^{alg} of F (i.e., an algebraic group) interalgebraic with a,b,c respectively on a set of parameters E . 3. We then consider the stabilizer of \mbox{\rm tp}(a,a^{\prime}/E) in G\times H , and we show that it defines an isogeny between G and H . This is the method that we want to apply to study groups definable in \omega -free PAC fields of characteristic 0 . To achieve this we seek to generalize the notions of genericity and stabilizer to NSOP 1 . For the notion of generic, by taking the ’naive’ generalization of the generic in the simple setting we have a negative answer (which was already noted by Dobrowolski: [ Dob23 , Proposition 8.14] ). For the notion of stabilizer we give a definition generalizing that of the simple case, which defines in general an invariant group. We show that in certain examples the subgroup obtained, which we will call the Kim-stabilizer, is type-definable. We generalize some of the results on groups definable in a simple theory to this notion. We also introduce another notion of stabilizer, due to Hrushovski in [ Hru12 ] . An ideal of formula is a set of formula closed under disjunction and logical implication (if \theta\in\mu and \theta\vdash\theta^{\prime} then \theta^{\prime}\in\mu ). An ideal \mu is said to be S1 on a set of parameters A if it is A -invariant and if \varphi(x,a_{i})\wedge\varphi(x,a_{j})\in\mu for i\mathchoice{\mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\kern 3.8889pt\kern-5.27776pt$\displaystyle\not$\hss}{=}}}{\mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\kern 3.8889pt\kern-5.27776pt$\textstyle\not$\hss}{=}}}{\mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\kern 3.06946pt\kern-4.45831pt$\scriptstyle\not$\hss}{=}}}{\mathrel{\hbox to0.0pt{\kern 2.56949pt\kern-3.95834pt$\scriptscriptstyle\not$\hss}{=}}}j<\omega implies \varphi(x,a_{i})\in\mu for any A -indiscernible sequence (a_{i})_{i} and any formula \varphi(x,y) . Under the assumption of the existence of an S1 ideal of formulas in a group, he defines a notion of stabilizer and shows that it is a type-definable subgroup. Using the two notions of stabilizers, the Hrushovski one and the Kim-stabilizer one we prove under certain assumptions on a NSOP 1 field F and a group G definable in F that there exists a typical-definable subgroup of G of bounded index and a finite kernel embedding of this subgroup into the F -rational points of an algebraic group definable over F . We also show that the groups definable in \omega -free PAC fields of characteristic 0 satisfy these assumptions. 2 NSOP 1 groups 2.1 Kim-generics In this section we consider the notion of generic from stability and simplicity theory and try to see if we can find an analogy in the context of NSOP 1 . The answer to this question seems to be negative: we give here some examples of ‘bad’ behavior of NSOP 1 groups. The main example we consider in this section is the model completion of the theory of abelian groups with a generic unary function f such that f(0)=0 . We denote this theory by T_{f,ab} . This theory is constructed in [ Bos24 ] . It is an NSOP 1 theory with existence and has quantifier elimination in the language L=\{+,0,f\} . Let \mathbb{M} be a monster model of T_{f,ab} , we recall some of the properties of \mathbb{M} : 1. [ Bos24 , Remark 3.2.5] : The algebraic closure of any set A\subseteq\mathbb{M} is equal to the structure generated by A . 2. [ Bos24 , Corollary 3.2.10] : Kim-forking independence coincides with algebraic independence \mathrel{\mathop{\vbox{\hbox{\vtop{\halign{#\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr\hfil$|$\hfil\cr\kern-3.01385pt\cr$\smile$\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr}}}}}\displaylimits}^{a} . 3. [ Bos24 , Proposition 3.2.9] : There is an independence relation \mathrel{\mathop{\vbox{\hbox{\vtop{\halign{#\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr\hfil$|$\hfil\cr\kern-3.01385pt\cr$\smile$\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr}}}}}\displaylimits}^{\Gamma} that is invariant, stationary, satisfies existence, extension, transitivity, base monotonicity and symmetry. 4. [ Bos24 , Definition 3.3.1(4)] : For any subset A\subseteq\mathbb{M} there is a type p_{A}\in S(A) that satisfies the following property: Let a\models p and let \psi:A\rightarrow B be morphism of L -structures from A to B\subseteq\mathbb{M} and let b\in B be any element. Then there is a unique extension of \psi into a morphism from \langle A,a\rangle to B sending a to b . p_{A} is called the \Gamma -generic type over A .

Read the complete text