A Participatory Strategy for AI Ethics in Education and Rehabilitation grounded in the Capability Approach

Valeria Cesaroni, Eleonora Pasqua, Piercosma Bisconti, Martina Galletti · 2025

Read A Participatory Strategy for AI Ethics in Education and Rehabilitation grounded in the Capability Approach by Valeria Cesaroni, Eleonora Pasqua, Piercosma Bisconti, Martina Galletti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15466.txt.

Introduction

Valeria Cesaroni and co-authors propose a participatory strategy for AI ethics in education and rehabilitation in a 2025 paper. AI tools could support children with special educational needs and disabilities, enriching learning and therapy. Their use also raises risks that demand an ethical frame and a wider ecological view.

The authors ground their approach in the Capability Approach, which judges tools by what they let people actually do and be. They argue that research and design should involve the people affected. Teachers, clinicians, and families thus help shape AI rather than merely receive it.

Catalog record

CREATORValeria Cesaroni, Eleonora Pasqua, Piercosma Bisconti, Martina Galletti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15466

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Participatory Strategy for AI Ethics in Education and Rehabilitation grounded in the Capability Approach Valeria Cesaroni, Eleonora Pasqua, Piercosma Bisconti, Martina Galletti Abstract AI-based technologies have significant potential to enhance inclusive education and clinical-rehabilitative contexts for children with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities. AI can enhance learning experiences, empower students, and support both teachers and rehabilitators. However, their usage presents challenges that require a systemic-ecological vision, ethical considerations, and participatory research. Therefore, research and technological development must be rooted in a strong ethical-theoretical framework. The Capability Approach - a theoretical model of disability, human vulnerability, and inclusion - offers a more relevant perspective on functionality, effectiveness, and technological adequacy in inclusive learning environments. In this paper, we propose a participatory research strategy with different stakeholders through a case study on the ARTIS Project, which develops an AI-enriched interface to support children with text comprehension difficulties. Our research strategy integrates ethical, educational, clinical, and technological expertise in designing and implementing AI-based technologies for children’s learning environments through focus groups and collaborative design sessions. We believe that this holistic approach to AI adoption in education can help bridge the gap between technological innovation and ethical responsibility. 1 Introduction The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in educational and clinical contexts necessitates a multidimensional approach that considers cognitive, relational, and ethical dimensions. First, the literature underscores that artificial intelligence, by directly influencing cognitive and relational structures [ 3 ] can play a crucial role in the scaffolding function. This, in turn, plays a pivotal role in proximal development, significantly shaping subjectification, qualification, and socialization processes [ 4 ] . Second, an inclusive perspective requires an ecological-systemic approach to the technology design that can take into account the interaction between individuals, technologies, and their broader social environments [ 5 ] . For these reasons, the development and the implementation of such technologies must be anchored within an ethical framework which is appropriate and grounded in a theoretical model suitable for childhood, disability, and human vulnerability [ 6 ] . Moreover, it is essential to design the development of the technology by engaging diverse stakeholders, each bringing distinct epistemic and methodological perspectives. This study makes several key contributions. Drawing inspiration from the ARTIS Project [ 7 , 8 ] , which develops an AI-based interface to rehabilitate children with text comprehension difficulties. The study contributes to: (I) Propose a theoretical framework based on the capability approach; (II) Introduce a co-creation strategy applicable to various contexts; (III) Present implementation results using ARTIS as a case study. The study illustrates a research and development pathway linking inclusion, technological innovation and critical assessment of personal capabilities, proposing a holistic and participatory model for ethical and inclusive AI development aimed at supporting vulnerable learners. 2 Related Work The field of AI in Education (AIEd) has grown alongside developments in big data and adaptive technologies, with AI typically supporting students, teachers, or institutions [ 9 ] . While widely adopted in mainstream education for administration and personalized learning [ 10 ] , its role in inclusive and special education remains limited and often instrumental [ 11 ] . Scholars have criticized the lack of ethical and pedagogical consideration in AI integration [ 12 ] noting that many tools are not designed with the needs of learners with disabilities in mind [ 9 ] . Recent research has moved beyond AI’s technical functions to highlight its ethical and social implications in education [ 13 ] . AI ethics research often remains narrowly technical—focused on fairness, bias, and transparency—while neglecting deeper pedagogical and inclusive concerns [ 14 , 5 ] . This functionalist approach sidelines critical, theory-driven perspectives and rarely involves educators or specialists in early design stages [ 15 , 16 ] . The lack of an ecological and systemic outlook results in AI tools misaligned with pedagogical values and classroom realities, especially in inclusive education contexts. Finally, AI has demonstrated promise in diagnosing neurodevelopmental disorders through machine learning analysis of MRI [ 17 ] and EEG [ 18 ] data, providing effective screening support [ 2 ] . Despite benefits for clinical decision-making [ 19 , 20 ] and personalized learning [ 21 ] , AI’s role in structured therapeutic interventions and long-term rehabilitation remains underexplored. Research on AI in structured therapeutic interventions is still limited [ 22 ] , and few programs provide adequate training for educators and clinicians. This study addresses the lack of AI-driven rehabilitation tailored to diverse cognitive needs and the shortage of training for practitioners by positioning AI as a core component of clinical and educational interventions that support cognitive and linguistic development. The ARTIS project [ 7 , 8 ] exemplifies a research approach based on an ethical framework of human development and provides an example of the context-sensitive use of technology. Based on van Dijk’s neuropsycholinguistic model [ 23 , 24 ] , and developed with speech therapists and tested in public and clinical settings [ 8 ] , ARTIS aims to support the rehabilitation process. 3 The Theoretical Framework Existing ethical frameworks for AI, often focused on risk mitigation (e.g. fairness, bias, privacy), prove inadequate in educational and rehabilitative contexts involving children. These models tend to be object-oriented and contractualist, assuming autonomous, equal agents [ 6 ] . Such assumptions neglect the fundamental conditions of vulnerability, dependence, and asymmetry that characterize childhood and disability [ 6 ] . We argue for a shift toward a holistic perspective that sees technology as a sociotechnical mediator rather than a neutral tool [ 1 ] . This requires an ethical model grounded in vulnerability, interdependence, and the complex interplay between individuals, technology, and their environments. AI, especially in childhood contexts, challenges instrumentalist perspectives and demands a rethinking of inclusion through a more relational and systemic lens. To address this gap, we adopt the Capability Approach (CA) as a foundational framework. Originating with Amartya Sen [ 26 ] and expanded by Martha Nussbaum [ 25 ] , the CA redefines justice not in terms of equal resources, but of real freedoms - what individuals are effectively able to do and be. It emphasizes conversion factors - individual (e.g. impairments), social (e.g. norms, expectations), and environmental (e.g. infrastructures) - that shape how resources like technology translate into meaningful opportunities (capabilities and functionings) [ 28 ] . In this light, AI must be evaluated not just on its technical performance but on how it shapes learning, inclusion, and well-being. It calls for research questions attentive to human diversity, contextual factors, and the mediating role of technology in subject formation. With this approach, we can interpret the interplay between technology, context, and users’ situated conditions in a more nuanced way, enabling a deeper, more critical understanding of the role technology plays in inclusive processes. Especially relevant to AI - defined as a third-level technology [ 27 ] for its pervasive cognitive and hermeneutic role - the CA supports a systemic, hybridized view of educational processes. In the ARTIS project, the Capability Approach has shaped the formulation of key research questions that guide both design and evaluation. These include: whether the technology is developmentally appropriate for its intended users; what user model underpins the system’s design choices; and which capabilities

Read the complete text