Scale-by-scale kinetic energy flux calculations in simulations of rotating convection
Youri H. Lemm \aff 1, Xander M. de Wit \aff 1, Rudie P.J. Kunnen \aff 1 · 2025
Read Scale-by-scale kinetic energy flux calculations in simulations of rotating convection by Youri H. Lemm \aff 1, Xander M. de Wit \aff 1, Rudie P.J. Kunnen \aff 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15463.txt.
Introduction
Youri Lemm, Xander de Wit, and Rudie Kunnen compare two ways to track energy flow in swirling hot fluid in a 2025 paper. In such flows, energy can move to smaller swirls or gather into larger ones. Heat-driven flow that also spins is a stand-in for flows in oceans, air, and stars.
One method sorts the flow by patch size, while the other sorts it by wave size. Both methods still work in tight boxes where the flow is uneven, the team shows. In their tests, the deep bulk sent energy to small scales. Near the top and bottom plates, small swirls merged and sent energy to large scales instead.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Youri H. Lemm \aff 1, Xander M. de Wit \aff 1, Rudie P.J. Kunnen \aff 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15463
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scale-by-scale kinetic energy flux calculations in simulations of rotating convection Youri H. Lemm \aff 1, Xander M. de Wit \aff 1, Rudie P.J. Kunnen \aff 1 Abstract Turbulence is an out-of-equilibrium flow state that is characterised by nonzero net fluxes of kinetic energy between different scales of the flow. These fluxes play a crucial role in the formation of characteristic flow structures in many turbulent flows encountered in nature. However, measuring these energy fluxes in practical settings can be challenging as soon as one moves away from unrestricted turbulence in an idealised periodic box. Here, we focus on rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, being the canonical model system to study geophysical and astrophysical flows. Owing to the effect of rotation, this flow can yield a split cascade, where part of the energy is transported to smaller scales (direct cascade), while another fraction is transported to larger scales (inverse cascade). We compare two different techniques for measuring these energy fluxes throughout the domain: one based on a spatial filtering approach and an adapted Fourier-based method. We show how one can use these methods to measure the energy flux adequately in the anisotropic, aperiodic domains encountered in rotating convection, even in domains with spatial confinement. Our measurements reveal that in the studied regime, the bulk flow is dominated by the direct cascade, while significant inverse cascading action is observed most strongly near the top and bottom plates, due to the vortex merging of Ekman plumes into larger flow structures. \lefttitle Youri H. Lemm, Xander M. de Wit, Rudie P.J. Kunnen \righttitle Journal of Fluid Mechanics \corresau Youri H. Lemm, keywords Turbulence, Energy cascade, Rotating flows, Thermal convection. 1 Introduction The behaviour of kinetic energy transport in turbulent flows is known to be dramatically different depending on the dimensionality of the system ( Frisch 1995 ; Davidson 2015 ) . In three-dimensional (3D) turbulence, energy injected at the largest scales is cascaded towards smaller and subsequently smaller scales. This cascading process ends with energy dissipating into heat on the smallest scales. This is referred to as the direct or forward cascade of energy ( Pope 2000 ) . When constrained to only two spatial dimensions, this cascading process is inverted, and the kinetic energy is transported mainly towards the large scales. This inversion of the energy cascade can result in an accumulation of kinetic energy at the largest scales. This phenomenon is known as the so-called inverse cascade of energy, which originates from the fact that this process is opposite to what is expected from unconstrained 3D turbulence. This inversion of the energy cascade is caused by the absence of vortex stretching in these two-dimensional (2D) turbulent flows ( Fox & Davidson 2010 ; Boffetta & Ecke 2011 ) . This idealised version of two-dimensional turbulence is only rarely realised in the world beyond textbooks, but many systems in our physical world do possess some of the relevant characteristics of two-dimensional turbulence, and hence we refer to these as cases of quasi -two-dimensional turbulence ( Boffetta & Ecke 2011 ) . This quasi-two-dimensional turbulence is a result of constraints such as rotation, density stratification, or the application of a strong magnetic field and has been the subject of many previous studies, see e.g. Chen et al. 2006 ; Alexakis & Biferale 2018 ; Alexakis 2023 , and is formally defined as turbulent flow that undergoes little to no variation along a (vertical) direction of the system. This quasi-two-dimensional behaviour of turbulence can be retrieved and studied in a number of ways, depending on the type of forcing and method of analysis. The flow system central to this paper is rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRBC); an extension of the classical convection system described by Rayleigh 1916 and Bénard 1901 . In RRBC, a thermal forcing is caused by a destabilising temperature difference \Delta T=T_{h}-T_{c} imposed between two horizontal parallel plates, which rotate around a central axis with angular velocity \boldsymbol{\Omega} . Here, T_{h} and T_{c} represent the high and low temperatures of the parallel plates, respectively. The parallel plates are spaced a distance H apart and are D wide. The quasi-two-dimensionality in these systems is a result of the system rotation. In these types of flow, this behaviour can be, at least partially, approximated and explained by the well-known Taylor-Proudman theorem ( Taylor 1923 ; Proudman 1916 ) . (a) (b) Figure 1 : The domains wherein we simulate rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection. For both the horizontally periodic domain (a) and the cylindrically bounded domain (b), this figure illustrates the geometry and the thermal forcing through a temperature difference between the top and bottom plates. The transition from the theoretical concept of energy flux to the calculation of this quantity in turbulent flows is not very straightforward. When we consider any flow system that does not consist of homogeneous and isotropic turbulence in a periodic box, a number of practical and pragmatic choices need to be made before even reaching the actual implementation. For RRBC, specifically, we need to consider how to handle the anisotropy and inhomogeneity of the flows itself before we can start to tackle the lack of periodicity in the domain. Having a nonperiodic domain also introduces subsequent issues that need solving, like the boundary layer effects that this confinement brings with it. The aim of this work is to find an effective methodology for retrieving the energy flux from the velocity fields of RRBC. We consider two separate domains in which we simulate RRBC, which vary in their geometric confinement. The first of these is illustrated in Figure 1(a) and consists of a domain bounded from above and below by solid plates, with periodic boundary conditions imposed in the horizontal directions. The second simulation domain consists of a cylindrically bounded domain, shown in Figure 1(b) . The increasing complexity of the latter simulation domain serves the purpose of approaching domains of a finite nature that resemble what can be achieved in experimental research ( Stevens et al. 2013 ; Kunnen 2021 ; Ecke & Shishkina 2023 ) . Simulation works on horizontally periodic domains have shown that axial rotation combined with thermal forcing in RRBC can result in a sharp change between 3D and quasi-2D turbulence ( Julien et al. 2012 ; Guervilly et al. 2014 ; Favier et al. 2014 ; Rubio et al. 2014 ; de Wit et al. 2022 ) . We calculate the scale-by-scale kinetic energy flux based on an associated length scale. The sign of this quantity gives us the directionality of the energy transport through that scale. When the flux is positive, energy is transported from the specified length scale towards smaller scales (corresponding to a forward or direct cascade of energy). If the calculated flux is of a negative sign, this indicates the transport of energy towards larger length scales, i.e. an inverse cascade of energy. Traditionally, the scale-by-scale flux of the kinetic energy is calculated based on Fourier decompositions of the flow ( Favier et al. 2014 , e.g.) . For a correct application of this, it is required that the domains have periodic boundary conditions. Since this periodicity obviously cannot be found in experimental works, another approach is required. Here, following Chen et al. 2006