Let’s Take Esoteric Programming Languages Seriously
Jeremy Singer, Steve Draper · 2025
Read Let’s Take Esoteric Programming Languages Seriously by Jeremy Singer, Steve Draper (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15327.txt.
Introduction
Jeremy Singer and Steve Draper argue that joke programming languages deserve serious study, in a 2025 essay. Esoteric languages range from the deliberately obtuse to the artistic, like one whose programs are abstract paintings, to probes of computation itself. Their odd constraints, the authors claim, train real skill. Wrestling a hostile language sharpens reading and writing code everywhere.
Designing such languages also exposes why anyone designs languages at all, a question mainstream work leaves implicit. The essay weighs teaching uses and the new wrinkle of AI assistance. Showing off obscure mastery among peers is admitted as part of the fun. The authors distill a set of good reasons for language design from the fringe inward.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jeremy Singer, Steve Draper |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15327
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Let’s Take Esoteric Programming Languages Seriously Jeremy Singer, Steve Draper Abstract . Esoteric programming languages are challenging to learn, but their unusual features and constraints may serve to improve programming ability. From languages designed to be intentionally obtuse (e.g. INTERCAL) to others targeting artistic expression (e.g. Piet) or exploring the nature of computation (e.g. Fractan), there is rich variety in the realm of esoteric programming languages. This essay examines the counterintuitive appeal of esoteric languages and seeks to analyse reasons for this popularity. We will explore why people are attracted to esoteric languages in terms of (a) program comprehension and construction, as well as (b) language design and implementation. Our assertion is that esoteric languages can improve general PL awareness, at the same time as enabling the esoteric programmer to impress their peers with obscure knowledge. We will also consider pedagogic principles and the use of AI, in relation to esoteric languages. Emerging from the specific discussion, we identify a general set of ‘good’ reasons for designing new programming languages. It may not be possible for anyone to be exhaustive on this topic, and it is certain we have not achieved that goal here. However we believe our most important contribution is to draw more attention to the varied and often implicit motivations involved in programming language design. DOI: 10.1145/3759429.3762632 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2151-9/25/10 Conference: Proceedings of the 2025 ACM SIGPLAN International Symposium on New Ideas, New Paradigms, and Reflections on Programming and Software; October 12–18, 2025; Singapore, Singapore Proceedings of the 2025 ACM SIGPLAN International Symposium on New Ideas, New Paradigms, and Reflections on Programming and Software (Onward! ’25), October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore CCS: Software and its engineering Language types CCS: Social and professional topics Cultural characteristics † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Despite their name, esoteric programming languages are surprisingly popular in the general Computer Science community. This essay is based on a presentation we have given several times to audiences of academic Computer Scientists interested in programming language design; on each occasion we have encountered keen advocates of esoteric languages like Whitespace and Brainf***. However we have also detected a sense of shame—esoteric language usage is an unexpectedly common ‘guilty secret’. In this work, we seek to analyse potential reasons for these attitudes to esoteric languages. We will argue that Computer Scientists need to take esoteric languages seriously. Let’s start with some definitions: An esoteric programming language (hereafter contracted to esolang , following general convention) is ‘a programming language designed to experiment with weird ideas, to be hard to program in, or as a joke, rather than for practical use’. 1 1 1 https://esolangs.org/wiki/Esoteric_programming_language Temkin ( Temkin, 2017 ) characterizes an esoteric programming language as one that is ‘intentionally ununsable, uncomputable or conceptual’. Another definition 2 2 2 https://esoteric.codes/blog/esolangs-as-an-experiential-practice is that ‘esolangs are a class of languages made for reasons other than practical use’. More generally, the adjective esoteric relates to philosophical doctrines and modes of speech. It refers to concepts or materials that are appreciated only by an ‘inner circle’ of advanced persons, known as initiates. And, if a definition were needed, a programming language is a systematized notation for precise expression of intended computational behaviour. The ACM encyclopedia definition of ‘programming languages’ ( Sammet and Hemmendinger, 2003 ) describes them as: ‘both tools for directing the operation of a computer and tools for organizing and expressing solutions to problems’. The claim of this essay is that esoteric languages might be inherently useful in some significant ways, and so they deserve to be studied in a serious manner. The first question we seek to address is: What is the appeal of esolangs, in general? Our discussion will cover the following four high-level reasons for their popularity: (1) A sense of fun or playfulness (2) Recalling a lost ‘golden age’ of coding (3) Sense of cultic initiation (4) Artistic value The second question we will address is: What is the appeal of designing esolangs, in particular? We will explore the reasons of parody and comedy, before moving on to considering the skills of working within very tight self-imposed constraints, and the attraction of creating a programming language ‘of one’s own’, as Virginia Woolf might have said. Taking inspiration from Wing’s conceptual framework of Computational Thinking ( Wing, 2006 ) , we will ask: what do programmers actually do? We will explore how this characteristic behaviour is manifested in the medium of esolangs. Whereas Wing’s claim is that practitioners in other disciplines can benefit from a grasp of computing principles, our study of esoteric languages leads us to believe that computer programmers can benefit from a wider appreciation of other disciplines. This is Gordon’s argument in his Onward! essay from last year ( Gordon, 2024 ) which takes the complementary stance to Wing, encouraging computer programmers to appreciate natural language and linguistics. In considering pedagogic principles, we will ask Why is it beneficial to expose learners to esoteric languages? We will explore this question through the lens of variation theory, inter alia . Although esolangs may seem trivial, they deserve our attention since they can change the way we think about programming and language design. As Perlis ( Perlis, 1982 ) puts it: Epigram 19: A language that doesn’t affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing. 2. Background In this section, we briefly survey the field of esolangs. We commence with the prototypical esolang, INTERCAL, in Section 2.1 . After this, for the sake of convenience we cluster the languages into broadly related sets, considering esolangs that have a natural language syntax (Section 2.2 ), those with non-textual syntax (Section 2.3 ) and those with an exotic computational model (Section 2.4 ). We acknowledge that these characteristic properties are not mutually exclusive. Further, we acknowledge that other esolangs may not fall into any of these categories, but we hope this is sufficient for an imprecise ‘first cut’ at surveying the field. One key observation is that almost all esolangs have low-level semantics, in terms of primitive arithmetic operations on integer values, limited input/output facilities and primitive control flow. Higher-level facilities such as abstract data types, modularity and concurrency features are almost entirely absent. Another general observation is that the surface-level, concrete syntax of all esolang programs is highly unconventional. Typical esolang code does not look like mainstream code, indeed, it may not look like code at all ( Cox and McLean, 2012 ) . 2.1. INTERCAL We first discuss INTERCAL, since this is the archetype of esolangs. To the best of our knowledge, its language reference manual ( Woods and Lyon, 1973 ) makes the first mention of ‘esoteric’ in relation to programming languages of this nature. The examples of INTERCAL programming which have appeared in the preceding sections of this manual have probably seemed highly esoteric to the reader unfamiliar with the language. With the aim of making them more so, we present here a description of INTERCAL. Like many subsequent esolangs, INTERCAL was devised by university students as a playful, humorous artifact. It has become ‘the longest-running and most convoluted joke in the history of programming language design’ ( Raymond, 2010 ) . Although the language initially had a minimal compiler and negligible