Extreme Fluctuations in the Sun’s Activity over the Modern Maximum: Understanding the Enigmatic Solar Cycles 19-20

S. Pal, D. Nandy · 2025

Read Extreme Fluctuations in the Sun’s Activity over the Modern Maximum: Understanding the Enigmatic Solar Cycles 19-20 by S. Pal, D. Nandy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15326.txt.

Introduction

Shaonwita Pal and Dibyendu Nandy wrote a paper in two thousand twenty-five about wild swings in the Sun's activity during the last century. That era, called the Modern Maximum, held the strongest sunspot cycle on record, cycle nineteen. The very next cycle was far weaker, and why the flip was so sharp stayed an open puzzle.

The authors run data-driven models of magnetic fields on the solar surface and inside the Sun. They show that random tilts and flipped orientations in pairs of sunspots are enough to reproduce the extreme jump between the two cycles. The result backs the idea that odd tilts in emerging active regions drive the solar dynamo's extremes. It also bears on how the Sun may fall quiet.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Pal, D. Nandy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15326

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extreme Fluctuations in the Sun’s Activity over the Modern Maximum: Understanding the Enigmatic Solar Cycles 19-20 S. Pal, D. Nandy Abstract Over the past century, the Sun’s activity – which exhibits significant variations – went through a phase known as the Modern Maximum. Notably, the strongest sunspot cycle on record during this period, and indeed since direct sunspot observations began, was cycle 19; this was followed by a significantly weaker cycle 20. Understanding and reconstructing this extreme variability has remained elusive. Utilizing data-driven, coupled models of magnetic field evolution on the Sun’s surface and within its convection zone, here we show that random deviations in the tilt angle and polarity orientation of bipolar sunspot pairs is sufficient to explain these observed, extreme fluctuations during the modern maximum in solar activity. Our results support the theory that perturbation in the poloidal field source of the dynamo mechanism – mediated via the emergence of anomalously tilted solar active regions - is the primary driver of extreme variations in the Sun’s activity. This study has implications for understanding how the Sun may switch from a phase of extreme activity to quiescent, low activity phases – such as the Maunder Minimum. 1 Introduction The sunspot cycle – characterized by an approximately 11-year quasi-periodic rise and fall in solar activity – is a striking manifestation of the Sun’s magnetic behavior ( Charbonneau, 2020 ; Usoskin, 2023 ) . However, the strength of the Sun’s activity cycle is not uniform and varies from one cycle to another, resulting in a variable forcing of the heliosphere that seamlessly bridges physical phenomena originating in our host star’s interior to planetary impacts ( Daglis et al., 2021 ) . Observational evidence has uncovered that over the past century, the Sun has exhibited a prolonged period of unusually high activity known as the Modern Maximum ( Solanki et al., 2004 ) . The strongest cycle during this phase – in fact over the past four centuries since direct sunspot cycle observations began with Galileo Galilei and his contemporaries – was sunspot cycle 19 peaking around 1957; this was followed by an unexpectedly weak sunspot cycle 20. Understanding and reconstructing this extreme solar activity fluctuation over cycles 19-20 through physics-based models has remained an outstanding challenge ( Cameron et al., 2010 ; Jiang et al., 2013 ; Bhowmik & Nandy, 2018 ; Virtanen et al., 2022 ; Pal & Nandy, 2024 ; Yeates et al., 2025 ) . Figure 1: The top panel illustrates the variations in the optimized simulated polar flux (solid curves) alongside the observed polar flux obtained from the MWO polar faculae database (dashed curves) for solar cycles 15 to 23. The red and blue curves represent the Northern and Southern hemispheres, respectively. Additionally, the black/grey curve in the same panel depicts the total yearly/monthly averaged unsigned sunspot flux, derived from the RGO/USAF/NOAA database. The bottom panel presents the time-latitudinal distribution of the radial magnetic field ( \mathrm{B_{r}} ) based on the optimized simulation. Here, yellow and blue shades indicate magnetic fields of positive and negative polarity, respectively. It is understood that nonlinearities inherent in the magnetohydrodynamic solar dynamo mechanism and stochastic perturbations in the dynamo source terms can lead to amplitude fluctuations from one solar cycle to another ( Charbonneau & Dikpati, 2000 ; Saha et al., 2025 ) . The Sun’s large-scale dipolar field – the poloidal component (of which the polar field is a proxy) – is inducted by solar differential rotation within the Sun’s convection zone to produce the toroidal magnetic field component of the following sunspot cycle ( Parker, 1955 ) . Magnetic (Lorentz) feedback of strong toroidal flux tubes on the Sun’s differential rotation can, in principle, result in amplitude modulation; however, observations show that inter-cycle variations (known as torsional oscillations) in the solar differential rotation which acts as the source of the Sun’s toroidal field – is quite small \leq 5 \% ( Mahajan et al., 2024 ) . Strong toroidal fields are unstable to magnetic buoyancy and rise up to emerge through the solar surface giving rise to bipolar sunspot pairs — which are observed to be systematically tilted relative to the local latitude (due to the action of the Coriolis force on rising flux tubes). Observations ( Dasi-Espuig et al., 2010 ; Muñoz-Jaramillo et al., 2012 ) , theoretical considerations ( Cameron & Schüssler, 2015 ) as well as data-driven, physical models of the long-term evolution of solar magnetic fields – such as solar surface flux transport (SFT) models and dynamo models ( Bhowmik & Nandy, 2018 ) – have suggested that the dispersal of the magnetic flux of these tilted bipolar sunspots (mediated by plasma flows) is the primary mechanism for recreation of the Sun’s large scale dipolar field; the latter mechanism is known as the Babcock-Leighton (BL) mechanism ( Babcock, 1961 ; Leighton, 1969 ) . As magnetic flux tubes rise through the solar convection zone, they are buffeted by vigorous turbulence, generating an observed scatter in the tilt angles around the mean (Joy’s law tilt) expected from Coriolis force ( Cheung & Isobe, 2014 ) . The amplitude of this scatter is observed to be much more than the mean tilt angle, which acts as a significant source of perturbation on the poloidal field source ( Jiang et al., 2014 ; Nagy et al., 2017 ) . Anti-Hale active regions (ARs) – bipolar sunspot pairs whose polarity orientation does not conform to the conventional solar cycle trend – are an additional source of perturbation ( Nagy et al., 2017 ; Pal et al., 2023 ) . Other mechanisms, such as tilt quenching and latitudinal quenching, are also known to act as amplitude-limiting mechanisms for the BL poloidal field generation mechanism ( Jiao et al., 2021 ; Yeates et al., 2025 ) . Although the interplay of these nonlinearities and stochastic forcing are theorized to drive solar activity fluctuations, capturing the extreme variation between cycles 19-20 has remained elusive. Here we address the outstanding question whether solar cycles 19 and 20 can be accurately reconstructed using known physics and physical models of solar magnetic field evolution. Figure 2: The violet curve represents the total yearly averaged unsigned sunspot flux from solar cycle 16 to 24, derived from the USAF/RGO/NOAA database. The orange curve indicates the total unsigned flux simulated using the dynamo model (refer A.2 ), driven by the poloidal field generated by the C-PhoTraM model. A Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.93, calculated with a 99 \% confidence level, highlights the strong agreement between the observed and simulated flux strengths at cycle maxima. Figure 3: Top panel denotes correlation between the flux-weighted tilt coefficient multiplied by total flux ( \mathrm{\Phi T_{A}} ) for the \mathrm{n^{th}} solar cycle and the observed average polar flux at the end of the same cycle. This correlation is estimated using the sunspot database without incorporating stochasticity. Bottom panel illustrates correlation between the \mathrm{\Phi T_{A}} and two quantities at the end of the same solar cycle ( \mathrm{n} ): (i) the dipole moment simulated by C-PhoTraM simulation (left x -axis, red circles), and (ii) the observed average polar flux (right x -axis, magenta squares). These correlations are estimated after incorporating stochasticity in the

Read the complete text