Emotional Supporters often Use Multiple Strategies in a Single Turn
Xin Bai, Guanyi Chen, Tingting He, Chenlian Zhou, Yu Liu · 2025
Read Emotional Supporters often Use Multiple Strategies in a Single Turn by Xin Bai, Guanyi Chen, Tingting He, Chenlian Zhou, Yu Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15316.txt.
Introduction
Xin Bai, Guanyi Chen, Tingting He, Chenlian Zhou, and Yu Liu redefine a task in supportive conversation in this 2025 paper. Emotional support chats help people in distress with empathy, validation, and gentle advice. Systems learn the skill from datasets where each supporter reply is tagged with one strategy, like asking a question or giving comfort.
Reading a real corpus closely, the authors found that tag scheme false: supporters often stack several strategies in a single turn, comforting, then probing, then advising. They recast the task as producing the whole sequence of strategy-and-text pairs. New models are proposed for that richer target, from trained networks to large language models. In tests, the big models handled the stacked replies best. The fix gives support bots a more human shape.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xin Bai, Guanyi Chen, Tingting He, Chenlian Zhou, Yu Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15316
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Emotional Supporters often Use Multiple Strategies in a Single Turn Xin Bai, Guanyi Chen, Tingting He, Chenlian Zhou, Yu Liu Abstract Emotional Support Conversations (ESC) are crucial for providing empathy, validation, and actionable guidance to individuals in distress. However, existing definitions of the ESC task oversimplify the structure of supportive responses, typically modelling them as single strategy–utterance pairs. Through a detailed corpus analysis of the ESConv dataset, we identify a common yet previously overlooked phenomenon: emotional supporters often employ multiple strategies consecutively within a single turn. We formally redefine the ESC task to account for this, proposing a revised formulation that requires generating the full sequence of strategy–utterance pairs given a dialogue history. To facilitate this refined task, we introduce several modelling approaches, including supervised deep learning models and large language models. Our experiments show that, under this redefined task, state-of-the-art LLMs outperform both supervised models and human supporters. Notably, contrary to some earlier findings, we observe that LLMs frequently ask questions and provide suggestions, demonstrating more holistic support capabilities. 1 Introduction Emotional Support Conversations (ESC) play a critical role in helping individuals manage emotional distress and navigate personal challenges through meaningful, empathetic dialogue ( Langford et al. 1997 ; Heaney and Israel 2008 ) . The goal of ESC is not only to reduce emotional intensity but also to foster a sense of connection, validation, and clarity during difficult times. Despite its importance, providing effective emotional support remains a complex, nuanced task, often requiring sensitivity, contextual understanding, and advanced interpersonal skills—traits that even humans may struggle to consistently exhibit ( Burleson 2003 ) . As such, building intelligent systems capable of engaging in ESC presents both a valuable opportunity and a significant challenge. To this end, Liu et al. 2021 proposed the ESC framework, which is grounded in Hill’s helping skills theory ( Hill 1999 ) , and introduced the ESConv dataset. In the ESC framework, an ESC takes place between a help-seeker and an emotional supporter. The framework recommends that supporters follow three stages (i.e., exploration, comforting, and action), and employ a total of eight associated strategies. Figure 1 presents an example of an ESC. Based on the help-seeker’s inquiry, the supporter begins with the exploration stage, using strategies such as asking questions when essential details about the seeker’s situation are missing. Once the necessary information is obtained, the supporter may provide comfort by reflecting the seeker’s emotions or offering affirmations, and/or take action by suggesting possible next steps. Figure 1: Example of an emotional support conversation. The part in the red window is the dialogue history, and the part in the blue window is the target that the ESC task asks an ESDS to produce. This Figure contains three tasks on ESC: (1) emotional support utterance generation; (2) emotional support message continuation; (3) the refined ESC task. Based on this framework and the ESConv dataset, Liu et al. 2021 defined the ESC task. Since then, a range of Emotional Support Dialogue Systems (ESDS), built on deep learning techniques or Large Language Models (LLMs), has been developed ( Tu et al. 2022 ; Zhao et al. 2023 ; Cheng et al. 2023 ; Zheng et al. 2023 ; Deng et al. 2023 ; Kang et al. 2024 ) . Interestingly, recent studies have found that LLMs, despite their demonstrated effectiveness in various psychological counselling tasks ( Ayers et al. 2023 ) , often struggle with the ESC task. Specifically, they tend to select inappropriate strategies ( Kang et al. 2024 ) and frequently fail to provide suggestions to seekers ( Bai et al. 2025 ) . We argue that the observed discrepancy in LLM performance stems from a limitation in the current definition of the ESC task. Specifically, prior studies defined the ESC task as predicting the supporter’s next strategy and generating a corresponding utterance based on the dialogue history. However, this formulation overlooks a critical detail: the last utterance in the dialogue history is not necessarily from the supporter. As illustrated in the example ESC in Figure 1 , a supporter may employ multiple strategies within a single turn, resulting in multiple utterances. We refer to this phenomenon as the Consecutive Use of multiple Strategies (CUS). This observation reveals that the ESC task actually comprises two distinct subtasks. When the last utterance is from the seeker, the task is the emotional support utterance generation (Figure 1 (1)). When the last utterance is from the supporter, the task becomes continuing the supporter’s previous message, i.e., emotional support message continuation (Figure 1 (2)). In fact, the second subtask does not occur in isolation in real-world settings, as it presupposes that the decision to continue a prior message has already been made. This presents two key implications. First, when evaluating ESDSes on the ESConv dataset, existing zero-shot or few-shot LLM-based ESDSes fail to understand that they need to distinguish between these subtasks and that they need to generate only a single strategy–utterance pair out of multiple pairs. Second, in real-life deployments, supervised deep learning-based ESDSes typically perform only the first subtask, generating a single strategy–utterance pair in response to each seeker’s message. This behaviour diverges from that of human supporters, who may employ CUS in a turn. In response to this issue, we argue that modelling CUS is essential for building effective ESDSes and for accurately defining the true ESC task. As illustrated in Figure 1 (3), the ESC task should be reformulated as predicting all strategies and their corresponding utterances within a single supporter turn, based on a dialogue history in which the last utterance must come from the seeker. In this study, we begin with a brief corpus analysis of the ESConv dataset to examine the prevalence of CUS in ESCs. We then formally redefine the ESC task. Based on this new task formulation, we preprocess the ESConv dataset and introduce several models, ranging from supervised deep learning approaches to LLM-based systems, that explicitly model CUS to accomplish the task. Finally, we evaluate these models using both automatic metrics and human assessments, and analyse their performance with respect to strategy usage and the quality of the emotional support responses they produce. The data and code used in this study are publicly available at: https://github.com/Baixin-ccnu/emotional_support_cus . 2 Analysing and Redefining ESC We begin by analyzing the ESConv dataset to determine how frequently CUS occurs. Based on our findings, we redefine the ESC task and preprocess the dataset to align with the new task formulation. 2.1 Analysing ESConv Figure 2: The distribution of responses and the average response length based on the number of strategies employed. Note that the average length is 0 for responses with 6 strategies, as no such responses exist in the ESConv dataset. To investigate the prevalence of CUS, we count the number of strategies used in each supporter response in the ESConv dataset. Figure 2 presents the distribution of responses by the number of strategies employed. It also reports the average number of tokens in responses that use different numbers of strategies. Out of 13,767 responses in ESConv, 2,525 responses use more than one strategy, indicating the presence of CUS. The response with the highest number of strategies employs seven in a single turn. Regarding