AI Solutionism and Digital Self-Tracking with Wearables CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models

Hannah R. Nolasco, Andrew Vargo, Koichi Kise · 2025

Read AI Solutionism and Digital Self-Tracking with Wearables CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models by Hannah R. Nolasco, Andrew Vargo, Koichi Kise (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-15162.txt.

Introduction

Hannah Nolasco and co-authors argue that bolting artificial intelligence onto self-tracking wearables can quietly rob users of the very reflection that makes tracking useful. Devices already automate data gathering and insight-making, and new studies propose language models to automate still more, all in the name of lowering effort. Drawing on their work with a popular sleep-tracking ring, the authors call this reflex AI solutionism.

Their worry is behavioral: when the device does the noticing and the judging, users stop forming their own readings of their sleep and habits, and agency drains out of the intervention. A tracker meant to build self-knowledge becomes a feed of verdicts to accept. The paper explores remedies that keep automation in a supporting role rather than the driver's seat. As a position piece, it asks designers to count lost reflection as a cost, not just saved effort as a gain.

Catalog record

CREATORHannah R. Nolasco, Andrew Vargo, Koichi Kise
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE13 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-15162

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI Solutionism and Digital Self-Tracking with Wearables CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models Hannah R. Nolasco, Andrew Vargo, Koichi Kise Abstract . Self-tracking technologies and wearables automate the process of data collection and insight generation with the support of artificial intelligence systems, with many emerging studies exploring ways to evolve these features further through large-language models (LLMs). This is done with the intent to reduce capture burden and the cognitive stress of health-based decision making, but studies neglect to consider how automation has stymied the agency and independent reflection of users of self-tracking interventions. In this position paper, we explore the consequences of automation in self-tracking by relating it to our experiences with investigating the Oura Ring, a sleep wearable, and navigate potential remedies. 1 1 1 This work was presented at the ACM CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI ’25) Workshop on Resisting AI Solutionism: Where Do We Go from Here? Yokohama, Japan. 1. Introduction The Quantified Self (QS) movement encourages a systematic practice of self-tracking that is mediated by technology, meant to augment the act by allowing one to capture large amounts of personal data at a much faster rate and with greater accuracy ( Feng et al. 2021 ) . This is supposed to empower one into optimizing their lifestyle for the purpose of improving their wellbeing or productivity ( Choe et al. 2014 ; Li et al. 2010 ; Ruckenstein 2014 ) while foisting the burden of data collection from the user to the machine ( Choe et al. 2017a ) . Self-tracking facilitated through wearable devices can collect physiological data passively, and through the accurate capture of physiological health markers, the device can aggregate insights often with the support of embedded artificial intelligence systems ( Wu et al. 2020 ) . This automation in the capture of personal data and in the dispensing of insights is perceived as a benefit to the user, given it reduces the cognitive load of having to determine the actions required to improve one’s health as captured by the technology ( Choe et al. 2017a ) . Despite this, researchers remain divided on the impact of digital self-tracking and wearable devices—although there are studies which report an increase in decision making capabilities and self-confidence in users, others report experiences of anxiety and self-doubt, a loss of agency, and alienation from one’s perception of the self ( Wieczorek et al. 2023 ) . There is no evidence to support the notion that automation in self-tracking of health parameters encourages behavior change ( Patel et al. 2015 ) . Yet most self-tracking tools and devices continue to be designed in such a way that curtails the involvement of the user in the process. With Large Language Models (LLMs) now coming into vogue, a growing body of literature is emerging which explores the implementation of LLMs into wearables to further automate the processing of device feedback ( Ahmed et al. 2025 ) , health monitoring and behavior modeling ( Ferrara 2024 ; Kim et al. 2024 ) , and activity recognition ( Ferrara 2024 ; Imran et al. 2024 ) . In this position paper, we discuss the myriad hurdles to leveraging digital self-tracking interventions posed by automation and how it affected participants of our ongoing investigation of the Oura Ring, a sleep monitoring wearable. We contemplate upon the degrees of automation present in these technologies, which risk rendering users impotent to form independent decisions and embodied perceptions, and list ways the development of self-tracking interventions can be steered toward a more user-centered approach. 2. Hurdles to Leveraging Automated Self-Tracking 2.1. Impairment to Information Literacy and Perception of Device Impact Commercially ready wearable sleep-trackers are equipped with sensors that are comparable to research grade equipment and are effective at tracking and assessing substantial amounts of personal data ( De Zambotti et al. 2019 ) . The Oura ring is one such device evidenced to be accurate in its sleep stage detection ( Altini and Kinnunen 2021 ) and its prediction of sleep quality ( Malakhatka et al. 2024 ) . Despite its sensor fidelity, we encountered an absence of improvement in sleep in users of the ring after one year of consistent device adherence ( Nolasco et al. 2023 ) . The users exhibited stagnant trend lines in their objective data, which contradicted their own reports that the device had a positive impact on both their sleep and habits. Wearable devices utilize feedback systems which make use of descriptive statistics, and the highly technical and context-agnostic nature of the communicated information often leads to disengagement, which in turn prevents users from complying with their device’s suggestions ( Patel et al. 2015 ; Wulfovich et al. 2019 ) . We suspect that this incongruence between the perceptions that users had of the device’s impact and their objective data is due to Oura’s identical data delivery methods. Users of self-tracking tools frequently struggle with contextualizing and interpreting the visualized information presented by their device or application ( Grammel et al. 2010 ; Rooksby et al. 2014 ) , and it is possible that the participants of our study failed to appraise their data and thus were unable to inform their habits in response to it; they merely formed an impression of wellbeing improvement conceivably due to a desire for the device to be effective. It is also possible that they did become more mindful of their sleep hygiene, but their efforts were not detected by the device. 2.2. Outsourcing Reflection Leading to Alienation from Data The effort necessitated by wellness-based decision making ostensibly affects a person’s ability to intervene in the aspects of their health which can be improved or optimized, and self-tracking tools seek to reduce this cognitive load by supplying users with generated insights derived by the technology ( Li et al. 2011 ; Cho et al. 2021 ; Choe et al. 2017b ) . But without a vehicle for self-reflection or involvement in the data interpretation, users of self-tracking technologies become alienated from their data and become increasingly disengaged until they eschew attentiveness to the device altogether ( Li et al. 2011 ) . In a qualitative interview with a cohort of long-term users of the Oura Ring, we urged participants to share their usage habits and impressions of the wearable, their relationship with sleep and the value they attribute to it, and the degree in which they have absorbed the knowledge that the device should have conferred to them after several months of usage. Many of their sentiments expressed a dissatisfaction with the information gained from the ring, as they felt it did not tell them anything they did not already know, or it contradicted their personal evaluations of their own condition. This aligns with the experiences of other users of digital self-tracking, who revealed that the data automatically captured by the device does not abide by what interests them ( Lazar et al. 2015 ) and that their objective data did not align with their own subjective observations ( Attig and Franke 2020 ; Rooksby et al. 2014 ; Nolasco et al. 2024 ) . Respondents of the interview also demonstrated a semblance of learned

Read the complete text