An inequality of Harish-Chandra
Nolan R. Wallach · 2025
Read An inequality of Harish-Chandra by Nolan R. Wallach (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14960.txt.
Introduction
Nolan Wallach offers a simpler proof of a key inequality from Harish-Chandra's classic work on harmonic analysis. The inequality helps show that certain parameter-dependent integrals settle down for large parameter values. Harish-Chandra's own proof leaned on a heavy theorem from logic and geometry. Wallach's route stays elementary.
The note expands an idea sketched in his own earlier book on real reductive groups. Along the way it repairs several serious misprints in that book's account. The author frames the piece as an erratum as much as a new proof. Readers gain a cleaner path to a result that underpins convergence arguments across the field. Short and focused, the note serves specialists who rely on the inequality. It also restores trust in a standard reference by fixing its errors in print.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nolan R. Wallach |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14960
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An inequality of Harish-Chandra Nolan R. Wallach Abstract In paper I of his masterpiece Harmonic Analysis on Real Reductive Groups, Harish-Chandra included an important inequality that is useful in proving that certain key integrals depending on a parameter converge for large values of the parameter. His proof involved the Tarski-Seidenberg Theorem. The purpose of this note is an elementary proof of the inequality which is an expansion of the idea in my Real Reductive Groups I. This exposition fixes several critical misprints in the original and can be considered to be an erratum for the book. 1 Introduction In [ H ] Lemma 32.2 Harish-Chandra stated an important inequality with a proof that asserted that it was a consequence of the Tarski-Seidenberg Theorem as stated in [ HO1 ] on page 276. In the next section, after setting up the appropriate notation, I will explain the inequality in question. In my book [ RRGI ] I stated this inequality as Lemma 4.A.2.3 (with an unfortunate misprint) and gave two ”proofs” the first saying at a certain point it follows from the Tarski-Seidenberg Theorem and the second involved an elementary induction. Unfortunately the second proof also had some misprints and missing symbols. This note can therefore be considered to be an erratum to my book. Also, in the next section the necessary algebra will be done in order to apply the elementary proof. No one was more careful in his proofs than Harish-Chandra so I have no doubt that he was certain that he was sketching a complete proof but the reason he gives in [ H ] (top of page 193) seems to need further explanation. Since I use this inequality in [ W ] and since my exposition of it in [ RRGI ] is riddled with typos I feel that it is worthwhile to distribute this note which hopefully clears up the subject. Also the proof given leaves less to the reader than a properly edited version of the original. Included, as an appendix, is a compendium of the results on the structure of parabolic subgroups of real reductive groups that we use in this note. 2 The set-up The notation for the material in this section can be found in the appendix on parabolic subgroups. As in the appendix, G will denote a real reductive group as in [ BW ] and K a maximal compact subgroup of G with corresponding Cartan involution \theta . All of the terminology on parabolic subgroups undefined in this section can be found in the appendix. Let P_{o} be a minimal parabolic subgroup of G with Langlands decomposition P_{o}=\left(M_{o}\cap K\right)A_{o}N_{o} . We assume that \mathfrak{a}_{o}\left(=Lie(A_{o})\right) is contained in \mathfrak{q}=\{X\in\mathfrak{g}|\theta X=-X\} . Let P be a parabolic subgroup of G containing P_{o} with Langlands decomposition P={}^{o}M_{P}A_{P}N_{P} . Let \bar{P}=\theta(P) then \bar{P} is a parabolic subgroup of G containing \bar{P}_{o}=\theta(P_{o}) the Langlands decomposition of \bar{P} is \bar{P}={}^{o}M_{P}A_{P}\bar{N}_{P} with \bar{N}_{P}=\theta(N_{P}) . Let a_{\bar{P}}:G\rightarrow A_{P} be as in the appendix (note that {}^{o}M_{\bar{P}}={}^{o}M_{P} and A_{\bar{P}}=A_{P} ). Define \rho_{P}\in\mathfrak{a}_{P}^{\ast} by \rho_{P}(h)=\frac{1}{2}\mathrm{tr}(ad(h)_{|\mathfrak{n}_{P}}). Let \log:A_{P}\rightarrow\mathfrak{a}_{P} denote the inverse to the map \exp:\mathfrak{a}_{P}\rightarrow A_{P} . If \nu\in\left(\mathfrak{a}_{P}\right)_{\mathbb{C}}^{\ast} then define a^{\nu}=e^{\nu(\log a)} . Let \left\langle...,...\right\rangle be as in the appendix and let \left\|...\right\| be the corresponding norm on \mathfrak{g} . The Harish-Chandra inequality that is the subject of this note is (the logarithm of) Proposition 1 There exist C>0 and m>0 such that if X\in\mathfrak{n}_{P} then a_{\bar{P}}(\exp(X))^{\rho_{P}}\geq C(1+\left\|X\right\|^{2})^{m}. Notice that \exp:\mathfrak{n}_{P}\rightarrow N_{P} is a diffeomrophism. Thus if \log:N_{P}\rightarrow\mathfrak{n}_{P} is the invers map then the inequality reads a_{\bar{P}}(n)^{\rho_{P}}\geq C(1+\left\|\log n\right\|^{2})^{m},n\in N_{P}. For the rest of this section we fix P_{o} and P as above with their given Langlands decompositions. Let H\in\mathfrak{a}_{P} be such that adH defines a grade, \mathfrak{g=\oplus}_{j\in\mathbb{Z}}\mathfrak{g}_{j} (that is, \mathfrak{g}_{j} is the j eigenspace for adH ) such that \mathfrak{p=\oplus}_{j\geq 0}\mathfrak{g}_{j},\mathfrak{m}_{P}=\mathfrak{g}_{0} and \mathfrak{n}_{P}=\mathfrak{\oplus}_{j\geq 1}\mathfrak{g}_{j} . Also, note that the decomposition \mathfrak{g=\oplus}_{j\in\mathbb{Z}}\mathfrak{g}_{j} is orthogonal. We will write \left(\mathfrak{n}_{P}\right)_{j}=\mathfrak{g}_{j} if j>0 . As we have observed in the appendix \left(\mathfrak{n}_{P}\right)_{1}\neq 0 . Let q be the maximum of the j such that \left(\mathfrak{n}_{P}\right)_{j}\neq 0 . Let r=\dim\mathfrak{n}_{p} and let V=\wedge^{r}\mathfrak{g} and extend the inner product, \left\langle...,...\right\rangle , to V in the usual way. Let \xi be a unit vector in \wedge^{r}\mathfrak{n}_{\bar{P}}\mathfrak{.} Let \sigma(g)=\wedge^{r}ad(g) we will also write \sigma(X)=d\sigma(X) . Set Z=\sigma(U(\mathfrak{g}))\xi=\sigma(U(\mathfrak{n}_{P}\mathfrak{))\xi.} Set Z_{j} equal to the \sigma(H) eigenspace for eigenvalue -2\rho_{P}(H)+j for j=0,1,... . Then the decomposition Z=\oplus_{j\geq 0}Z_{j} is orthogonal. Observing that if \bar{n}\in N_{\bar{P}},m\in{}^{o}M_{P}={}^{o}M_{\bar{P}} and a\in A_{o} then \sigma(ma\bar{n})\xi=\det(ad(m)_{|\mathfrak{\bar{n}}_{P}})a^{-2\rho_{P}}\xi . Also, if m\in{}^{o}M_{P} then \left|\det(ad(m)_{|\mathfrak{\mathfrak{n}}_{\bar{P}}})\right|=1 . Thus, if g=\bar{n}mak with \bar{n}\in N_{\bar{P}} , a\in A_{P},m\in{}^{o}M_{P} then \left\|\sigma(g)^{-1}\xi\right\|=a^{2\rho_{P}}=a_{\bar{P}}(g)^{2\rho_{P}}. We note that \left\|\sigma(\exp-X)\xi\right\|^{2} is a polynomial in X that is strictly positive. The Tarski-Seidenberg Theorem implies (see [ HO2 ] , Example A.2.7 p. 368) that if f(x) is a polynomial function on \mathbb{R}^{n} such that f(x)>0 for all x\in\mathbb{R}^{n} then there exists C>0 and r such that f(x)\geq C(1+\left\|X\right\|^{2})^{r}. Which seems to prove the above proposition. However, Hörmander shows on page 369 that there are polynomial functions, f , on \mathbb{R}^{n} such that f(x)>0 for all x\in\mathbb{R}^{n} but any inequality of the type displayed above has r<0 . This is, however not Harish-Chandra’s reference to the Tarski-Seidenberg Theorem it is in, fact, to an earlier exposition of Hörmander in [ HO1 ] p. 276. The only pertinent result on that page is Lemma 2.1 which doesn’t directly prove the proposition since it gives asymptotic behavior and not lower bounds. Obviously, Harish-Chandra felt that the transition to the appropriate lower bound is obvious. The next lemma reduces the proposition above to the Lemma that is the subject of the next section. We will be using the notation X_{i} for the orthogonal projection of X\in\mathfrak{n}_{P} to \left(\mathfrak{n}_{P}\right)_{j} and z_{j} of the orthogonal projection of z\in Z to Z_{j} . In light of lemma 3 in the next section the following result, taking (in the notation of lemma 3 and this lemme) \varphi=\psi, W=\mathfrak{n}_{P},T_{j}w=\sigma(-w)\xi , implies Proposition 1 Lemma 2 Set \psi(X)=\sigma(\exp(-X))\xi for X\in\mathfrak{n}_{P} then \psi(X)_{0}=\xi , \psi(X)_{1}=-\sigma(X_{1})\xi and if 2\leq j\leq q then \psi(X)_{j}=-\sigma(X_{j})\xi+u_{j}(X_{1}+X_{2}+...+X_{j-1}) with u_{j} a polynomial on \mathfrak{n}_{1}\oplus...\oplus\mathfrak{n}_{j-1} with values in V_{j} of degree j . Also the map \mathfrak{n}_{j}\rightarrow V_{j} , X\mapsto\sigma(X)\xi is injective for 1\leq j\leq q . Proof. Note that \psi(X)=\xi+\sum_{j\geq 1}\frac{(-1)^{j}}{k!}\sigma(X)^{j}\xi since every every component in X\in\mathfrak{n} is at least of degree 1 in the grade it is clear that \psi(X)_{0}=\xi. Similarly, if k>j\geq 0 then \left(\sigma(X)^{k}\xi\right)_{j}=0 . Thus \psi(X)_{1}=-\sigma(X_{1})\xi and if j>1 then \psi(X)_{j}=\sum_{k=1}^{j}\frac{(-1)^{k}}{k!}\sigma(X)^{k}\xi. using the above observations, if j\leq q then \psi(X)_{j}=\sum_{k=1}^{j}\frac{(-1)^{k}}{k!}\left(\sigma(X_{1}+...+X_{j})^{k}\xi\right)_{j}. Hence \psi(X)_{j}=-\sigma(X_{j})\xi+\sum_{k=2}^{j}\frac{(-1)^{k}}{k!}\left(\sigma(X_{1}+...+X_{j-1})^{k}\xi\right)_{j} since \left(\sigma(X)^{k-l}\sigma(X_{j})\sigma(X)^{l-1}\xi\right)_{j}=0 if k-l\geq 0 , l-1\geq 0 and one of k-l>0 or l-1>0 . Take u_{j}(X_{1},...,X_{j-1})=\sum_{k=2}^{j}\frac{(-1)^{k}}{k!}\left(\sigma(X_{1}+...+X_{j-1})^{k}\xi\right)_{j}\text{.} Finally,if X\in\mathfrak{n}_{P} and \sigma(X)\xi=0 then ad(X)\mathfrak{\bar{n}}_{P}\mathfrak{\subset\mathfrak{\bar{n}}}_{P} . But if X\neq 0 then [X,\theta X]\in\mathfrak{a}-\{0\} . 3 A key lemma Lemma 3 Let \left(W,\left\langle...,...\right\rangle\right) and (V,(...,...)) be non-zero finite dimensional Hilbert spaces over \mathbb{R} such that W=\oplus_{j=1}^{q}W_{j} and V=\oplus_{{}_{j=0}}^{p}V_{j} orthogonal direct sums. If w\in W (resp. v\in V) set w_{j} (resp. v_{j} ) equal to its orthogonal projection into W_{j} (resp. V_{j} ). Let \varphi:W\rightarrow V be a map satisfying: If j=0 then \varphi(w)_{0} is non-zero and constant. If j=1 then \varphi(w)_{1}=T_{1}w_{1}\text{.} If 1<j\leq q then \varphi(w)_{j}=T_{j}w_{j}+u_{j}(w_{1}+...+w_{j-1}) with T_{j} an injective linear map of W_{j} into V_{j} for j=1,...,q and u_{j} is a polynomial