Algorithms in the Stacks: Investigating automated, for-profit diversity audits in public libraries Conference: The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency; June 23–26, 2025; Athens, Greece The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25), Ju
Melanie Walsh, Connor Franklin Rey, Chang Ge, Tina Nowak, Sabina Tomkins · 2025
Read Algorithms in the Stacks: Investigating automated, for-profit diversity audits in public libraries Conference: The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency; June 23–26, 2025; Athens, Greece The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25), Ju by Melanie Walsh, Connor Franklin Rey, Chang Ge, Tina Nowak, Sabina Tomkins (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14890.txt.
Introduction
Walsh and co-authors investigate the software that public libraries now buy to audit the diversity of their own shelves. Sold by book distributors, these automated audits score how well a collection mirrors demographic and thematic diversity. The team surveyed 99 public librarians, interviewed 14, and read purchasing records and vendor documents. The question was what happens when a normative judgment — whose stories a community needs — is outsourced to a commercial algorithm.
Librarians often welcomed the tools as time-savers under pressure. But the audits also squeezed complex identities into fixed boxes, missed local needs, and deepened libraries' dependence on the vendors who sell them books. The authors place the trend against a heated backdrop: anti-DEI campaigns and politically driven defunding. Their recommendations aim at audits that serve local judgment instead of replacing it. For any public institution buying algorithmic self-knowledge, the case study is a caution with receipts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Melanie Walsh, Connor Franklin Rey, Chang Ge, Tina Nowak, Sabina Tomkins |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14890
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Algorithms in the Stacks: Investigating automated, for-profit diversity audits in public libraries Conference: The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency; June 23–26, 2025; Athens, Greece The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25), June 23–26, 2025, Athens, Greece DOI: 10.1145/3715275.3732140 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1482-5/2025/06 CCS: Social and professional topics Automation CCS: Information systems Digital libraries and archives Melanie Walsh, Connor Franklin Rey, Chang Ge, Tina Nowak, Sabina Tomkins Abstract . Algorithmic systems are increasingly being adopted by cultural heritage institutions like libraries. In this study, we investigate U.S. public libraries’ adoption of one specific automated tool—automated collection diversity audits—which we see as an illuminating case study for broader trends. Typically developed and sold by commercial book distributors, automated diversity audits aim to evaluate how well library collections reflect demographic and thematic diversity. We investigate how these audits function, whether library workers find them useful, and what is at stake when sensitive, normative decisions about representation are outsourced to automated commercial systems. Our analysis draws on an anonymous survey of U.S. public librarians ( n = 99 n=99 ), interviews with 14 librarians, a sample of purchasing records, and vendor documentation. We find that many library workers view these tools as convenient, time-saving solutions for assessing and diversifying collections under real and increasing constraints. Yet at the same time, the audits often flatten complex identities into standardized categories, fail to reflect local community needs, and further entrench libraries’ infrastructural dependence on vendors. We conclude with recommendations for improving collection diversity audits and reflect on the broader implications for public libraries operating at the intersection of AI adoption, escalating anti-DEI backlash, and politically motivated defunding. † † cc-license: by-sa Figure 1 . A library collection diversity audit report from the vendor Ingram, showing representation of books per diversity category. 1. INTRODUCTION Algorithmic systems are increasingly being adopted by cultural heritage institutions like libraries, museums, and archives. In U.S. libraries, these tools now include recommendation systems that personalize borrowing suggestions ( Enis 2024 ; Price 2023 ; OCL 2023 ; Malespina 2024 ) ; chatbots that assist patrons with questions and search ( Szydlowski lish ; Get 2025 ; Rodriguez and Mune 2025 ; Rodriguez and Mune 2022 ) ; predictive algorithms that forecast book circulation and checkout hold times ( Enis 2014 ; Enis 2024 ) ; and automated tools that measure the “diversity” of thousands or even millions of library books (Figure 1 ). Like algorithmic systems adopted by other public institutions—such as courts, schools, and hospitals ( Sendak et al. 2020 ; Freund and Weng 2024 ) —these developments offer potential advantages and risks. While automated tools are often embraced to perform tasks faster, at scale, and with a veneer of objectivity, extensive research at FAccT and elsewhere has shown that they can also reinforce and exacerbate biases, even when the goal is to root them out ( Obermeyer and Mullainathan [n. d.] ; Raghavan et al. 2020 ; Eubanks 2018 ) . In this paper, we focus on the growing use of automated collection diversity audits in public libraries—tools that quantitatively measure how well library holdings reflect demographic and thematic diversity. These tools are typically developed and sold by third-party vendors, and are rapidly becoming normalized in library practice. While we focus on U.S. public libraries, collection diversity audits are increasingly being used in school and academic libraries, and outside the U.S. ( Libraries 2025 ; Pedersen 2022 ) . Broadly, we ask: What happens when sensitive, value-driven cultural work is partly outsourced to automated systems developed by commercial vendors? Can these tools meaningfully support the values they claim to advance? Central to these questions is the term diversity itself. While at its most basic, diversity means difference within a group, the term has become widely used in U.S. institutional contexts to refer to structurally marginalized human identities and backgrounds, and especially Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) efforts ( Leong 2025 ) . We acknowledge the complexity and long history of the term diversity in the U.S. ( Ahmed 2012 ; Melamed 2020 ; Lawrence 1997 ) . For clarity, we broadly use diverse and diversity as they are deployed by vendors—to signal books that represent historically marginalized identities or subjects—and we examine how their systems define and operationalize those terms. Collection diversity audits have emerged in response to longstanding inequities in both librarianship and book publishing ( So and Wezerek 2020 ; Lib 2024 ; Alter and Harris 2024b ) . While 61% of the U.S. population identified as white in the most recent census, over 81% of librarians and 72% of publishing industry employees identified as white as of 2023 ( Lib 2024 ; Low 2023 ; Bureau 2021 ) . The disparities are even greater in published books. Between 1950 and 2018, over 95% of the most widely held titles released by mainstream U.S. publishers were authored by white writers, according to a study by So and Wezerek 2020 . Because public libraries rely heavily on mainstream publishers, their collections are likely similarly skewed, limiting the kinds of stories and perspectives that are available to readers. Diversity audits aim to assess and address these gaps. They can prompt libraries to seek out more queer love stories; more narratives with Muslim protagonists; more books by and about Black and Indigenous people and other people of color. Yet in the increasingly hostile and reactionary political climate of the U.S.—marked by rising book bans and anti-DEI legislation ( ALA 2024 ; House 2025b ; Gardiner 2025 ; Adams and Chiwaya 2024 ; Alfonseca 2024 ; Swaine and Merrill 2025 ; America 2024 ) —diversity audits are not only used as tools to improve equity. They have also been used defensively: to demonstrate that library collections are not ideologically skewed toward progressive agendas and to push back against censorship efforts ( Schermele 2022 ; Escudero 2023 ) . While manual audits date back almost a decade ( Jensen and comments 2017 ) , the practice accelerated in 2021 when commercial vendors like Baker & Taylor, Ingram, and OverDrive introduced large-scale audit tools powered by proprietary metadata and automated classification ( Ingram 2021 ; Syme 2021 ; Staff 2022a ) . Where manually auditing just the children’s section of a library might take months, these tools promise to audit entire collections in weeks or days. The companies also provide “shopping lists” and recommended books to fill diversity gaps, which are typically books sold by the same vendor performing the audit. Despite their increased prevalence and popularity, little academic work has examined the effectiveness, accuracy, or implications of automated collection diversity audits ( Voels 2022 ) —and few FAccT studies have explored algorithmic interventions in cultural heritage settings ( Huang and Liem 2022 ; Jo and Gebru 2020 ) . To address these gaps, we draw on an anonymous survey of U.S. public librarians ( n =99), in-depth interviews with 14 librarians, purchasing records from a sample of public libraries, and an analysis of vendor documentation and promotional materials. We ask: • RQ1: How prevalent are automated collection diversity audits in libraries, and who provides them at what cost? • RQ2: How do automated collection diversity audits actually work,