Coordinated Motion Control of a Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Robotic System for Multi-directional Building Parts

Fernando Coutinho, Nicolas Lizarralde and Fernando Lizarralde · 2025

Read Coordinated Motion Control of a Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Robotic System for Multi-directional Building Parts by Fernando Coutinho, Nicolas Lizarralde and Fernando Lizarralde (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14858.txt.

Introduction

Fernando Coutinho, Nicolas Lizarralde, and Fernando Lizarralde control two robots building metal parts together in a 2025 paper. The process, wire arc additive manufacturing, lays down weld metal layer by layer, usually with the part kept flat.

Flat building fails on complex shapes, leaving overhangs and stepped surfaces. The authors' scheme steers the welding torch over the growing part while a second robot tilts the workpiece. Each new layer is kept aligned with gravity, which improves quality. The control method plans the torch path in the part's own frame while tracking orientation in the world frame. Parts with tricky geometry were built in a two-robot cell to prove the approach.

Catalog record

CREATORFernando Coutinho, Nicolas Lizarralde and Fernando Lizarralde
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14858

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Coordinated Motion Control of a Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Robotic System for Multi-directional Building Parts Fernando Coutinho, Nicolas Lizarralde and Fernando Lizarralde Abstract Note to Practitioners This work addresses the technical constraints of Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) regarding non-planar geometries and variable build directions. To mitigate issues like unsupported overhangs and the staircase effect, we present a closed-loop coordinated control algorithm for dual-robot systems, where a manipulator guides the torch and a secondary robot repositions the substrate. The practical advantage lies in the task-augmentation scheme that automates gravity-aligned deposition, ensuring the melt pool remains stable and flat throughout the process. This eliminates the need for complex support structures and minimizes post-processing. By synchronizing both robots, the algorithm allows operators to plan trajectories directly on the workpiece frame while the controller autonomously maintains optimal torch orientation relative to an inertial frame, significantly enhancing surface quality and operational efficiency in complex part production. I Introduction Metal additive manufacturing (MAM) is the process of producing near-net-shaped metallic parts layer-by-layer from a computer-aided design (CAD) model while maintaining predetermined internal characteristics [ 1 ] . Although MAM cannot be considered a novel method for manufacturing parts, since the first experiments with this technology date from the early 1980s, when it was first termed rapid prototyping [ 2 ] , it has recently attracted interest from industry and academia due to its high capability to manufacture complex structural parts that are difficult or even not possible to manufacture using conventional manufacturing techniques [ 2 , 3 ] . The parts produced with MAM are printed in layers using consumable materials, mostly metal powder or metal wire feedstock, hence, MAM can save time and material in the fabrication of parts with complex shapes if compared to conventional subtractive manufacturing technology, which starts with an oversized raw block and removes unwanted material [ 4 ] . Furthermore, MAM processes usually have the flexibility to produce a numerous variety of parts using the same set of equipment and feedstock, which attracts the interest of all kinds of industries, specially those located in isolated environments with difficult access to transport spare parts (e.g., mining, oil, gas). Among the available MAM technologies described in the ASTM F2792 standard, wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) stands out due to its potential capability to produce large parts with distinct geometry without the necessity of specific tools. WAAM is the combination of wire feedstock with an electric arc as a heat source, all guided by a robotic system to enable the buildup of a designed part. It uses standard robotic welding hardware, such as welding power source, torch, wire feeding system, positioning table, robot arm, and others common welding equipment [ 5 ] , which makes it less expensive and more adaptable for existing production lines. Complex geometry parts for which build direction is not constant remain a challenge for WAAM due to the unsupported overhang sections, in which the molten material may drip and spread to undesired areas. An example of a multi-directional building part (curved pipe) produced with WAAM is shown in Fig. 1 . Fig. 1: Multi-directional building example. Many researches investigate the possibility of producing complex parts using WAAM by a variety of techniques such as depositing using support structures to deal with overhang sections, changing the torch orientation while keeping the deposition substrate parallel to the ground [ 6 ] . The use of support structures leads to an increase of waste and cost of post-processing [ 7 ] and leads to a non-optimal manufacturing time. Changing only the torch direction with respect to the substrate produces irregular melting pool geometry, which leads to changes in the morphology of the deposited bead [ 8 ] leading to a stair-stepping effect on the part surface and degrades the part’s volumetric accuracy [ 9 ] . Conventional additive manufacturing systems are generally limited to three degrees of freedom (DOF) with fixed nozzle orientation [ 10 ] . For WAAM, the most common system utilized to carry the welding power source torch is the standard 6-DOF manipulator, mostly because the majority of power sources and industrial manipulators manufacturers already provide fully integrated solutions between these hardware as they are commonly used for industrial welding tasks. For this setup, the building of parts with unsupported overhangs, depending on the inclined or curved section of the structure, may not be achievable by WAAM as gravity affects the morphology of the molten pool [ 11 ] . In recent years, many researchers have turned their efforts to additive manufacturing technologies with redundant robotic systems. The extra DOFs available on these systems are useful to improve the part strength and the surface quality or, as it is the case for WAAM, produce more complex parts [ 10 , 12 ] . In order to produce complex geometry parts and reduce production time, [ 13 ] proposed similar offline planning algorithms for manufacturing specific rounded metal additive manufacturing parts parts with a system that coupled a 6-axis robot manipulator with a 2-axis positioning table. These methods consist of planning the deposition trajectory while using an external-axis system in order to maintain the molten pool orientation with respect to gravity. For curved parts offline solutions [ 14 , 13 , 11 ] , the part was either fabricated in the center of the deposition surface, aligned with the axis of rotation of the positioning table, or the substrate (e.g. metal cylinder) was centered to facilitate the part manufacturing and trajectory planning. A general limitation of offline planning methods is that although they allow parameters correction before each layer deposition, they cannot make trajectory or deposition parameters corrections during the deposition. For instance, the deposition bead/layer geometry could be monitored and estimated by sensors and an online closed loop control could adjust the deposition parameters (arc current, wire feed speed), deposition path and tool center point (TCP) travel speed [ 15 , 16 ] . For a WAAM system composed by two robots, which together constitute a single redundant kinematic chain, it is possible to control the motions of both the workpiece and the torch, in order to decouple the orientation between the torch and the workpiece and the orientation between the torch and an inertial frame (e.g. gravity). This strategy allows full closed loop control, which could be used for parameters corrections during deposition and facilitates the deposition trajectory planning, since the trajectory can be designed directly on the deposition substrate while keeping the building direction aligned with both the deposition orientation and an inertial frame. In the present study, the deposition trajectory with respect to the deposition frame (positioning table workpiece) and the TCP orientation with respect to an inertial frame are treated as one single trajectory reference in order to maintain the building direction aligned with gravity during each layer deposition. Which means that, for the additive manufacturing of complex shaped parts structures with unsupported overhangs is treated as a multi robot coordinated motion problem by defining an augmented task vector which considers both the deposition trajectory and the deposition alignment with an inertial frame, solved by using the augmented Jacobian approach. The augmented Jacobian method presents a more general approach alternative to the task-priority

Read the complete text