Voice to Vision: Enhancing Civic Decision-Making through Co-Designed Data Infrastructure

Margaret Hughes, Cassandra Overney, Ashima Kamra, Jasmin Tepale, Elizabeth Hamby, Mahmood Jasim, Deb Roy · 2025

Read Voice to Vision: Enhancing Civic Decision-Making through Co-Designed Data Infrastructure by Margaret Hughes, Cassandra Overney, Ashima Kamra, Jasmin Tepale, Elizabeth Hamby, Mahmood Jasim, Deb Roy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14853.txt.

Introduction

Margaret Hughes and co-authors present Voice to Vision, a system for civic planning feedback, in this 2025 paper. Residents often send comments on neighborhood plans into a void. They never learn whether their input changed anything. Trust in the process fades as a result.

The system gives community members and planners linked interfaces over one shared data structure. It was co designed over five months with 21 stakeholders. A field test then involved 24 participants. Planners valued tools that find connections across many diverse comments. Residents valued seeing themselves reflected in the process and seeing patterns in feedback. Both sides wanted clear, actionable outcomes. The paper draws design lessons for civic technology.

Catalog record

CREATORMargaret Hughes, Cassandra Overney, Ashima Kamra, Jasmin Tepale, Elizabeth Hamby, Mahmood Jasim, Deb Roy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14853

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Voice to Vision: Enhancing Civic Decision-Making through Co-Designed Data Infrastructure Margaret Hughes, Cassandra Overney, Ashima Kamra, Jasmin Tepale, Elizabeth Hamby, Mahmood Jasim, Deb Roy Abstract . Trust and transparency in civic decision-making processes, like neighborhood planning, are eroding as community members frequently report sending feedback “into a void” without understanding how, or whether, their input influences outcomes. To address this gap, we introduce Voice to Vision, a sociotechnical system that bridges community voices and planning outputs through a structured yet flexible data infrastructure and complementary interfaces for both community members and planners. Through a five-month iterative design process with 21 stakeholders and subsequent field evaluation involving 24 participants, we examine how this system facilitates shared understanding across the civic ecosystem. Our findings reveal that while planners value systematic sensemaking tools that find connections across diverse inputs, community members prioritize seeing themselves reflected in the process, discovering patterns within feedback, and observing the rigor behind decisions, while emphasizing the importance of actionable outcomes. We contribute insights into participatory design for civic contexts, a complete sociotechnical system with an interoperable data structure for civic decision-making, and empirical findings that inform how digital platforms can promote shared understanding among elected or appointed officials, planners, and community members by enhancing transparency and legitimacy. CCS: Human-centered computing Interactive systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Visualization systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative and social computing systems and tools CCS: Applied computing Computing in government Figure 1 . A diagram of the Voice to Vision system showing the flow of community voice data between community members and planners during an engagement process. This system helps close feedback loops between both stakeholder groups. TODO 1. Introduction Trust and legitimacy in civic processes are foundational to effective democratic governance, yet in urban planning and other civic domains, a persistent challenge exists in connecting community input to decision outcomes. While planners invest significant resources in gathering community voices, the process of transforming this input into concrete planning outputs remains opaque, often leading to perceptions that engagement efforts merely “check a box” rather than meaningfully shape decisions ( Overney et al., 2025b ) . The challenge of building shared understanding between planners and communities is particularly acute in metropolitan areas, where neighborhoods may house populations equivalent to small cities (15,000-100,000 residents). At this scale, cooperation requires navigating diverse current needs against future priorities while considering a multitude of hopes, concerns, and visions ( Baumer et al., 2022 ) . These complex planning processes involve multiple stakeholder groups, such as planners, community members, other city agencies, and elected or appointed officials, each with distinct needs, constraints, and perspectives on what constitutes successful engagement ( Jasim et al., 2021a ) . Planning departments increasingly face expectations to demonstrate responsiveness to community input, creating a significant need for systems that support both rigorous sensemaking of feedback and transparent communication of outcomes ( Villanueva et al., 2017 ) . Addressing these complex cooperation challenges requires sociotechnical solutions that balance technological capacity with relational sensitivity. In HCI and CSCW fields, researchers have developed technological systems to improve both the gathering of community input ( Overney et al., 2025a ; Jasim et al., 2021b ; Kriplean et al., 2012 ) and the analysis capabilities of decision-makers ( Jasim et al., 2021a ) . In addition, platforms like Polis ( Small, 2021 ) and other deliberative systems demonstrate the potential for technology to facilitate large-scale civic participation. Within planning practice, considerable work focuses on strengthening the social relationship-building aspects of community engagement ( Harvey, 1970 ) . However, a critical gap persists at the intersection of planning practice and CSCW research. While each domain offers valuable insights, they rarely inform each other. Planning literature emphasizes relationship-building without technological sophistication, while civic technology often adopts transactional approaches that focus narrowly on either collecting input or supporting analysis in isolation ( Corbett and Le Dantec, 2018 ) . This separation has resulted in few systems that create comprehensive data infrastructures connecting community voices to planning outputs. Such fragmentation contributes to the black box perception of planning, where residents provide feedback but cannot trace how (or whether) it influences outcomes, further eroding trust in civic processes. Our work addresses this gap through an integrated sociotechnical system that supports both the analytical needs of planners and the transparency demands of community members. We conducted a five-month iterative design process, employing co-design and participatory design methods with 12 planners (two of whom are co-authors) and 9 community members. This process identified 5 key design goals that informed the development of Voice to Vision, a comprehensive sociotechnical system comprising a data structure and two complementary interfaces: a sensemaking interface for planners and a community-facing platform for the public. We evaluated the system through a six-week field deployment of the community-facing platform in an ongoing neighborhood planning process with 15 community member interviews. The sensemaking interface was evaluated through qualitative user studies with 7 planners. Our evaluation revealed Voice to Vision’s potential to strengthen the connection between community input and planning outcomes. Planners emphasized the system’s value in supporting systematic sensemaking by enabling them to find connections across diverse inputs and communicate outputs accessibly, a capability lacking in their typical spreadsheet-based workflows. Among community members, we observed multifaceted benefits: participants valued seeing themselves and others reflected in the voices, discovering patterns within community feedback, and witnessing the rigor behind decision-making processes. However, they consistently emphasized actionability as a critical concern, wanting to see concrete paths from community input to implementation. Both stakeholder groups demonstrated a preference for digestible information formats while appreciating the availability of deeper exploration opportunities. Perhaps most significantly, the platform facilitated a sense of legitimacy and care across the civic ecosystem, helping build shared understanding between officials, planners, and community members. The primary contributions of our work are: (1) Insights and reflections on a design process with novel mitigations to common challenges that arise when doing participatory design in governance contexts (2) Voice to Vision, a complete sociotechnical system with an interoperable data structure for urban planning, community engagement, and constituency-informed decision-making (3) Empirical insights from a field deployment and qualitative interviews with 24 participants that inform future work on designing tools for civic decision-making to promote shared understanding between stakeholders 1.1. Positionality Statement Our research team brings together academic researchers from human-computer interaction and data visualization with practicing urban planners who have direct responsibility for neighborhood planning processes. Two of our co-authors are city planners who simultaneously played multiple roles during this work: they managed the specific planning process studied, contributed to department-wide process improvements, and represented a public agency with civic leadership responsibilities. Additionally, one co-author is a resident of the neighborhood where we conducted our field deployment, bringing both researcher and community member perspectives to the work. We acknowledge that our team’s shared interest in creating more transparent connections between community voices and planning outputs influenced our design priorities, sometimes prioritizing this challenge over other concerns raised by community members during our design process. We used co-design methods with planners, integrating them fully into research and design decisions, while employing participatory design with community members through workshops and

Read the complete text