Designing Semantically-Resonant Abstract Patterns for Data Visualization

\authororcid Zihan Lu0009-0003-1610-7435, \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-0500-7995, \authororcid Jiayi Hong0000-0002-1332-5045, \authororcid Lijie Yao0000-0002-4208-5140, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 · 2025

Read Designing Semantically-Resonant Abstract Patterns for Data Visualization by \authororcid Zihan Lu0009-0003-1610-7435, \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-0500-7995, \authororcid Jiayi Hong0000-0002-1332-5045, \authororcid Lijie Yao0000-0002-4208-5140, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14816.txt.

Introduction

Zihan Lu and four co-authors set out a method for designing abstract patterns that hint at what they stand for, in a 2025 paper. A pattern of small dots might stand for olives in a food chart, just as olive green does among colors. Such meaning-matched colors are known to speed chart reading, but patterns lacked a shared design method.

The team ran workshops with design experts and distilled their practice into a step-by-step methodology. They then tested the method in workshops with non-designers. The novices succeeded in making meaning-matched patterns for both abstract and concrete ideas. The authors offer the method as a way for the general public to build clearer, friendlier data displays.

Catalog record

CREATOR\authororcid Zihan Lu0009-0003-1610-7435, \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-0500-7995, \authororcid Jiayi Hong0000-0002-1332-5045, \authororcid Lijie Yao0000-0002-4208-5140, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14816

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Designing Semantically-Resonant Abstract Patterns for Data Visualization \authororcid Zihan Lu0009-0003-1610-7435, \authororcid Tingying He0000-0002-0500-7995, \authororcid Jiayi Hong0000-0002-1332-5045, \authororcid Lijie Yao0000-0002-4208-5140, \authororcid Tobias Isenberg0000-0001-7953-8644 Abstract We present a structured design methodology for creating semantically-resonant abstract patterns, making the pattern design process accessible to the general public. Semantically-resonant patterns are those that intuitively evoke the concept they represent within a specific set (e.g., in a vegetable concept set, small dots for olives and large dots for tomatoes), analogous to the concept of semantically-resonant colors (e.g., using olive green for olives and red for tomatoes). Previous research has shown that semantically-resonant colors can improve chart reading speed, and designers have made attempts to integrate semantic cues into abstract pattern designs. However, a systematic framework for developing such patterns was lacking. To bridge this gap, we conducted a series of workshops with design experts, resulting in a design methodology that summarizes the methodology for designing semantically-resonant abstract patterns. We evaluated our design methodology through another series of workshops with non-design participants. The results indicate that our proposed design methodology effectively supports the general public in designing semantically-resonant abstract patterns for both abstract and concrete concepts. \onlineid 0 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype please specify \authorfooter Z. Lu ( ) and T. Isenberg are with Univ. Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Inria, LISN, France. Emails: [email protected], [email protected], T. He ( ) is with Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Inria, LISN, France and the University of Utah, USA. E-mail: [email protected], J. Hong ( ) is with the Arizona State University, USA. Email: [email protected], L. Yao ( ) is with Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University, China. Email: [email protected] Z. Lu and T. He share first authorship. T. He is corresponding author. keywords Patterns, visual representations, design. 1 Introduction The concept of “semantically-resonant” design refers to choices when creating visual data mappings that evoke specific concepts or associations in a viewer, as originally defined by Lin et al. [ 20 ] in the context of color. Their study showed that semantically-resonant colors (e. g., representing bananas in yellow rather than blue) enhance chart reading speed, especially when strong concept-color associations exist. Follow-up work [ 33 ] also showed that color-concept associations have the potential to help viewers interpret visualizations more intuitively than with non-resonant mappings. In contexts where color is unavailable or insufficient, black-and-white patterns offer an important alternative visual variable option [ 12 ] . These patterns have shown benefits for visualization, from historical applications to modern-life practices. Leveraging pattern-concept associations may similarly improve chart reading and interpretation as color-concept associations. Prior research by He et al. [ 15 ] explored the influence of using patterns in visualization by asking designers to create black-and-white patterns for visualizations, focusing on two types: abstract geometric patterns (using simple lines or dots) and iconic patterns (such as a banana icon for bananas) . Although iconic patterns are inherently semantically-resonant, they did not improve chart reading speed as expected [ 15 ] . In contrast, abstract geometric patterns showed promise, particularly in enhancing reading speed in pie charts. An intriguing observation in He et al.’s study [ 15 ] showed participants attempted to embed semantic meaning into patterns while they created abstract geometric patterns. One designer mainly used the strategy of creating associations between patterns and the concepts they represent ( Figure 12 in Appendix B shows such design, and we discuss related strategies in Appendix B ), e. g., used small and large dots to represent olives and tomatoes, respectively, reflecting their relative physical sizes. Such design received the highest aesthetic pleasure rating among 14 expert-designed bar charts with abstract patterns. In their past work, He et al. [ 15 ] focused broadly on pattern design—without discussing in-depth how to systematically embed semantic meaning into abstract geometric patterns. Their findings, however, suggest that such abstract patterns have the potential to carry meaningful associations that enhance both the readability and aesthetics of the visuals that use the patterns. Building on this insight, our work specifically investigates how to effectively embed semantic meaning into abstract geometric patterns. We first conducted a series of design workshops with 13 design experts to design semantically-resonant abstract patterns for three concept sets that range from the concrete to the abstract: vegetables, music genres, and emotions. This workshop yielded 273 pattern designs and associated design strategies. Based on our qualitative coding of the feedback we received from the design experts, we developed a structured design methodology for how to design semantically-resonant abstract patterns. Our design methodology categorizes the approaches into two key steps: first, to identify the underlying content to be visualized and, second, to encode the content as suitable patterns. Based on the codes we analyzed, we identified possible approaches that are applicable at each stage of this process. Subsequently, we conducted another series of workshops with 12 non-expert participants to assess whether our design methodology can effectively guide them in creating semantically-resonant patterns. This second group of workshops demonstrated the effectiveness of our design methodology , as most participants consider it useful, easy to use, and helpful for both abstract and concrete concepts. The results of the evaluation workshops also show that our design methodology comprehensively covers potential thinking directions for designing semantically-resonant patterns. In summary, our contributions include (1) a structured design methodology, which summarizes approaches for designing abstract semantically-resonant patterns that work for both abstract and concrete concepts, derived from expert-led design workshops, along with a curated set of pattern designs. We also contribute (2) an evaluation of our design methodology with non-experts, which demonstrates its effectiveness in supporting semantically-resonant pattern design without requiring specialized design knowledge. Overall, our methodology advances the understanding of the visual variable pattern , expands the toolkit available to visualization designers, and lowers barriers for non-experts to engage in visualization design. 2 Background and related work We first discuss the difference between abstract and concrete concepts, followed by associations between visual variables and concepts. 2.1 Concrete and abstract concepts According to research in psychology, concrete concepts are tangible and directly experienced through sensory perception (e.g., “cat” or “chair”), while abstract concepts are intangible and not directly perceived with our sensors (e.g., “love” or “freedom”) [ 27 , 42 , 7 , 4 , 24 ] . People understand these two types of concepts in different ways. According to embodied cognition theory [ 35 ] , people comprehend concepts through perceptual experiences, which can include sensorimotor (e. g., vision or hearing) and emotional experiences. Concrete concepts are often strongly associated with sensorimotor experiences, while abstract concepts are understood more through emotional and metaphorical connections [ 1 , 39 , 37 , 40 ] . Based on embodied cognition, conceptual metaphor theory [ 18 ] also provides a framework for our meaning-making process and a theoretical foundation for understanding the visualization process [ 28 , 30 , 29 ] . It states that we understand the concepts in one concept domain by associating them with another concept in another concept domain. Therefore, to understand an abstract concept, we can link this abstract concept to a more concrete one [ 38 , 10 , 9 ] . To visually represent these two types of concepts, there might also be differences. In semiotics, Peirce categorized signs into three types based on their

Read the complete text