Lomb-Scargle periodograms struggle with non-sinusoidal supermassive BH binary signatures in quasar lightcurves
Allison Lin, Maria Charisi, Zoltán Haiman · 2025
Read Lomb-Scargle periodograms struggle with non-sinusoidal supermassive BH binary signatures in quasar lightcurves by Allison Lin, Maria Charisi, Zoltán Haiman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14778.txt.
Introduction
Allison Lin, Maria Charisi, and Zoltán Haiman published this astronomy paper in 2025. Pairs of supermassive black holes should betray themselves by making their host quasars brighten and dim on a regular cycle. Searches usually rely on the Lomb-Scargle periodogram, a standard tool tuned to smooth sine-wave signals. Simulations, though, predict spikier, sawtooth-shaped pulses. The team tested how badly that mismatch hurts detection.
They built fake quasar light curves with realistic noise and injected both sine and sawtooth signals. They mimicked an older survey's data and the coming Rubin Observatory survey. Even sine signals were recovered less than half the time. Sawtooth recovery collapsed to about nine percent in survey-like data and near one percent in the cleaner sets. The authors conclude past searches missed most binaries, and future surveys need better tools than the standard periodogram.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Allison Lin, Maria Charisi, Zoltán Haiman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14778
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lomb-Scargle periodograms struggle with non-sinusoidal supermassive BH binary signatures in quasar lightcurves Allison Lin, Maria Charisi, Zoltán Haiman Abstract Supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) systems are expected to form as a consequence of galaxy mergers. At sub-parsec separations, SMBHBs can be identified as quasars with periodic variability with previous periodicity searches uncovering significant candidates. However, these searches focused primarily on sinusoidal signals, while theoretical models and hydrodynamical simulations predict that binaries produce more complex non-sinusoidal pulse shapes. Here we examine the efficacy of the Lomb-Scargle periodogram (LSP; one of the most popular tools for periodicity searches in unevenly sampled lightcurves) to detect periodicities with a sawtooth shape mimicking results of hydrodynamical simulations. We simulate idealised well-sampled lightcurves, lightcurves that mimic the data in the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) analyzed in [ 12 ] , and lightcurves that resemble our expectations for single-band data in the upcoming Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) of the Rubin Observatory. We approximate quasar variability with a damped random walk (DRW) model, inject sinusoidal and sawtooth pulse shapes and assess their statistical significance. We find that in the presence of red noise the LSP detects a relatively low fraction of the sinusoidal signals ( ∼ \sim 45%, ∼ \sim 24% and ∼ \sim 23%, in the PTF-like, idealised, and LSST-like lightcurves, respectively). The fraction is significantly reduced for sawtooth periodicity (with only ∼ \sim 9% in PTF-like and ∼ \sim 1% in idealised and LSST-like lightcurves). These low recovery rates imply that previous searches have missed the large majority of binaries. They also have significant implications for the detection of SMBHBs in upcoming LSST necessating the developement of advanced tools that go beyond the simple LSP. I Introduction Observational evidence suggests that supermassive black holes (SMBHs) exist at the center of every massive galaxy [ 59 , 46 ] . The SMBHs play an important role in shaping their host galaxies, since the mass of the SMBHs is correlated to several properties of the host. In addition, frequent mergers of galaxies naturally deliver two SMBHs to the nucleus of the post-merger galaxies, which can eventually form bound SMBH binaries [ 6 ] . After the galaxies merge, the SMBHs sink towards the center of the post-merger galaxy through dynamical friction. As the SMBHs spiral closer toward each other, they form a near-Keplerian system. When they reach separations of a few parsecs, gravitational interactions with nearby stars and the gaseous circumbinary disk can continue to shrink the binary orbits. If these mechanisms are sufficiently effective to overcome the ’final-parsec problem,’ gravitational wave (GW) emission takes over, accelerating the inspiral toward the merger. The most massive systems can be detected at nanohertz GW frequencies with pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) [ 10 , 67 ] . In fact, all major PTA collaborations, like the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav), the European Pulsar Timing Array (EPTA) along with the Indian Pulsar Timing Array (InPTA), the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array (PPTA), the Chinese Pulsar Timing Array (CPTA) and the MeerKAT Pulsar Timing Array (MPTA) have recently detected evidence for a GW background [ 2 , 26 , 58 , 76 , 54 ] , which is likely produced by a population of SMBH binaries [ 3 , 27 ] . Individual binaries are expected to be resolved on top of this background in a few years [ 40 , 68 , 5 ] . In addition to strong GWs, binaries are also expected to produce bright electromagnetic (EM) emission, since SMBH binaries reach small separations surrounded by large amounts of gas, which accretes to the SMBHs and produces bright EM signatures. Therefore, binaries are promising sources for multi-messenger observations combining EM+GW data [ 44 , 31 , 39 , 14 ] . Given that binary systems are expected to form in gas-rich environments, several hydrodynamic simulations have explored such systems embedded in gaseous disks. These studies suggest that binaries may manifest as quasars with periodic variability. More specifically, simulations demonstrate that torques exerted by the binary expel the gas from the central-most region and create a low-density cavity. As the orbital motion of the binary perturbs the cavity edge, the SMBHs pull streams of gas inwards, leading to periodic mass transfer from the disk onto the binary components, which translates into periodic brightness fluctuations [ 72 , e.g.] . Periodic variability can also arise due to Doppler boost from gas bound to the individual SMBHs, and from self-lensing effects (see Bogdanovic et al. 7 and D’Orazio & Charisi 22 for recent reviews). Many observational studies have searched for this EM signature in time-domain surveys and identified several candidate SMBHBs as quasars with periodically varying optical emission. Note that this approach associates the bright quasar phases with SMBHBs, which is justified as quasars are thought often to be triggered by mergers [ 38 ] . However, the search requires large surveys, because the binary lifetime due to gravitational-wave inspiral would be of order 10^{5} years, which is \sim 10^{-3} of the typical expected bright quasar phase [ 31 ] . This implies that even if most quasars are binaries, we would expect to find them only in a small fraction \lesssim 10^{-3} of quasars. Suitably large systematic searches in the Catalina Real-Time Transient Survey (CRTS; Graham et al. 30 ), the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF; Charisi et al. 12 ), the Panoramic Survey Telescope and Rapid Response System (PanSTARRS; Liu et al. 50 ), the Dark Energy Survey (DES; Chen et al. 15 ), the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF; Chen et al. 17 ), the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE; Luo et al. 52 ) and Gaia [ 33 ] have revealed over 200 candidates to date. Additional candidates were also identified individually in lightcurves from long-term observing campaigns [ 19 , 8 , 49 ] . However, quasars exhibit red noise variability, which can mimic periodic signals introducing false positives, while at the same time hindering the identification of genuine periodicity [ 71 , 73 , 20 , 60 ] . This is exacerbated by limitations in our understanding of the stochastic variability of quasars, which in previous periodicity searches was modeled with a DRW model [ 42 , 53 , 47 , 65 , 9 ] and the fact that binaries typically have relatively long periods allowing only 2-3 cycles to be observed [ 71 ] . Therefore, additional signatures, such as spectral line shifts indicative of radial motion [ 28 ] , multi-wavelength Doppler boost [ 24 , 13 , 74 ] , distorted radio jets [ 61 , 11 ] or atypical X-ray spectra [ 62 ] , are required to boost the significance of each candidate. We refer the reader to De Rosa et al. [21] and D’Orazio & Charisi [22] for reviews on binary signatures and observational searches. To date, most searches for periodic variability have focused on sinusoidal periodicity, which is the simplest periodic signal. A widely used method for detecting periodic signals in unevenly sampled data is the Lomb-Scargle periodogram (LSP; Lomb 51 , Scargle 63 or VanderPlas 70 for a recent review). The LSP (along with other Fourier-based techniques) is particularly effective in identifying sinusoidal variations, but may