Semi-parametric efficient estimation of small genetic effects in large-scale population cohorts
Olivier Labayle 1,2 , Breeshey Roskams-Hieter 1,2 , Joshua Slaughter 1,2 , Kelsey Tetley-Campbell 1,2 , Mark J. van der Laan 3 , Chris P. Ponting 1 , Sjoerd Viktor Beentjes 1,3,4,* , Ava Khamseh 1,2,3,* · 2025
Read Semi-parametric efficient estimation of small genetic effects in large-scale population cohorts by Olivier Labayle 1,2 , Breeshey Roskams-Hieter 1,2 , Joshua Slaughter 1,2 , Kelsey Tetley-Campbell 1,2 , Mark J. van der Laan 3 , Chris P. Ponting 1 , Sjoerd Viktor Beentjes 1,3,4,* , Ava Khamseh 1,2,3,* (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14675.txt.
Introduction
Labayle and co-authors present a statistics workflow, published in 2025, for measuring small gene effects in huge population studies. Modern cohorts hold millions of people and variants, and most effects are tiny. Sloppy models can flood results with false finds. Their workflow estimates effects with methods that stay honest even when parts of the model are off. It also handles effects that arise only when several variants act together, and it copes with tangled backgrounds.
The method builds in double protection: two chances to get the background adjustment right. It keeps that rigor while still running at cohort scale. Interactions are framed as direct comparisons, which makes them easier to read. The authors argue that careful design matters as much as sample size. Their tool aims to make gene-effect claims from giant cohorts worth trusting.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Olivier Labayle 1,2 , Breeshey Roskams-Hieter 1,2 , Joshua Slaughter 1,2 , Kelsey Tetley-Campbell 1,2 , Mark J. van der Laan 3 , Chris P. Ponting 1 , Sjoerd Viktor Beentjes 1,3,4,* , Ava Khamseh 1,2,3,* |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 103 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14675
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Semi-parametric efficient estimation of small genetic effects in large-scale population cohorts Olivier Labayle 1,2 , Breeshey Roskams-Hieter 1,2 , Joshua Slaughter 1,2 , Kelsey Tetley-Campbell 1,2 , Mark J. van der Laan 3 , Chris P. Ponting 1 , Sjoerd Viktor Beentjes 1,3,4,* , Ava Khamseh 1,2,3,* Abstract . Population genetics seeks to quantify DNA variant associations with traits or diseases, as well as interactions among variants and with environmental factors. Computing millions of estimates in large cohorts in which small effect sizes are expected, necessitates minimising model-misspecification bias to control false discoveries. We present TarGene, a unified statistical workflow for the semi-parametric efficient and double robust estimation of genetic effects including k k -point interactions among categorical variables in the presence of confounding and weak population dependence. k k -point interactions, or Average Interaction Effects (AIEs), are a direct generalisation of the usual average treatment effect (ATE). We estimate AIEs with cross-validated and/or weighted versions of Targeted Minimum Loss-based Estimators (TMLE) and One-Step Estimators (OSE). The effect of dependence among data units on variance estimates is corrected by using sieve plateau variance estimators based on genetic relatedness across the units. We present extensive realistic simulations to demonstrate power, coverage, and control of type I error. Our motivating application is the targeted estimation of genetic effects on trait, including two-point and higher-order gene-gene and gene-environment interactions, in large-scale genomic databases such as UK Biobank and All of Us. All cross-validated and/or weighted TMLE and OSE for the AIE k k -point interaction, as well as ATEs, conditional ATEs and functions thereof, are implemented in the general purpose Julia package TMLE.jl. For high-throughput applications in population genomics, we provide the open-source Nextflow pipeline and software TarGene which integrates seamlessly with modern high-performance and cloud computing platforms. 1. Introduction Over the past 15 years, many genetic risk loci have been associated with disease or traits ( Visscher et al.,, 2017 ) . Most genetic effect sizes are small and require large samples to be reliably estimated ( Uffelmann et al.,, 2021 ) . Their detection helps guide interventions on the downstream disease consequences of the variant that may be both sizeable and clinically relevant ( Minikel et al.,, 2024 ; King et al.,, 2019 ) . Nevertheless, a slight bias, such as when an estimation model is misspecified, can appreciably alter genetic effect estimates and, additionally, their associated confidence intervals may not have the theoretical nominal coverage of the ground truth. This problem of bias is exacerbated for larger sample sizes that yield more confident estimates. Statistical models in common use, such as logistic, linear and linear mixed models (LMMs) ( Uffelmann et al.,, 2021 ) , rely on parametric assumptions, including linearity of the variant-covariate-trait relationship, and normality of the associated conditional distribution. LMMs also usually include a random effect to capture population relatedness ( Uffelmann et al.,, 2021 ; Svishcheva et al.,, 2012 ; Lippert et al.,, 2011 ) . When genotype assignment is entirely random ( i.e. , without population stratification), and when non-linear genotype effects are absent, the commonly employed LMM model is adequate for estimating the true effect size consistently. Nevertheless, genetic effects are often non-linear ( Palmer et al., 2023a, ; Milind et al.,, 2024 ; Mackay and Anholt,, 2024 ) , and have been accounted for as an additive-plus-dominance part of an LMM ( Huang and Mackay,, 2016 ) . Also, warped LMM has generalised LMMs by transforming outcomes to account for non-Gaussian distributed residuals ( Fusi et al.,, 2014 ) . Recent applications of ML algorithms, such as DeepNull/XGBoost ( McCaw et al.,, 2022 ) , can adaptively account for genetics and confounder/covariate non-linearities data-adaptively, yet they lack theoretical guarantees of consistency and coverage. Furthermore, for any variant and trait combination, the validity of any linearity assumption is a priori unknown, and so provides no guarantee that the LMM is a consistent estimator with nominal coverage. Beyond single variant associations, interactions among multiple variants, known as epistasis, may be even smaller and more complicated to estimate ( Wei et al.,, 2014 ) yet are crucial to understanding complex disease ( Mackay and Anholt,, 2024 ) . In summary, robust estimation techniques are needed to accurately estimate genetic effect sizes, together with interactions among variants, and interactions among variants and environmental factors. The Targeted Learning (TL) Roadmap offers a step-by-step guide to estimating causal and statistical parameters from real-world data with minimal bias ( Gruber et al.,, 2024 ) . This includes the construction of substitution estimators, including Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimators (TMLE), which are semi-parametric efficient under minimal assumptions ( Van der Laan and Rubin,, 2006 ) . TL has been successfully applied in various clinical and biomedical settings to generate real-world evidence ( Fong et al.,, 2022 ; Gilbert et al.,, 2022 ; Havlir et al.,, 2019 ) . Here, we introduce Targeted Genomic Estimation (TarGene), a method based on targeted semi-parametric estimation theory ( Pfanzagl and Wefelmeyer, 1985a, ; Van der Laan and Rose,, 2011 ) following the TL roadmap for the estimation of genetic effects of single variants and interactions. The five key contributions of this paper are as follows. (1) Development of semi-parametric estimators, namely, Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimator (TMLE), weighted TMLE (wTMLE), one-step estimator (OSE) and their cross-validated (CV) versions, for k -point interaction effects on outcome, here among genetic variants, and genetic variants and environmental factors. (2) Accounting for population dependence structure, by updating variance estimates via a network adaptation of the sieve plateau variance estimator of Davies and van der Laan, (2014) . (3) Extensive simulations to assess type I error, power, and coverage of various semi-parametric estimators and target parameters in realistic population genetics contexts. This includes (rare) binary outcomes, continuous outcomes, and categorical variants with diverse population frequencies. (4) A general purpose Julia software package, TMLE.jl , implements these semi-parametric estimators and k -point interaction target parameters. (5) An end-to-end Nextflow pipeline, software and documentation, TarGene , for scalable and seamless application to large-scale biobanks ( 0.5 million or more individuals) such as the UK Biobank ( Bycroft et al.,, 2018 ) and the All of Us cohort ( Bick et al.,, 2024 ) . As an illustration, we apply TarGene to five applications on UK Biobank data: (i) Performing a Phenome-wide Association Study (PheWAS) for the FTO intronic variant rs1421085, a candidate causal variant for obesity ( Claussnitzer et al.,, 2015 ) on 768 traits, including body mass index (BMI). We find that p-values currently reported in the literature may be inflated thereby leading to a higher false discovery rate. (ii) We simultaneously discover non-linear effect sizes of additional allelic copies on trait or disease. Specifically, we demonstrate significant genetic non-linearity at the FTO locus for 39 traits in this study. (iii) For the same locus, we find evidence of gene-by-environment interactions (G \times E) using deprivation indices on body weight-related traits. (iv) We further reproduce five pairs of epistatic loci associated with red hair and find 16 further epistatic interactions on hair or skin colour (G \times G). (v) Finally, we illustrate how TarGene can be used to investigate higher-order interactions (G \times G \times G) using three variants linked to the vitamin