Measuring spin precession from massive black hole binaries with gravitational waves: Insights from time-domain signal morphology

Simona J. Miller, Maximiliano Isi, Katerina Chatziioannou, Vijay Varma, Sophie Hourihane · 2025

Read Measuring spin precession from massive black hole binaries with gravitational waves: Insights from time-domain signal morphology by Simona J. Miller, Maximiliano Isi, Katerina Chatziioannou, Vijay Varma, Sophie Hourihane (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14573.txt.

Introduction

Simona Miller and colleagues dissect gravitational wave signals cycle by cycle to learn which part of a heavyweight black hole merger actually reveals the holes' spins. Spin precession, the wobble of the orbital plane, betrays how the binary formed, but heavy systems merge fast, leaving few cycles to read. Writing in twenty twenty-five, the team simulated signals with fixed spins and nearly equal masses, varied loudness, total mass. Viewing geometry, then re-ran inference on truncated versions: everything before a cut, or everything after it. A state-of-the-art waveform model anchored the analysis.

With loud enough post-peak data alone, precession could still be measured from the ringdown after the merger. With enough pre-peak signal, the inspiral alone sufficed for lighter systems. The study tells observers which seconds of a short, precious signal carry the spin evidence, guiding detector and analysis choices for heavy binaries.

Catalog record

CREATORSimona J. Miller, Maximiliano Isi, Katerina Chatziioannou, Vijay Varma, Sophie Hourihane
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE104 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14573

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Measuring spin precession from massive black hole binaries with gravitational waves: Insights from time-domain signal morphology Simona J. Miller, Maximiliano Isi, Katerina Chatziioannou, Vijay Varma, Sophie Hourihane Abstract Robustly measuring binary black hole spins via gravitational waves is key to understanding these systems’ astrophysical origins, but remains challenging—especially for high-mass systems, whose signals are short and dominated by the merger. Nonetheless, events like GW190521 show that strong spin precession can indeed be gleaned from high-mass systems. In this work, we track how spin precession imprints on simulated high-mass binary black hole signals cycle-by-cycle using time-domain inference. We investigate a suite of signals, all with the same spins and (near-unity) mass ratio—yielding identical spin evolution—but different signal-to-noise ratios, total masses, and extrinsic angles, all of which affect the observed waveform morphology. We truncate each signal at various times and infer source parameters using only the data before or after each cutoff. The resultant posterior allows us to identify which time segments of each signal inform its spin precession constraints. We find that at a sufficiently high post-peak signal-to-noise ratio (SNR, ρ ∼ 20 \rho\sim 20 ), spin precession can be constrained by the NRSur7dq4 waveform model when just the post-peak data (i.e., ringdown) are visible. Similarly, at a large enough pre-cutoff SNR ( ρ ∼ 10 \rho\sim 10 ), spin precession can be constrained using only pre-peak data (i.e., inspiral); this occurs for signals with detector-frame total mass ≲ 100 ​ M ⊙ \lesssim 100M_{\odot} at GW190521’s full-signal SNR. Finally, we vary the inclination, polarization, and phase angles, finding that their configuration need not be fine-tuned to measure spin precession, even for very high-mass and short signals with two to three observable cycles. We do not find that the same morphological features consistently drive precession constraints: in some signals, precession inference hinges on the relationship between a loud merger and quiet pre-merger cycle, as was the case for GW190521, but this is not generically true. Our studies enable a morphological understanding of precession that can help bolster confidence in precession inference in the presence of signal or noise systematics. I Introduction Black hole (BH) spin is a key astrophysical observable, promised to illuminate physics on multiple scales, from understanding of stellar interiors [ 59 ] to the formation and evolution of binary black holes (BBHs) throughout cosmic history [ 100 ] . Measurable precession of the BBH orbital plane caused by misalignment between the spin and orbital angular momenta is particularly useful for distinguishing between different BBH evolutionary pathways [ 100 , 102 , 134 , 63 , 56 , 170 , 23 , 82 , 62 , 126 , 168 , 146 , 35 , 9 , 56 , 133 , 171 , 48 , 87 , 130 , 164 , 147 , 148 ] . Gravitational waves (GWs) from BH mergers observed by Advanced LIGO [ 1 ] , Advanced Virgo [ 17 ] , and KAGRA [ 19 ] are one of the few ways to measure the spins of stellar-mass BHs directly. Spin precession is, however, notoriously difficult to measure from GW signals [ 165 , 163 , 144 , 52 ] . Informative spin measurements are rare to begin with: most observations are consistent with negligible spin magnitudes, and contain no information about spin precession [ 8 , 13 , 11 ] . Moreover, among observed BBHs with interesting spin configurations, a few are contaminated by non-Gaussian noise transients (“glitches” [ 44 , 3 , 45 ] ). The anti-aligned spins of GW191109_010717 [ 152 ] and the large spin precession of GW200129_065458 [ 129 ] , for example, are both dependent on the assumed glitch model. Measuring precessing spins is further complicated by waveform systematics: different models for the waveform can yield different in-plane spin measurements for the same signals [ 160 ] . Therefore, obtaining robust spin measurements can be even more challenging than other BBH properties like mass, not only because the imprint is weaker but also because it is more subtle to model. We submit that a detailed understanding of signal morphology (i.e., strain over time) can lead to more robust spin inference and interpretation. Connecting astrophysical parameters with waveform phenomenology—or how these parameters imprint cycle-by-cycle onto observable GW signals—bolsters the measurements’ robustness. For instance, if spin precession consistently imprints a distinct waveform feature, identifying that feature in a new GW event would strengthen confidence in the measurement and clarify potential systematics. Additionally, consider the highly probable situation in which we detect a GW that overlaps with a glitch or its residual [ 44 ] : with a priori knowledge of how and where precession imprints on GWs, we can better identify whether or not that glitch can mimic precession. This knowledge is especially powerful in the case where the imprint of precession is subtle and can be easily mimicked by non-Gaussianities in data. In this way, signal morphology is a tool to help safeguard against spurious spin measurements caused by data quality issues or waveform systematics. A similar idea of dividing data into time or frequency chunks to compare how data and simulations accumulate signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is used in GW searches [ 20 , 155 , 46 ] and glitch mitigation [ 152 ] . Working in the time domain allows us to draw a connection between the waveform morphology and the dynamics of the source, leading to better intuitions. The link between waveform morphology and system parameters is especially challenging for high-mass (“heavy”) BBHs with redshifted (i.e., detector-frame) component masses \gtrsim 50+50\,M_{\odot} . These systems merge at the low-frequency edge of the sensitivity band for current ground-based interferometers [ 32 ] , resulting in a short-duration detectable GW signal dominated by the merger phase of coalescence. In such cases, up to seventeen BBH parameters 1 1 1 Fifteen parameters describe a non-eccentric BBH, and an additional two are necessary if the orbit is eccentric. must be inferred from just a few observed waveform cycles. If a cycle overlaps with a glitch, a large portion of the signal is compromised. Moreover, the observational signature of BBH parameters on the merger phase remains poorly understood. Unlike in the inspiral which is described by, e.g., the post-Newtonian formalism [ 29 , 120 ] , spin is not analytically tractable in the merger [ 84 ] . Precession is particularly difficult to measure, as the precession timescale is comparable to the duration of the signal itself [ 64 ] . A sizable fraction of the most recent catalog of GW transients [ 11 ] is consistent with being high-mass, and therefore plagued by these issues. Although the typical BBH detected with GWs is consistent with having detector-frame masses of less than 40+40\,M_{\odot} , generating an observable inspiral, about one third 2 2 2 Nuance is necessary when interpreting the significance of high-mass BBH merger detections. This back-of-the-envelope estimate uses the standard astrophysical probability significance threshold [ 11 ] and not the more stringent thresholds used when searching for intermediate mass BHs [ 16 ] . of the BBHs in the third GW transient catalog [ 11 ] have a median inferred detector-frame total mass M\gtrsim 100\,M_{\odot} , which corresponds to a merger at

Read the complete text