A Logic of General Attention Using Edge-Conditioned Event Models (Extended Version)

Gaia Belardinelli, Thomas Bolander, Sebastian Watzl · 2025

Read A Logic of General Attention Using Edge-Conditioned Event Models (Extended Version) by Gaia Belardinelli, Thomas Bolander, Sebastian Watzl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14539.txt.

Introduction

Gaia Belardinelli, Thomas Bolander, and Sebastian Watzl build the first general logic of attention. Attention lets a mind pick out what matters, from a claim to another's beliefs. It can also bias us when some sources are always ignored. Older logics could only model attention to bare facts, and they ballooned in size as agents were added. Their 2025 logic lifts both limits.

The team first sharpens a model tool that says the same as the standard one in a fraction of the space. Then they let attention range over any claim, even claims about attention itself. Rules for the attention operator support a full proof system. Worked cases show AI agents spotting human attention bias. The authors treat attention as a basic mode like belief.

Catalog record

CREATORGaia Belardinelli, Thomas Bolander, Sebastian Watzl
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE128 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14539

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Logic of General Attention Using Edge-Conditioned Event Models (Extended Version) Gaia Belardinelli, Thomas Bolander, Sebastian Watzl Abstract In this work, we present the first general logic of attention. Attention is a powerful cognitive ability that allows agents to focus on potentially complex information, such as logically structured propositions, higher-order beliefs, or what other agents pay attention to. This ability is a strength, as it helps to ignore what is irrelevant, but it can also introduce biases when some types of information or agents are systematically ignored. Existing dynamic epistemic logics for attention cannot model such complex attention scenarios, as they only model attention to atomic formulas. Additionally, such logics quickly become cumbersome, as their size grows exponentially in the number of agents and announced literals. Here, we introduce a logic that overcomes both limitations. First, we generalize edge-conditioned event models, which we show to be as expressive as standard event models yet exponentially more succinct (generalizing both standard event models and generalized arrow updates). Second, we extend attention to arbitrary formulas, allowing agents to also attend to other agents’ beliefs or attention. Our work treats attention as a modality, like belief or awareness. We introduce attention principles that impose closure properties on that modality and that can be used in its axiomatization. Throughout, we illustrate our framework with examples of AI agents reasoning about human attentional biases, demonstrating how such agents can discover attentional biases. 1 Introduction Attention is the crucial ability of the mind to select and prioritize specific subsets of available information [ 2017 ] . Research in psychology suggests that agents who do not pay attention to something do not update their beliefs about it [ 1999 ] . Therefore, while the ability to focus attention is a strength, as it helps agents ignore irrelevant information, restricting which information is learned can also introduce biases [ 2024 ] : an agent with limited attention may never learn about certain news, some aspects of a candidate’s application, or what certain individuals (e.g. of a specific gender or nationality) have to say. Researchers have begun to investigate the significance of attention-driven biases in both humans and AI [ 2024 , 2023 ] . AI systems that can robustly reason about attention could potentially detect such attentional biases and correct them. As a step toward that aim, we provide the first logic of general attention, here captured in a dynamic epistemic logic (DEL) framework [ 1998 ] . Attention is treated as a modality that restricts which parts of an event an agent learns. An agent who is not attending to a formula will mistake an event containing that formula for one that does not. Our work builds on earlier proposals that introduce DEL models of attention to capture its effects on agents’ beliefs. However, the first proposal only modeled a notion of all-or-nothing attention [ 2016 ] , and later work extended it to apply to atomic propositions [ 2023 ] . While the latter can treat cases where a member of a hiring committee systematically attends only to, say, the research parts of applicants’ CVs, it cannot represent agents whose attention is biased against specific agents, e.g. paying attention to what candidate a has to say about a research topic, but not candidate b [ 2023 , 2020 ] . Or consider the distinction between an agent who aims to learn by paying attention to the world and an agent who aims to learn by attending to what others pay attention to – the latter arguably being an important component of social learning [ 2010 , 2011 ] . To model such cases, we need a notion of attention that applies to arbitrary formulas. A key obstacle to such a richer notion is that models for attention quickly become highly complex and their size grows at least exponentially large, even for all-or-nothing attention. A fully general theory requires technical innovations that allow to capture attention and its impact on beliefs in a tractable way. To that goal, we adopt an edge-conditioned version of DEL [ 2018 ] and generalize it so that every edge carries both a source and a target condition. Source conditions are used to encode an agent’s current attentional state, while target conditions specify what the agent learns about her own attention. We show that this single modification allows for an exponentially more succinct reformulation of earlier event models for propositional attention [ 2023 ] . We also show that edge-conditioned event models are as expressive as standard event models, establishing exponential succinctness of edge-conditioned event models over standard event models. We further provide an axiomatization of edge-conditioned models and show that they are as expressive as generalized arrow updates [ 2011b ] and as succinct as them. Taken together, these results imply that edge-conditioned models provide a novel event model formalism that generalizes and unifies the two common alternative formalisms in DEL: standard event models and generalized arrow updates. Due to these properties, it seems a good candidate for a new standard formalism in DEL. Thanks to the increased simplicity and clarity of the new formalisation, we can now generalize the framework along another dimension, namely to accommodate attention to arbitrary formulas (not merely atomic ones). In this richer framework attention becomes a modality, in that way resembling belief or awareness (though, unlike the latter, attention is intrinisically dynamic as it affects what agents learn from events, and it is not used to restrict their standing beliefs). We argue that the behaviour of that modality can be governed by a family of attention principles, namely closure conditions that can be used to axiomatize a specific logic of attention. The logic of general attention can model agents who attend to the world, to what other agents believe, or to what other agents attend to. It can thus be used to study social attention and learning and the attentional biases mentioned above in potentially complex multi-agent settings. In summary, the paper makes the following contributions: 1. We present the first general theory of attention , allowing agents to attend to arbitrary formulas. 2. We provide the first event model formalism that generalizes and unifies standard event models and generalized arrow updates . We show that this new formalism is always at least as succinct as both, and can be exponentially more succinct. 3. We provide the first principles for general attention that can be used to axiomatize specific attention notions. The main text only contains proof sketches. Full proofs can be found in the appendix. 2 DEL and Propositional Attention We are going to work with multiple distinct languages, in all of which we use Ag to denote a finite set of agents and P to denote a finite set of propositional atoms . 1 1 1 So all our languages take the sets Ag and P as parameters, but this dependency is kept implicit throughout the paper. The symbol \mathcal{L} is used to denote any language extending the language of epistemic logic \mathcal{L}_{\text{EL}} given by the grammar: \varphi::=\top\mid p\mid\neg\varphi\mid\varphi\wedge\varphi\mid B_{a}\varphi, with p\in P , a\in Ag , and B_{a}\varphi reads “agent a believes \varphi ”. We define the other propositional connectives in the standard

Read the complete text