From What to How : A Taxonomy of Formalized Security Properties

Imen Sayar, Nan Messe, Sophie Ebersold, Jean-Michel Bruel · 2025

Read From What to How : A Taxonomy of Formalized Security Properties by Imen Sayar, Nan Messe, Sophie Ebersold, Jean-Michel Bruel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14514.txt.

Introduction

Imen Sayar, Nan Messe, Sophie Ebersold, and Jean-Michel Bruel propose, in 2025, a taxonomy that follows security goals through the whole software building cycle. Goals such as privacy, integrity, and accountability are usually set early and then left vague, while attacks and defenses get refined in detail later. That mismatch weakens self-adaptive systems that must react to threats.

Their taxonomy refines each security property step by step, in line with the other artifacts. A method for building the taxonomy is presented, and its correctness is checked using a formal language for system models. The goal is security goals that stay precise from first requirements to running code.

Catalog record

CREATORImen Sayar, Nan Messe, Sophie Ebersold, Jean-Michel Bruel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14514

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From What to How : A Taxonomy of Formalized Security Properties Imen Sayar, Nan Messe, Sophie Ebersold, Jean-Michel Bruel Abstract Confidentiality, integrity, availability, authenticity, authorization, and accountability are known as security properties that secure systems should preserve. They are usually considered as security final goals that are achieved by system development activities, either in a direct or an indirect manner. However, these security properties are mainly elicited in the high-level requirement phase during the System Development Life Cycle (SDLC) and are not refined throughout the latter phases as other artifacts such as attacks, defenses, and system assets. To align security properties refinement with attacks, defenses, and system assets refinements, we propose an SDLC taxonomy of security properties that may be used in a self-adaptive context and present the methodology for defining it. To verify and check the correctness of the resulting taxonomy, we use the Event-B formal language. I Introduction A system’s security properties, e.g., confidentiality, integrity, and availability (the CIA triad), are to be ensured during different stages of a System Development Life Cycle (SDLC) to help system engineers build trustworthy systems. During the requirement phase, security properties are included in various activities, e.g., attack trees [ 36 ] , abuse cases, and misuse cases [ 17 ] , to help requirement analysts elicit security requirements. Then, during the design phase, different architectural measures, e.g., security patterns [ 30 ] , assurance cases [ 16 ] , and security controls can be applied by architects as architecture decisions to satisfy security requirements, which in turn ensure security properties. Those architecture decisions are later implemented by developers during the implementation phase, where codes are also tested, using for example code review [ 8 ] , penetration testing [ 5 ] and SAST [ 39 ] to identify any security requirement’s non-satisfaction or security property violation. Finally, systems in operation are monitored to detect security anomalies that go against security properties and are maintained or recovered in case of security breaches. As we can see, security properties are addressed in various security activities throughout the SDLC, either directly or indirectly. However, the gains made by their inclusion in different stages are not equivalent. Dealing with security properties during the design phase and addressing them during the system operation entail different costs. Indeed, the earlier the security properties are covered and verified in system development, the earlier the vulnerabilities are detected. This results in less cost to be spent on incident responses and less the reputation of the company will be damaged. Therefore, security should not be an afterthought but be built into the system from the ground up. Identifying and verifying security properties since the early phases of SDLC, especially in the requirement and design phases, are thus critical for building a successful and secure system product. In the information security practice and academic literature, security properties are known as CIA and AAA , which respectively refer to Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability and Authentication, Authorization, Accountability [ 18 , 24 , 26 ] . They serve as security final goals to be addressed in development activities [ 23 , 34 ] . As illustrated in the white part of Figure 1 , attacks, exploiting system assets and violating security properties, as well as defenses, protecting system assets and preserving security properties, can each be refined into attack tactics and defense strategies respectively, which are both addressed during the requirement and high-level design phases. These artifacts are then, in their turn, refined into attack techniques and mitigation controls correspondingly, which are dealt with during the lower-level design and implementation phases. This refinement is carried out throughout the SDLC. However, this is not the case for security properties due to their high-level nature and lack of support. Refining, tracing, and verifying the security properties during the different stages of the SDLC are therefore complicated tasks, which require dedicated support and techniques. Fig. 1: Security artifacts refinement model For instance, the security requirement “ The messages in transit between the client and the server should not be modified by a third party .” is elicited by targeting the integrity objective. Refining, representing, and satisfying this security requirement during the architecture design would result in several architecture decisions, such as protecting interfaces, supporting user-input validations, identifying race conditions, etc. In practice, determining those architecture decisions requires domain expertise, security expertise, and tool support, to capture all intended security properties that were considered during the requirement phase [ 33 , 40 ] . For example, in the widely-used threat modeling activity, domain experts and security experts need to work together in a brainstorming session to identify vulnerabilities and threats that may violate the security requirements, and provide mitigation controls which will be rendered as architecture decisions [ 25 ] . Consequently, the resulting architectural decisions are highly dependent on human expertise and the chosen tools. Moreover, in each phase of the SDLC, and particularly in the requirements definition phase, checking whether lower-level (e.g., component-level) requirements demonstrate the satisfaction of higher-level (e.g., system-level) requirements is still an area of ongoing research [ 35 ] . Currently, even in safety-critical systems with well-understood domains, it is hard to specify requirements correctly [ 35 ] . To provide an SDLC support for aligning security properties refinement with attack and defense refinement, as shown in the yellow part of Figure 1 , we propose a taxonomy of security properties in this paper. This taxonomy is described together with the methodology used to define it. The taxonomy presented in this paper addresses “what” security properties a system or a system element should preserve rather than “how” to implement them. The proposed taxonomy can yet be bridged with lower-level implementation, which is not the focus of this paper. To verify the proposed taxonomy, we use Event-B, a formal language, to early check its correctness. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first SDLC taxonomy of formalized security properties provided in the literature. This paper is organized as follows: Section II highlights the long-term objective of proposing the security properties taxonomy. Then, we elaborate in Section III the tasks used for building and verifying this taxonomy with a BPMN-based process. In Section IV , the taxonomy of security properties is defined. To check its correctness, by formally verifying and validating the taxonomy, we use Event-B. This is presented in Section V . Related works are discussed in Section VI . We then discuss the advantages of the taxonomy and identify its current limitation in Section VII . Finally, we conclude the paper and discuss future works in Section VIII . II Taxonomy’s Long-Term Objective To illustrate the long-term objective of our security properties taxonomy, we use an analogy with the algorithm design paradigm. In computer science, a developer designs an algorithm and implements it into a program to solve a problem. When the problem becomes relatively complicated, the developer follows the “divide and conquer” strategy [ 7 ] to recursively break down the problem into two or more sub-problems of the same or related type, until these problems become simple enough to be solved directly. With the aim of building secure systems, we pursue a similar philosophy to define a taxonomy of

Read the complete text