Freezing line of polydisperse hard spheres via direct-coexistence simulations
Antoine Castagnède, Laura Filion, Frank Smallenburg · 2025
Read Freezing line of polydisperse hard spheres via direct-coexistence simulations by Antoine Castagnède, Laura Filion, Frank Smallenburg (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-14360.txt.
Introduction
Antoine Castagnède, Laura Filion, and Frank Smallenburg map freezing lines for mixed-size hard spheres in 2025. Real colloid particles always vary in size, and that spread can block crystal growth. Even for plain hard spheres, the freezing map under size spread stayed murky.
Their method runs direct-coexistence simulations that let fluid and crystal share one box under a semi-grand setup. As spread rises, the crystal picks larger particles and ends up tidier than the fluid. At high spread, the crystal packs fewer particles per volume than the fluid, a surprise flip. Interface traits like surface stress also come from the same runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Antoine Castagnède, Laura Filion, Frank Smallenburg |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-14360
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Freezing line of polydisperse hard spheres via direct-coexistence simulations Antoine Castagnède, Laura Filion, Frank Smallenburg Abstract In experimental systems, colloidal particles are virtually always at least somewhat polydisperse, which can have profound effects on their ability to crystallize. Unfortunately, accurately predicting the effects of polydispersity on phase behavior using computer simulations remains a challenging task. As a result, our understanding of the equilibrium phase behavior of even the simplest colloidal model system, hard spheres, remains limited. Here, we present a new approach to map out the freezing line of polydisperse systems that draws on direct-coexistence simulations in the semi-grand canonical ensemble. We use this new method to map out the conditions where a hard-sphere fluid with a Gaussian size distribution becomes metastable with respect to partial crystallization into a face-centered-cubic crystal. Consistent with past predictions, we find that as the polydispersity of the fluid increases, the coexisting crystal becomes increasingly size-selective, exhibiting a lower polydispersity and larger mean particle size than the fluid phase. Interestingly, for sufficiently high polydispersity, this leads to a crystal phase with a lower number density than that of the coexisting fluid. Finally, we exploit our direct-coexistence simulations to examine the characteristics of the fluid-crystal interface, including the surface stress and interfacial absorption. I Introduction When studying colloidal self-assembly, we often assume that we are working with systems that are either monodisperse, or consist of a limited number of distinct species, each with a well-defined size, shape, and other characteristics. In practice, however, colloidal particles inevitably exhibit a finite degree of polydispersity: variations of the particle characteristics around their mean value. This is particularly crucial in crystallization studies, where polydispersity can hinder the formation of well-ordered structures, or even induce formation of complex crystal phases Cabane et al. 2016 ; Bommineni et al. 2019 ; Coslovich, Ozawa, and Berthier 2018 ; Lindquist, Jadrich, and Truskett 2018 . Unfortunately, we still have a limited understanding of the effect of polydispersity on the phase behavior of even the simplest of colloidal model systems: hard spheres. Colloidal hard spheres are arguably one of the most fundamental model systems in soft-matter physics, as their simplicity makes them extremely amenable for study in theory, simulations, and experiments Royall et al. 2024 . As a result, significant efforts have been made to explore the effects of size polydispersity on e.g. the dynamics Sear 2000 ; Orsi et al. 2012 ; Roberts et al. 2020 , phase behavior Coslovich, Ozawa, and Berthier 2018 ; Fasolo and Sollich 2003 ; Fasolo and Sollich 2004 ; Bolhuis and Kofke 1996a ; Kofke and Bolhuis 1999 ; Wilding and Sollich 2010 ; Bolhuis and Kofke 1996b ; Sollich and Wilding 2010 and crystal nucleation Auer and Frenkel 2004 ; Schöpe, Bryant, and Van Megen 2006 ; Zaccarelli et al. 2009 ; Bommineni, Klement, and Engel 2020 ; Lindquist, Jadrich, and Truskett 2018 ; Coslovich, Ozawa, and Berthier 2018 ; Martin, Bryant, and Van Megen 2003 ; LaCour, Moore, and Glotzer 2022 of hard spheres. Despite these efforts, our knowledge of the equilibrium crystallization behavior is still incomplete. Specifically, simulation studies that focus on drawing equilibrium phase boundaries for polydisperse hard-sphere mixtures Bolhuis and Kofke 1996a ; Bolhuis and Kofke 1996b ; Kofke and Bolhuis 1999 ; Wilding and Sollich 2010 ; Fasolo and Sollich 2003 ; Fasolo and Sollich 2004 ; Sollich and Wilding 2010 typically consider only crystallization into face-centered cubic (FCC) crystals – the crystal phase that is known to be stable for monodisperse hard spheres. However, a number of recent simulation studies have revealed that at relatively high polydispersities ( \gtrsim 10\% ) more complex crystal structures can spontaneously form, including Laves phases Lindquist, Jadrich, and Truskett 2018 ; Coslovich, Ozawa, and Berthier 2018 ; Bommineni et al. 2019 , whose stability has not yet been explored in detail. The reason for our lack of clear results for this fundamental model system is the fact that determining phase boundaries for polydisperse systems is notoriously difficult Sollich and Wilding 2010 . In polydisperse systems coexisting phases can have significantly different distributions of the relevant particle properties, a phenomenon known as fractionation. As a result, determining phase boundaries requires considering a vast space of possible mixtures of particles with different size distributions, significantly complicating any computational methodology. Past studies have addressed this problem in a variety of ways, often making use of semi-grand canonical ensemble simulations, where the particles can fluctuate in size but the total number of particles stays fixed Kofke and Glandt 1987 ; Bolhuis and Kofke 1996a ; Bolhuis and Kofke 1996b ; Wilding and Sollich 2010 . Using this ensemble, methodologies such as Gibbs-Duhem integration Bolhuis and Kofke 1996a ; Kofke and Bolhuis 1999 ; Bolhuis and Kofke 1996b or phase-switch Monte Carlo Wilding and Bruce 2000 ; Wilding 2009 ; Wilding and Sollich 2010 provide a route towards locating coexisting state points. Alternatively, theoretical methods can be used to estimate phase boundaries based on free-energy calculations that build on approximate equations of state for the fluid phase and cell theory for the crystal phase Fasolo and Sollich 2003 ; Fasolo and Sollich 2004 . These methods have given us a solid picture of the phase behavior of hard sphere in the low-polydispersity regime, but often struggle at higher polydispersities. Here, we propose a new approach for predicting fluid-solid phase coexistences based on direct-coexistence simulations in the semi-grand canonical ensemble. In particular, we build on our recent work on direct-coexistence simulations for monodisperse systems Smallenburg et al. 2024 , and combine it with efficient event-driven simulations in which particles can fluctuate in size based on an externally imposed relative chemical potential. Using this approach, we map out the fluid-FCC freezing line as a function of polydispersity, and examine the behavior of the particle size distribution across the interface. Our methodology can be readily extended to other model systems and more complex crystal phases, opening the door to a more complete exploration of polydisperse phase behavior in the future. II Methods The main aim of this work is to determine the thermodynamic conditions for the fluid-solid phase coexistence of a polydisperse hard-sphere system, where the particle size distribution in the fluid phase is characterized by a Gaussian distribution \mathcal{P}(\sigma)=\frac{1}{p\bar{\sigma}\sqrt{2\pi}}\exp\left(-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\sigma-\bar{\sigma}}{p\bar{\sigma}}\right)^{2}\right). (1) Here, p is the polydispersity of the parent fluid phase, defined as the ratio of the standard deviation of the particle diameter \sigma to its mean value \bar{\sigma} . Note that fixing the size distribution of the fluid phase does not fix the overall size distribution in the coexisting system. Since the crystal phase is generally expected to have a different size distribution (and polydispersity) from the fluid, the overall size distribution of any coexisting state also depends on the fraction of volume taken up by each phase. In this work, we specifically focus on the identification of the freezing line of a fluid with fixed size distribution, also known as the fluid cloud curve Fasolo and Sollich 2003 . The corresponding set of coexisting crystal phases is known as the shadow curve . When two polydisperse phases coexist, thermodynamic equilibrium requires that their temperature T , pressure P , and absolute chemical potential \mu(\sigma) are equal in the two phases. The