Capture and Escape of Planetary Mean-motion Resonances in Turbulent Discs

Yi-Xian Chen (陈逸贤), Yinhao Wu (吴寅昊), Ya-Ping Li (李亚平), Douglas N. C. Lin (林潮) , Richard Alexander , Sergei Nayakshin , Fei Dai (戴飞) · 2025

Read Capture and Escape of Planetary Mean-motion Resonances in Turbulent Discs by Yi-Xian Chen (陈逸贤), Yinhao Wu (吴寅昊), Ya-Ping Li (李亚平), Douglas N. C. Lin (林潮) , Richard Alexander , Sergei Nayakshin , Fei Dai (戴飞) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13952.txt.

Introduction

Yi-Xian Chen and six co-authors simulate young planet pairs drifting together in their birth disc, and find that turbulence can break the rhythmic lockstep migration should create, in this 2025 paper. When two planets migrate at different speeds, the faster catches up and their orbital periods can lock into a simple ratio, a mean-motion resonance, like two clocks ticking three against two.

Disk observations of real young systems hint that such locks were once commoner than they are in older systems. The simulations show calm discs capture pairs into the 3:2 resonance robustly, whatever the viscosity. Realistic turbulence, though, keeps the planets' orbits more elongated and pumps the resonance's swinging until the pair slips free and settles closer in. Tighter resonances, 4:3 and 5:4, resist better. Messy discs, in other words, may explain why so many grown-up planet pairs sit just wide of resonance.

Catalog record

CREATORYi-Xian Chen (陈逸贤), Yinhao Wu (吴寅昊), Ya-Ping Li (李亚平), Douglas N. C. Lin (林潮) , Richard Alexander , Sergei Nayakshin , Fei Dai (戴飞)
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13952

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Capture and Escape of Planetary Mean-motion Resonances in Turbulent Discs Yi-Xian Chen (陈逸贤), Yinhao Wu (吴寅昊), Ya-Ping Li (李亚平), Douglas N. C. Lin (林潮) , Richard Alexander , Sergei Nayakshin , Fei Dai (戴飞) Abstract Mean-motion resonances (MMRs) form through convergent disc migration of planet pairs, which may be disrupted by dynamical instabilities after protoplanetary disc (PPD) dispersal. This scenario is supported by recent analysis of TESS data showing that neighboring planet pairs in younger planetary systems are closer to resonance. To study stability of MMRs during migration, we perform hydrodynamical simulations of migrating planet pairs in PPDs, comparing the effect of laminar viscosity and realistic turbulence. We find stable 3:2 resonance capture for terrestrial planet pairs migrating in a moderately massive PPD, insensitive to a range of laminar viscosity ( α = 10 − 3 − 10 − 1 \alpha=10^{-3}-10^{-1} ). However, realistic turbulence enhances overstability by sustaining higher equilibrium eccentricities and a positive growth rate in libration amplitude, ultimately leading to resonance escape. The equilibrium eccentricity growth rates decrease as planets migrate into tighter and more stable 4:3 and 5:4 MMRs. Our results suggest that active disc turbulence broadens the parameter space for overstability, causing planet pairs to end up in closer-in orbital separations. Libration within MMR typically lead to deviation from exact period ratio | Δ | ∼ 0.5 % |\Delta|\sim 0.5\% , which alone is insufficient to produce the typical dispersion of | Δ | ∼ 1 − 3 % |\Delta|\sim 1-3\% in TESS data, suggesting that post-migration dynamical processes are needed to further amplify the offset. 2026 Capture and Escape of Planetary Mean-motion Resonances in Turbulent Discs – References 1 Introduction Orbital migration plays a crucial role in planet formation, ultimately shaping the architecture of planetary systems. Disc-driven migration occurs in the early stages of protoplanetary disc (PPD) evolution, when planets tidally interact with their natal discs. Type I migration primarily affects low-mass planets ( Goldreich & Tremaine, 1980 ; Ward, 1997 ; Tanaka et al., 2002 ) , typically up to a few Earth masses around Sun-like stars, before they reach the thermal mass to open up a gap in the disc ( Lin & Papaloizou, 1986 ) . This process influences the formation of super-Earths and proto-gas-giant cores ( Ida & Lin, 2008 ; Benz et al., 2014 ; Liu et al., 2015 ) . Migration torques, set by the disc structure ( Paardekooper et al., 2010 ; Kley & Nelson, 2012 ; Paardekooper et al., 2023 ) , usually leads to inward motion on a timescale shorter than the typical lifetime of PPDs. Recent studies have also found that additional physical processes, such as disc winds ( McNally et al., 2017 ; McNally et al., 2018 ; Wu & Chen, 2025 ) , dust feedback ( Guilera et al., 2023 ; Hou & Yu, 2024 ; Hou & Yu, 2025 ) , and background drift ( Wu et al., 2024b ) , may also have the potential to modify the torques exerted on low-mass planets. Mean-motion Resonances (MMRs) or resonant chains naturally arise from convergent migration of planet pairs ( Lee & Peale, 2002 ) particularly when migration is relatively slow, though the exact conditions of resonant capture remain an active area of research ( Goldreich & Schlichting, 2014 ; Huang & Ormel, 2023 ; Batygin & Petit, 2023 ; Wong & Lee, 2024 ; Lin et al., 2025 ; Keller et al., 2025 ) . After PPD dispersal, these chains are expected to gradually break due to dynamical instabilities ( Deck et al., 2013 ; Izidoro et al., 2017 ; Lammers et al., 2024 ) , leading to late-stage compact systems that are typically not in resonance. The convergent migration scenario is supported by analysis of TESS data in Dai et al. (2024) , who show that across an age spectrum, earlier planetary systems are more likely to be near-resonant. Notably, these studies also find that observed period ratios often deviate from perfect commensurability by a fraction of \Delta\sim from -1\% to 3\% , a feature also present in the Kepler catalogue ( Fabrycky et al., 2014 ) . This is commonly attributed to tidal dissipation after disc dispersal ( Papaloizou & Terquem, 2010 ; Lithwick & Wu, 2012 ; Lee et al., 2013 ) , though it has recently been suggested that the offset from the perfect period commensurability with a few percent could be attributed to the interference density wave when the planet pair is close to MMR ( Yang & Li, 2024 ) . However, the persistence of this \Delta feature even in very young planetary systems, as emphasized by Dai et al. (2024) , suggests that at least some fraction of this deviation may originate from migration itself. This is because producing such \Delta by dissipation alone would require an unrealistically low total quality factor Q (a measurement of material dissipation) for young planets ( Xu & Dai, 2025 ) . This leads us to explore the possibility that planets may not be trapped in exact MMRs during convergent migration in the first place. The theory of resonant overstability, developed in the study of Saturnian satellites ( Meyer & Wisdom, 2008 ) , has been invoked by Goldreich & Schlichting (2014) as a potential explanation of non-negligible \Delta during migration. Namely, when planet pairs migrate into MMRs, small perturbation in their eccentricities and period ratio evolves with time as \propto\exp(s+i\omega)t . Both the libration frequency \omega and the growth rate s are explicit functions of the equilibrium eccentricity e_{\rm eq} , which itself depends on the planet masses M_{1},M_{2} and disc aspect ratio h . Analytical theory predicts that these oscillations are generally damped out ( s<0 ) for planet-to-star mass ratio q=M/M_{\star}\gtrsim h^{3} , while s>0 for lower mass q\lesssim h^{3} , the latter leads to either (i) saturation towards an equilibrium libration amplitude, or (ii) escape out of resonance within an eccentricity damping timescale, and subsequent migration towards the next (closer-in) resonance. Disc dispersal during these librations will imprint such amplitudes into the current \Delta distribution, even before the occurence of post-disc dynamical instabilities. This dichotomy is confirmed by recent hydrodynamic simulations of planet pairs migrating in and out of 2:1 resonances ( Hands & Alexander, 2018 ; Ataiee & Kley, 2021 ; Afkanpour et al., 2024 ) , although it’s worth noting that deviations from analytical theory can arise in low-viscosity cases due to partial gap-opening effects. Nevertheless, as in classic simulation of planet migration in PPDs, turbulence is modeled as a laminar viscosity term that’s expected to solely enhance dissipation, damp waves and interference, and prevent gap-opening ( Masset, 2000 ; Paardekooper et al., 2010 ; Kanagawa et al., 2015 , e.g.) . Realistic turbulence from magneto-rotational instability (MRI) ( Beckwith et al., 2011 ; Simon et al., 2012 ; Rea et al., 2024 ) and/or gravitational instability (GI) ( Rice et al., 2003 ; Deng et al., 2017 ) present in PPDs, on the other hand, introduce trans-sonic scale turbulent eddies. These eddies could generate stochastic torques ( Nelson, 2005 ; Wu et al., 2024a ; Kubli et al., 2025 ) and excite oscillation from exact resonances, potentially influencing the equilibrium eccentricity

Read the complete text