Dark States of Light and the Hidden Energy in Thermal Radiation Detection
Celso Jorge Villas-Boas, Ciro Micheletti Diniz · 2025
Read Dark States of Light and the Hidden Energy in Thermal Radiation Detection by Celso Jorge Villas-Boas, Ciro Micheletti Diniz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13767.txt.
Introduction
Celso Jorge Villas-Boas and Ciro Micheletti Diniz published a 2025 physics paper arguing that most of the energy in thermal radiation hides where detectors cannot see it. Heat glow, like light from a warm object, is usually treated as a crowd of independent waves. The authors show the crowd organizes into collective modes. Most of those modes are dark: entangled states of light that do not couple to matter.
In a system of many field modes, only one share in M of the energy can interact with matter at all. The rest sits locked in the dark modes. A common way of estimating energy, measuring brightness, can therefore mislead badly. The team tests the idea in a model cavity holding a single lossy atom, where breaking symmetry lets some hidden energy leak into view. The claim reframes what a detector reading means: silence may signal hidden energy, not absence.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Celso Jorge Villas-Boas, Ciro Micheletti Diniz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13767
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dark States of Light and the Hidden Energy in Thermal Radiation Detection Celso Jorge Villas-Boas, Ciro Micheletti Diniz Abstract We develop a quantum-optical framework demonstrating that thermal radiation can confine a significant portion of its energy in dark collective modes – highly entangled photon states that, despite their photonic nature, remain decoupled from matter through standard electromagnetic interactions. In a system comprising M M thermal field modes, we show that only a fraction 1 / M 1/M of the total energy is accessible to matter, while the remaining ( M − 1 ) / M (M-1)/M is stored in dark states, rendering it undetectable by conventional electromagnetic means. We also demonstrate that intensity measurements, commonly used to estimate field energy, can be misleading due to collective effects that suppress or enhance light-matter coupling. To explore further this phenomenon, we analyze a cavity QED model enclosing a single dissipative atom and show that symmetry breaking in the atom-field interaction enables access to the hidden energy stored in dark modes. While inconclusive, these findings suggest that dark states of light may underlie certain unexplained energy phenomena, pointing to a possible microscopic mechanism based on the collective structure of thermal radiation. I Introduction Recently, the concept of collective dark states of light has been introduced, that is, states containing photons and energy yet not interacting with matter via electromagnetic coupling [ 1 ] . This framework has offered new insights into the fundamental nature of light and interference phenomena, making it plausible, for instance, that photons may exist within the dark regions of double-slit experiments [ 1 ] . When extended to superpositions involving M modes, any pulse shape can be explained by bright and dark states of light. For instance, a mode-locked pulsed laser can be interpreted as a continuous photon flux partitioned into bright (pulse) and dark (inter-pulse) states [ 2 ] , operating in a regime dominated by dark states, i.e., for every single bright state, there are M-1 corresponding dark states. These dark states, involving two or more field modes, can host an arbitrarily large number of photons and, consequently, store significant amounts of energy. However, previous investigations focused either on single-photon states or coherent sources, where quantum effects are prominent. In contrast, most of the light in our daily environment appears as thermal radiation, prompting a natural question: Could this type of radiation also contain light in dark states? This hypothesis is particularly challenging, as thermal radiation is inherently incoherent, a feature that seemingly precludes the presence of dark states, which are highly non-classical and exhibit strong quantum entanglement [ 1 , 3 , 4 ] . In this manuscript, we demonstrate that thermal radiation contains projections onto collective dark modes – or, equivalently, dark states – and that the number of photons in such states increases with the number of field modes, as previously shown for coherent fields [ 2 ] . We formally prove this through two complementary approaches and reveal that a substantial portion of thermal energy resides in states that do not couple to matter. Specifically, for M superposed modes at a given position, only a fraction 1/M of the initial thermal energy can be locally exchanged with matter, while the remaining portion, (M-1)/M , becomes inaccessible to it via electromagnetic interactions. We further show that standard intensity measurements can significantly misrepresent the actual energy content of multimode fields due to collective effects that enhance or suppress light-matter coupling. In fact, classical and quantum textbooks commonly consider field intensity as energy over units of area and time [ 5 , 6 ] , which is true for single-mode cases. However, for two or more modes, the intensity needs to be properly treated as the first-order correlation function [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , which depends not only on the energy content but also on the coupling between the field and the detector, highlighting the importance of the careful treatment of the interaction process in order to obtain accurate understandings of the intensity measurements. Beyond the theoretical contributions, we show that all results can be experimentally tested using a simple and well-established setup in cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED) involving a single two-level atom trapped in a crossed-cavity system [ 10 ] . This reinforces the significance of our findings and highlights their practical feasibility and experimental verifiability. Finally, we analyze the possibility that undetectable energy may exist in free space, pointing toward a potential explanation for certain forms of unknown energy. II Model To establish this quantum-optical framework, we begin by introducing the quantum model that fundamentally governs the exchange of energy between radiation and matter, considering M thermal sources, as schematically illustrated in Fig. 1 (a). For electronic excitations, this interaction is described by the Jaynes–Cummings model [ 11 ] , which can be derived from first principles, such as the minimal coupling theory, and by applying the rotating wave approximation (RWA) [ 12 , 13 ] . For vibrational excitations, an analogous formalism applies, in which the interaction is mediated by the coupling between radiation and optical phonon modes in a given position in the material [ 14 ] . Thus, we consider the radiation–matter interaction described by the general Hamiltonian: \hat{H}_{\text{int}}\propto\left(\hat{S}_{+}\hat{E}^{(+)}+\hat{S}_{-}\hat{E}^{(-)}\right), (1) where \hat{S}_{+} ( \hat{S}_{-}=\hat{S}_{+}^{\dagger} ) represents the excitation (de-excitation) of matter via the absorption (emission) of energy from (to) the radiation field. For electronic transitions, \hat{S}_{-}=\hat{\sigma}_{-} is the lowering operator of a two-level system (related to the Pauli matrices), while for couplings involving optical phonons in a lattice, \hat{S}_{-}=\hat{b} denotes the bosonic annihilation operator associated with the respective collective vibrational mode of the matter. Figure 1: (a) Schematic representation of M thermal sources emitting in all directions. Their thermal photon beams may overlap at a given point in space, where they can interact with matter, here represented by a single dissipative atom (decay rate \gamma ). Panels (b) and (c) illustrate the possible collective states for two- and three-field modes. For each total excitation number N , there exists a unique bright mode state (shown in red), denoted by \lvert\Psi^{N}_{N,0,\ldots,0}\rangle . In contrast, the number of dark mode states (shown in blue), denoted by \lvert\Psi^{N}_{0,n_{1},\ldots,n_{M-1}}\rangle , increases with both the number of modes M and the excitation number N , where n_{\mu} is the number of photons in the {\mu} -th dark mode. Finally, the states \lvert\Psi^{N}_{n_{0},n_{1},\ldots,n_{M-1}}\rangle , with n_{0}\neq 0,N and \sum_{{\mu}=0}^{M-1}n_{\mu}=N , represent intermediate configurations. The operator \hat{E}^{(+)} (with \hat{E}^{(-)}=\hat{E}^{(+)\dagger} ) is the positive-frequency component of the electric field in a given position \vec{r} and time t , which, according to Glauber’s formalism [ 8 , 9 , 15 ] and assuming linear polarization for simplicity, can be expressed as a sum over discrete field modes: \hat{E}^{(+)}=\sum_{\vec{k}}g_{\vec{k}}(\vec{r},t)\hat{a}_{\vec{k}}, (2) where \hat{a}_{\vec{k}} is the annihilation operator for the mode of frequency \omega_{k} and wave vector \vec{k} , and the summation runs over M independent modes. The functions g_{\vec{k}}(\vec{r},t) depend on the system under study, but in general, they are proportional to e^{-i(\vec{k}\cdot\vec{r}\pm\omega_{k}t)} . Thus, they can induce distinct couplings and phases of the form e^{i\theta_{\vec{k}}(\vec{r},t)} , which may vary from point to point in spacetime. This is important because, at every position \vec{r} and time t , there