The Plunging Region of a Thin Accretion Disc around a Schwarzschild Black Hole
Jake Rule, Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, James Stone, Lizhong Zhang (张力中) · 2025
Read The Plunging Region of a Thin Accretion Disc around a Schwarzschild Black Hole by Jake Rule, Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, James Stone, Lizhong Zhang (张力中) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13701.txt.
Introduction
Jake Rule, Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, James Stone, and Lizhong Zhang tested in 2025 a model of the region where gas plunges into a black hole. Below the innermost stable orbit, gas was long assumed to fall freely with no stress, so its heat and light were set to zero in many models. A recent analytic model challenges that picture.
They compared the model with a three-dimensional simulation of a thin disc around a non-spinning black hole. With a heating term added, plausibly from magnetic effects at grid scale, the match was excellent. The gas loses a small share of its spin in the plunge, enough to keep it glowing near the edge. The results matter for measuring black hole spin from light.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jake Rule, Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, James Stone, Lizhong Zhang (张力中) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13701
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Plunging Region of a Thin Accretion Disc around a Schwarzschild Black Hole Jake Rule, Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, James Stone, Lizhong Zhang (张力中) Abstract A set of analytic solutions for the plunging region thermodynamics have been developed recently under the assumption that the fluid undergoes a gravity-dominated geodesic plunge into the black hole. We test this model against a dedicated 3D global GRMHD simulation of a thin accretion disc around a Schwarzschild black hole using the code AthenaK . Provided that we account for non-adiabatic heating in the energetics, plausibly from grid-scale magnetic dissipation, we find an excellent agreement between the analytic model and the simulated quantities. These results are particularly important for existing and future electromagnetic black hole spin measurements, many of which do not to include the plunging fluid in their emission modelling. This exclusion typically stems from the assumption of a zero-stress boundary condition at the ISCO, forcing all thermodynamic quantities to vanish. Instead, we find a non-zero δ 𝒥 ≈ 5.3 % \delta_{\mathcal{J}}\approx 5.3\% drop in the angular momentum over the plunging region, which is consistent with both prior simulations and observations. We demonstrate that this stress is small enough for the dynamics of the fluid in the plunging region to be well-described by geodesic trajectories, yet large enough to cause measurable dissipation near to the ISCO - keeping thermodynamic quantities from vanishing. In the plunging region, constant α \alpha -disc models are a physically inappropriate framework. 2026 The Plunging Region of a Thin Accretion Disc around a Schwarzschild Black Hole – 4 1 Introduction From the supermassive black holes at the center of Active Galactic Nuclei to the stellar mass black holes found in X-ray binary systems, disc accretion of matter onto black holes is a prominent source of power in the Universe. Moreover, the emission of radiation close to a black hole ‘shines a light’ on this strong gravity regime and is therefore an important tool for understanding General Relativity (GR), complementing the recent advent of gravitational wave detection. A feature of GR is the existence of a plunging region between the Innermost Stable Circular Orbit (ISCO) and the event horizon of a black hole. In this region, no stable circular orbits exist, yet it is still a source of light and other material. The position of the ISCO and the size of the plunging region is strongly dependent on the black hole spin, denoted by the parameter a=cJ/GM , where J is the angular momentum of the black hole and M is its mass. Maximally prograde black holes ( a/M=1 ), have no plunging region at all ( r_{\text{ISCO}}=r_{\text{horizon}}=GM/c^{2} ), whilst maximally retrograde black holes ( a/M=-1 ) have the largest plunging region ( r_{\text{ISCO}}=9\,r_{\text{horizon}}=9\,GM/c^{2} ), a dependence which has been used as the basis for measuring the black hole spin. Unlike the mass, the spin of a black hole has no Newtonian counterpart and is most readily measured by probing the strong gravity regime. A common technique for measuring the spin of a black hole is based upon measuring the thermal continuum emission of its accretion disc ( McClintock et al., 2014 ; Reynolds, 2021 ) . Modelling this emission allows one to constrain the location of the ISCO and hence the spin. Using classical disc models, the most energetic emission in the spectrum originates from just outside of the ISCO. Since the liberated binding energy will increase as the ISCO moves closer to the black hole, measuring the energy of this edge allows one to determine the location of the ISCO. Generally, this approach and all other accretion-based spin measurement techniques, such as reflection spectroscopy, are dependent on the disc model used and on the prescription used to model the emission. Both of these are a source of systematic error for existing and future spin measurements ( Reynolds, 2021 ) . The classical analytic model for steady disc accretion is the Shakura & Sunyaev (1973) model, which describes a non-relativistic, radiatively efficient, optically thick and physically thin disc. This was then extended into full GR by Novikov & Thorne (1973) and Page & Thorne (1974) . To close these solutions, an assumption must be made about the boundary condition at the inner edge of the models validity (the point at which circular orbits become unstable). For black holes, the traditional assumption is that there is a zero stress boundary condition at the ISCO. At the time, the role of magnetic fields in accretion discs was uncertain, it was not until the discovery of magnetorotational instability (MRI) ( Balbus & Hawley (1991) ) and its crucial role in the turbulent transport of angular momentum in discs ( Balbus & Hawley (1998) ) that the possibility of a finite stress at the ISCO from the magnetic fields was seriously considered ( Krolik (1999) , Gammie (1999) and Agol & Krolik (2000) ). Since then, simulations with increasing sophistication have confirmed the presence of a finite ISCO stress, including multiple global General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) simulations (e.g. Hawley & Krolik (2001) ; Krolik & Hawley (2002) ; Shafee et al. (2008) , Penna et al. (2010) , Noble et al. (2010) , Zhu et al. (2012) , Schnittman et al. (2016) , and Dhang et al. (2025) , amongst others). One consequence of a zero stress boundary condition is that it forces all thermodynamic quantities to vanish at the ISCO and remain zero throughout the plunging region. Such zero stress models are routinely used for the aforementioned thermal continuum fitting method for measuring black hole spins, despite compelling numerical evidence that there is a finite ISCO stress. As a consequence, they completely ignore the plunging fluid (this is a widespread practice, see e.g., McClintock et al., 2014 , for a review, or e.g., Zhao et al. 2021 for a recent example) . Mummery & Balbus (2023) (hereafter MB23) derived a full set of analytic thermodynamic solutions for the plunging region flow which can, among other things, be used to include the radiation emitted by fluid in the plunging region into the models used for continuum fitting. Crucially, MB23 find that the most energetic radiation can originate from within the plunging region, an effect that is a potential source of systematic error for existing spin measurements using classical disc models. Radiation from the plunging fluid provides a possible explanation for X-ray spectra which did not fit well using the classical zero stress models (e.g., Fabian et al. (2020) ; Mummery et al. (2024b) , Mummery et al. (2024c) ). The calculation discussed here assumes that the plunging flow is well-modelled by a gravity-dominated geodesic plunge for thin and weakly magnetised discs. In practice, even when modelling thin, weakly magnetised discs it is unclear a priori if thermal and magnetic pressure gradients are dynamically important to the plunging flow. Targeted global GRMHD simulations of the main disc and plunging region are required to test the theory. While being the simplest case to model analytically, thin discs are demanding to simulate (e.g. Liska et al. (2022) for a recent discussion). This is because one must adequately resolve the vertical extent of the disc, which is by definition much smaller than the radial extent. Increased spatial resolution