Trustworthy AI and Democracy: A Dual Taxonomy of Democratic Risks and Contributions
Oier Mentxaka, Natalia Díaz-Rodríguez, Mark Coeckelbergh, Marcos López de Prado, Emilia Gómez, David Fernández Llorca, Enrique Herrera-Viedma, Francisco Herrera · 2025
Read Trustworthy AI and Democracy: A Dual Taxonomy of Democratic Risks and Contributions by Oier Mentxaka, Natalia Díaz-Rodríguez, Mark Coeckelbergh, Marcos López de Prado, Emilia Gómez, David Fernández Llorca, Enrique Herrera-Viedma, Francisco Herrera (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13565.txt.
Introduction
Oier Mentxaka and seven co-authors build a two-sided frame for how AI affects democracy, in a 2025 paper. AI can erode self-rule and can also serve it. The frame sorts risks on one side and gains on the other. It rests on five democratic principles and seven trust needs drawn from a European expert group.
Risks span free choice, fairness, public debate, institutions, and trust. Gains span speed, access, safety, informed citizens, openness, wide dialogue, and fact-based policy. A step-by-step method links each case to the trust needs it touches and to fitting guard steps. Two worked cases, on election falsehoods and public service sorting, show the method in use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Oier Mentxaka, Natalia Díaz-Rodríguez, Mark Coeckelbergh, Marcos López de Prado, Emilia Gómez, David Fernández Llorca, Enrique Herrera-Viedma, Francisco Herrera |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13565
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Trustworthy AI and Democracy: A Dual Taxonomy of Democratic Risks and Contributions Oier Mentxaka, Natalia Díaz-Rodríguez, Mark Coeckelbergh, Marcos López de Prado, Emilia Gómez, David Fernández Llorca, Enrique Herrera-Viedma, Francisco Herrera Abstract Artificial Intelligence (AI) poses both significant risks and valuable contributions for democratic governance. This paper introduces a dual taxonomy to analyse AI’s complex relationship with democracy in the context of Trustworthy AI: the AI Risks to Democracy (AIRD) taxonomy, which identifies how AI can undermine core democratic principles such as autonomy, fairness, and trust; and the AI’s Positive Contributions to Democracy (AIPD) taxonomy, which highlights AI’s potential to enhance transparency, participation, efficiency, and evidence-based policymaking. Grounded in the European Union’s approach to ethical and Trustworthy AI governance, and particularly the seven Trustworthy AI requirements proposed by the European Commission’s High-Level Expert Group on AI, each identified risk is aligned with mitigation strategies based on EU regulatory and normative frameworks. Our analysis underscores the transversal importance of transparency and societal well-being across all risk categories and offers a structured lens for aligning AI systems with democratic values. By integrating democratic theory with practical governance tools, this paper offers a normative and actionable framework to guide research, regulation, and institutional design in support of trustworthy, democratic AI. It provides scholars with a conceptual foundation to evaluate the democratic implications of AI, equips policymakers with structured criteria for ethical and democratic oversight, and helps technologists align system design with democratic principles. In doing so, it bridges the gap between ethical aspirations and operational realities, laying the groundwork for more inclusive, accountable, and resilient democratic systems in the algorithmic age. Keywords Trustworthy AI, democratic governance, AI ethics, algorithmic governance, AI risks, AI opportunities, EU AI Act. 1 Introduction The accelerated deployment of artificial intelligence (AI) in multiple sectors has begun to shape not only technological infrastructures, but also the social, economic, and political foundations of democratic societies. As AI systems increasingly mediate communication, decision-making, and policy implementation, they raise significant concerns regarding the protection of democratic values such as freedom, equality, fraternity, the rule of law, and tolerance. Although many studies have explored the ethical implications of AI Floridi and Cowls (2019) ; Fjeld et al. (2020) ; Radanliev (2025a) , fewer have fully examined its democratic implications, both in terms of the risks it poses and the potential it holds to strengthen democratic institutions Coeckelbergh (2025b) ; Saura García (2025) ; Calvo and Saura Garcia (2025) ; Summerfield et al. (2025) . To provide a structured understanding of this complex duality, this paper introduces a twofold framework grounded in normative democratic theory and applied AI ethics. Our analysis builds on the tradition of epistemic democracy, which argues that democratic procedures have value partly because of their capacity to generate better political judgements under appropriate conditions Estlund (2008) ; Goodin and Spiekermann (2018) ; Landemore (2012) . At the same time, we draw on deliberative and participatory theories of democracy, which emphasise public reasoning, inclusive participation and discursive legitimacy Fishkin (1991) ; Habermas (1996) ; Dryzek (2000) , and on agonistic and critical approaches that stress conflict, pluralism and power Mouffe (2000) . Our five democratic principles should therefore be read as a synthesis of these strands rather than as a novel theory of democracy. It situates the analysis within two conceptual foundations: (1) five core principles of democracy, as identified by Coeckelbergh Coeckelbergh (2024b) , freedom, equality, fraternity, rule of law, and tolerance; and (2) the seven requirements for trustworthy AI as proposed by the European Commission’s High-Level Expert Group on AI European Commission High-Level Expert Group on AI (2019) . These frameworks serve as reference points for evaluating both the potential harms and the democratic advantages of AI systems. The motivation for this study stems from the urgent need to develop a shared vocabulary and an actionable framework to assess AI’s democratic implications. As several of the previous mentioned articles suggest, despite increasing attention to AI regulation, the public and scholarly discourse often remains fragmented, with technical or ethical issues frequently discussed in isolation from their democratic implications. We argue that a dedicated examination of AI’s interaction with democratic governance is essential to navigate this evolving landscape. In particular, the absence of structured conceptual taxonomies mapping the risks and benefits of AI to democratic values leaves a critical gap in policymaking, research, and civic understanding. To fill this gap, we propose two original taxonomies. Although presented separately for clarity of exposition, both taxonomies form part of a single underlying taxonomical framework of AI’s positive and negative democratic impacts. • AI’s Positive Impact to Democracy (AIPD): A framework that highlights how AI can support democratic processes through enhanced efficiency, accessibility, security, informed citizenry, transparency, and evidence-based policymaking. • AI’s Risks to Democracy (AIRD): A classification of how AI systems, when misaligned with ethical and democratic principles, can threaten core democratic values. This includes categories such as the subversion of autonomy, unfairness, power asymmetries, the danger of authoritarianism, erosion of trust, and others. The central hypothesis of this paper is that the dual nature of AI, as both a threat and a support for democracy, can be systematically understood, analyzed, and addressed through structured taxonomies aligned with ethical and policy-based AI governance principles. A comprehensive understanding of the democratic implications of AI requires addressing not only its risks but also its potential contributions. Focusing solely on harms risks fostering a reactive, fear-driven discourse, while overlooking opportunities may lead to underutilized tools for democratic strengthening. By developing both a risk taxonomy (AIRD) and a positive impact taxonomy (AIPD), this paper provides a balanced analytical framework that allows nuanced evaluation, targeted policy responses, and responsible innovation. This dual approach ensures that AI governance is neither overly prohibitive nor naively optimistic, but instead grounded in a realistic assessment of how AI can undermine or reinforce democratic values. The methodology used to develop both taxonomies is based on a comprehensive analysis of more than 100 academic publications on artificial intelligence and democracy, published since 2021. Using a thematic classification, the risks and benefits that occur significantly in the research community have been grouped together. Only about half of the analyzed papers are cited, since the others did not directly focus on the democracy–AI nexus that frames the scope of this study. In line with the legal scope of the EU AI Act, our analysis focuses on civilian applications of AI and their implications for democratic institutions and practices. We do not consider defence or military uses of AI, 1 1 1 The EU AI Act excludes AI systems used exclusively for military, defence, or national security purposes from its material scope. Complementary guidance on trustworthy AI in the defence domain is being developed separately, for example in the European Defence Agency White Paper Trustworthiness for AI in Defence European Defence Agency (2025) . which fall under distinct regulatory and governance arrangements and raise partly different normative questions. The risks selected in this section are related, to a greater or lesser extent, to the concerns raised by Coeckelbergh throughout his book Coeckelbergh (2024b) . Therefore, according to the hypothesis, the objectives of this paper are the following. 1. Identify the positive contributions AI can make to democratic