Insufficient evidence for DMS and DMDS in the atmosphere of K2-18 b
R. Luque, C. Piaulet-Ghorayeb , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Radica , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, Q. Xue , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Zhang , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, J. L. Bean, D. Samra, M. E. Steinrueck · 2025
Read Insufficient evidence for DMS and DMDS in the atmosphere of K2-18 b by R. Luque, C. Piaulet-Ghorayeb , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Radica , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, Q. Xue , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Zhang , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, J. L. Bean, D. Samra, M. E. Steinrueck (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13407.txt.
Introduction
Rafael Luque and co-authors retest a bold claim about a far planet in a 2025 paper. The planet, a warm world smaller than Neptune, had been read as a sea world with signs of life-linked gases in its air. Those gas claims rested on split reads from three space scope tools, each read on its own.
The team fit all three data sets at once, under more than one way of cleaning the data. Joined that way, the gas marks fade below firm proof. The paper does not rule out the gases, but it shows the case for them is weak. It urges care with such claims.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | R. Luque, C. Piaulet-Ghorayeb , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Radica , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, Q. Xue , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Zhang , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, J. L. Bean, D. Samra, M. E. Steinrueck |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13407
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Insufficient evidence for DMS and DMDS in the atmosphere of K2-18 b R. Luque, C. Piaulet-Ghorayeb , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Radica , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, Q. Xue , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, M. Zhang , {}^{{\ref{inst:uchicago},\ref{inst:equal}}}, J. L. Bean, D. Samra, M. E. Steinrueck Abstract Context. Recent JWST observations of the temperate sub-Neptune K2-18 b have been interpreted as suggestive of a liquid water ocean with possible biological activity. Signatures of dimethyl sulfide (DMS) and dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) have been claimed in the near-infrared (using the NIRISS and NIRSpec instruments) and mid-infrared (using MIRI). However, the statistical significance of the atmospheric imprints of these potential biomarkers has yet to be quantified from a joint analysis of the entire planet spectrum. Aims. We test the robustness of the proposed DMS/DMDS detections by simultaneously modeling the NIRISS and NIRSpec observations jointly with the MIRI spectrum, considering different data reductions and modeling choices. Methods. We use three well-tested pipelines to re-reduce the JWST observations, and two retrieval codes to analyze the resulting transmission spectra as well as previously published data. Results. Our joint analysis of the panchromatic (0.6 – 12 µm) spectrum of K2-18 b finds insufficient evidence for the presence of DMS and/or DMDS in the atmosphere of the planet. Furthermore, other molecules containing methyl functional groups (e.g., ethane) with absorption bands similar to DMS/DMDS provide an equally good fit to the data. We find that any marginal preferences are the result of limiting the number of molecules considered in the model and oversensitivity to small changes between data reductions. Conclusions. Our results confirm that there is no statistical significance for DMS or DMDS in K2-18 b’s atmosphere. While previous works have demonstrated this on MIRI or NIRISS/NIRSpec observations alone, our analysis of the full transmission spectrum does not support claims of potential biomarkers. Using the best-fitting model including DMS/DMDS on the published data, we estimate that ∼ \sim 25 more MIRI transits would be needed for a 3 σ \sigma rejection of a flat line relative to DMS/DMDS features in the planet’s mid-infrared transmission spectrum. From a joint analysis of JWST NIRISS, NIRSpec, and MIRI observations 1 Introduction Figure 1: Transmission spectra of K2-18 b from exoTEDRF (blue), JExoRES (black), SPARTA (orange) and Eureka! (green). For NIRISS and NIRSpec, faded points show higher resolution ( R =100 and 200, respectively) spectra, and solid colors are binned for clarity. Smaller panels show error-normalized differences relative to exoTEDRF . The JExoRES spectra used different binning and are interpolated in the difference panels. The temperate 1 1 1 T_{\rm eq}=255\pm 4\,\mathrm{K} assuming 0.3 Bond albedo ( Benneke et al. 2019 ) . sub-Neptune K2-18 b ( Montet et al. 2015 ) continues to be one of the most intensively studied exoplanets in the search for habitable environments beyond the solar system. Initial Hubble Space Telescope transmission spectroscopy suggested the presence of water vapor in the planet’s atmosphere ( Benneke et al. 2019 ; Tsiaras et al. 2019 ) , though later analyses highlighted degeneracies between H 2 O and CH 4 ( Barclay et al. 2021 ; Blain et al. 2021 ) . With the increased wavelength range of JWST, Madhusudhan et al. 2023 reported the detection of CH 4 at 5 \sigma and CO 2 at 3 \sigma in the H 2 -rich atmosphere of K2-18 b using data between 0.8 and 5 µm. These findings were interpreted as evidence supporting a hycean scenario — a world covered by a water ocean beneath a thin H 2 -rich atmosphere — potentially offering habitable conditions ( Piette & Madhusudhan 2020 ; Madhusudhan et al. 2021 ) . 38 also reported a low-significance signal from dimethyl sulfide (C 2 H 6 S or DMS) — a potential biosignature gas — in their near-infrared (NIR) spectrum. However, the robustness of these detections, particularly the tentative inference of DMS, has been the subject of active scrutiny. A reanalysis of the data presented in 38 by Schmidt et al. 2025 confirmed CH 4 at 4 \sigma , but found no statistically significant evidence for either CO 2 or DMS. Even using the molecular abundances from 38 , the hycean interpretation itself has been challenged ( Wogan et al. 2024 ; Shorttle et al. 2024 ; Huang et al. 2024 ) . More recently, Madhusudhan et al. 2025 inferred spectral features consistent with DMS and/or dimethyl disulfide (C 2 H 6 S 2 or DMDS) at 3 \sigma confidence in new mid-infrared JWST data from 5 to 12 µm. 36 argued that they represent independent evidence for the presence of sulfur-bearing biosignature gases. However, this analysis did not include the existing NIR JWST data, and the statistical robustness of the detection itself has been brought into question by Taylor 2025 and 66 . In this work, we present a reanalysis of the full suite of JWST transmission spectra of K2-18 b to reassess the evidence for DMS and/or DMDS. Advanced data products from this paper can be downloaded from Zenodo . Figure 2: Results from the PLATON retrievals performed on the transmission spectrum of K2-18 b produced with JExoRES in 38 and 36 . Top: Transmission spectrum (native-resolution data used in the retrievals in gray, binned data in black for visualization purposes). Best-fit models for the five cases outlined in the text are shown: a baseline model (blue), a model with DMS and DMDS (orange), a model with a common hydrocarbon C 2 H 6 (green), a model with DMS and DMDS but without using the MIRI data (red), and the baseline model with DMS, DMDS, and C 2 H 6 (pink). Models are smoothed to R\sim 200 for clarity. Bottom: 1D marginalized posterior distributions on the molecular species included in each retrieval. Colors reflect the model in the top panel. The black points and vertical dashed lines indicate the abundances reported for each molecule in 38 from just NIRISS and NIRSpec, whereas the gray points in the DMS/DMDS panel indicate the abundances reported in 36 from MIRI data alone. Figure 3: Results from the SCARLET retrievals on exoTEDRF and SPARTA where C 2 H 6 is included in the baseline. Top: Retrievals performed on the exoTEDRF dataset (data in gray, binned in purple). The best-fit model for the retrievals without (with) DMS or DMDS is shown in dark (light) purple, smoothed to R=200 . We show as a dashed line the impact of increasing the C 2 H 6 abundance to 10^{-2} in the best-fit model from the retrieval without DMS/DMDS with the dashed line. Middle: Same, but using SPARTA (orange) for the NIRSpec and MIRI datasets. Bottom: 1D marginalized posterior distributions on the molecular species included in each retrieval. Colors reflect the models in the top. Black error bars and vertical lines (median \pm 1\sigma or 2 \sigma upper limits) correspond to the combined POSEIDON results from 54 (which did not include the MIRI data). 2 Data The observations of K2-18 b analyzed in this work ( 38 ; 36 ; 54 , and in) are part of JWST GO Program 2722. There are a total of three transit observations: one each with the Near Infrared Imager and Slitless Spectrograph ( Doyon et al. 2023 , NIRISS;) in Single Object Slitless Spectroscopy (