Unraveling superradiance: entanglement and mutual information in collective decay

Xin H. H. Zhang, Daniel Malz, Peter Rabl · 2025

Read Unraveling superradiance: entanglement and mutual information in collective decay by Xin H. H. Zhang, Daniel Malz, Peter Rabl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13401.txt.

Introduction

Xin Zhang and co-authors dissect superradiance, the bright burst when many atoms shed light together. The burst is usually told as a story of shared quantum links. The team instead follows single runs of the decay, using a diffusion method to unravel each path. They test two settings: atoms bathed in squeezed light, and atoms linked to a one way light channel.

Links between atoms do build up along the way, fed by squeezing or by dark states. Yet the burst itself is well matched by averages over states with no links at all. The team explains this by a near total split of pairwise measures. For squeezed light, they give a purely classic account of the burst that stays exact for many atoms.

Catalog record

CREATORXin H. H. Zhang, Daniel Malz, Peter Rabl
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13401

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unraveling superradiance: entanglement and mutual information in collective decay Xin H. H. Zhang, Daniel Malz, Peter Rabl Abstract We study the collective decay of an initially inverted ensemble of two-level emitters into a squeezed photonic reservoir. By using a quantum-state diffusion approach to unravel the emission process, we investigate entanglement and classical correlations along individual quantum trajectories over time. This numerical analysis shows that despite an accelerated initial build-up of entanglement and a significant amount of spin squeezing in the steady state, the essential features of the superradiant burst are well described by averages over fully factorizable states. We explain this observation in terms of an almost complete factorization of all 2-local observables, which we identify as a generic property of superradiant decay. Based on this insight, we provide a purely classical theory for the burst in squeezed superradiance, which is both intuitive and exact for a large number of emitters. Moreover, we show that our numerical approach is also applicable for the investigation of subradiant states, which dominate the slow residual decay of non-uniform ensembles at very long times. Superradiance is a prototypical example that shows how the build-up of environment-induced correlations can drastically accelerate the decay of a large ensemble of two-level emitters Dicke 1954 ; Gross and Haroche 1982 . Interestingly, this phenomenon can explained in terms of transitions between highly entangled Dicke states Dicke 1954 , or as a dissipative evolution of a mixture of spin coherent states Narducci et al. 1974a . While the former interpretation suggests that quantum entanglement plays an important role in superradiance, in the latter description, the emission burst can be described classically, but seeded by initial quantum fluctuations. In conventional Dicke superradiance, where the underlying permutation symmetry permits precise analytic predictions Rehler and Eberly 1971 ; Bonifacio et al. 1971a ; Bonifacio et al. 1971b ; Degiorgio 1971 ; Degiorgio and Ghielmetti 1971 ; Haake and Glauber 1972 ; Narducci et al. 1974b ; Narducci et al. 1974a ; Agarwal 1974 ; Gross and Haroche 1982 ; Malz et al. 2022 ; Holzinger et al. 2025 , both descriptions lead to the same result Narducci et al. 1974a . However, in more general situations without permutation symmetry, the situation is much less clear, and the question whether entanglement is essential to describe the physical process gains immediate relevance, because numerical simulations are much more efficient in the absence of entanglement. This becomes particularly relevant for the study of subradiant states Guerin et al. 2016 ; Asenjo-Garcia et al. 2017a ; Albrecht et al. 2019 ; Holzinger et al. 2022 ; Fasser et al. 2024 ; Tiranov et al. 2023 ; Sheremet et al. 2023 ; Henriet et al. 2019 ; Kornovan et al. 2019 ; Wang et al. 2020 ; Zhang and Mølmer 2020 ; Poshakinskiy and Poddubny 2021 ; Glicenstein et al. 2022 ; Rubies-Bigorda and Yelin 2022 ; Piñeiro Orioli et al. 2022 ; Santos et al. 2022 ; Rubies-Bigorda et al. 2023 ; Fasser et al. 2024 ; Shi and Poddubny 2024 ; Ferioli et al. 2025 ; Lee et al. 2025 , which determine the long-time residual decay of non-uniform ensembles, and are expected to be highly entangled. In this Letter, we go beyond Dicke superradiance in two case studies. First, we study the decay of a permutation-invariant ensemble of two-level systems (TLSs) into a squeezed reservoir, and second, we consider a one-dimensional (1D) array of TLSs with spatially varying couplings to a reservoir. In the former scenario, it is well-known that the emitters relax into a steady state with a large degree of spin squeezing Agarwal and Puri 1989 ; Agarwal and Puri 1990 ; Dalla Torre et al. 2013 ; Barberena and Rey 2024 , which provides a direct witness for entanglement Sørensen et al. 2001 . Thus the natural question arises of how these quantum correlations emerge during the decay process and how they affect the superradiant burst. To address this question, here we use a quantum state diffusion (QSD) approach Dalibard et al. 1992 ; Gardiner et al. 1992 ; Gisin and Percival 1992 ; Carmichael 1993 to unravel the evolution of the mixed state of the system in terms of individual quantum trajectories. Along each stochastic trajectory, the system is in a pure state and can be represented as matrix product state (MPS) Schollwöck 2005 ; Cirac et al. 2021 , with an adjustable degree of entanglement. While from these simulations we observe a superradiant growth of entanglement already in the initial phases, these quantum correlations do not affect the central features of superradiance, which are accurately reproduced by averages over fully factorized states. As an immediate consequence, this finding allows us to derive an intuitive analytic model, which accurately predicts all the features of the emission burst for squeezed superradiance. Figure 1: (a) Schematic of an ensemble of two-level dipoles emitting collectively into a squeezed reservoir. Time evolution of (b) the magnetization \braket{S_{z}}/N , and (c) the average decay rate \mathcal{R}/N , as obtained from QSD simulations with N=50 TLSs and a bond dimension of d=10 . For comparison, the results with d=1 are shown by the dashed lines. For these plots, we used a step size of \delta t=2\times 10^{-4}\gamma^{-1} and averaged over N_{\text{tr}}=10^{3} trajectories. In the second scenario, of a one-dimensional (1D) array of TLSs with spatially varying couplings, it is known that the system occupies entangled dark states at late times after the superradiant burst. However, also in this case we find that the factorized state accurately reproduce the exact decay, including the late-time dynamics dominated by subradiant states. We explain this agreement by the suppression the total mutual information between any two TLSs along each trajectory. Therefore, while significant entanglement can be generated during both superradiant and subradiant decay, our results show that many relevant observables can be computed without taking such quantum correlations into account. This observation suggests that QSD simulations with factorizable states are already sufficient to model collective radiation processes in large ensembles with spatial varying couplings and in the presence of squeezing—scenarios that have been out of reach of efficient numerical simulations so far. Squeezed Superradiance. —We first study the collective radiative decay of N TLSs into a homogeneous, squeezed reservoir. This process can be modeled by a master equation of the form Agarwal and Puri 1989 ; Agarwal and Puri 1990 \frac{d}{dt}\rho=\gamma\mathcal{D}[S_{x}-i\zeta S_{y}]\rho, (1) where \rho is the system density operator and \gamma the decay rate of a single TLS. In Eq. ( 1 ) we have defined \mathcal{D}[J]\rho=J\rho J^{\dagger}-\frac{1}{2}\{\rho,J^{\dagger}J\} and introduced the collective spin operators S_{\alpha}=\sum_{j=1}^{N}\sigma_{j}^{\alpha}/2 with \sigma_{j}^{\alpha} denoting the usual Pauli operators. The parameter \zeta\in[0,1] quantifies the degree of squeezing, where for \zeta=1 we recover the case of conventional Dicke superradiance, while \zeta=0 corresponds to the extreme limit of an infinitely squeezed reservoir. For intermediate \zeta<1 , the steady state of Eq. ( 1 ) is a spin-squeezed state Agarwal and Puri 1989 ; Agarwal and Puri 1990 ; Dalla Torre et al. 2013 ; Barberena and Rey 2024 with spin- squeezing parameter \xi_{\text{R}}^{2}\approx\zeta . Note that a value of \xi_{\text{R}}^{2}<1 certifies that the state is entangled Sørensen et al. 2001 . In the following, we are primarily interested

Read the complete text