State- versus Reaction-Based Information Processing in Biochemical Networks

Anne-Lena Moor 1,2,∗, Age Tjalma 3, Manuel Reinhardt 3, Pieter Rein ten Wolde 3,∗, Christoph Zechner 4,1,2,∗ · 2025

Read State- versus Reaction-Based Information Processing in Biochemical Networks by Anne-Lena Moor 1,2,∗, Age Tjalma 3, Manuel Reinhardt 3, Pieter Rein ten Wolde 3,∗, Christoph Zechner 4,1,2,∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13373.txt.

Introduction

Anne-Lena Moor and colleagues clarified a measurement puzzle in biochemical networks in 2025. Researchers often quantify how much information one part of a cell's chemistry carries about another using trajectory mutual information. A popular shortcut, the linear-noise approximation, computes it through Gaussian channel theory and should be trustworthy for large systems. Yet in some cases its answers disagreed qualitatively with exact calculations, even for large molecule counts.

The authors show the mismatch comes from two different ways of describing a trajectory. In chemical systems the information lives in the sequence of reaction events, which the exact jump-process description records. The Gaussian shortcut can instead lump separate reaction channels into a single combined noise term, a state-based view that loses event detail. Naming that distinction explains when each calculation should be believed.

Catalog record

CREATORAnne-Lena Moor 1,2,∗, Age Tjalma 3, Manuel Reinhardt 3, Pieter Rein ten Wolde 3,∗, Christoph Zechner 4,1,2,∗
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13373

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

State- versus Reaction-Based Information Processing in Biochemical Networks Preprint: AIP/123-QED Anne-Lena Moor 1,2,∗, Age Tjalma 3, Manuel Reinhardt 3, Pieter Rein ten Wolde 3,∗, Christoph Zechner 4,1,2,∗ Abstract Trajectory mutual information is frequently used to quantify information transfer in biochemical systems. Tractable solutions of the trajectory mutual information can be obtained via the widely used Linear-Noise Approximation (LNA) using Gaussian channel theory. This approach is expected to be accurate for sufficiently large systems. However, recent observations show that there are cases, where the mutual information obtained this way differs qualitatively from results derived using an exact Markov jump process formalism, and that the differences persist even for large systems. In this letter, we show that these differences can be explained by introducing the notion of reaction- versus state-based descriptions of trajectories. In chemical systems, the information is encoded in the sequence of reaction events, and the reaction-based trajectories of Markov jump processes capture this information. In contrast, the commonly used form of the LNA uses a state (concentration) based description of trajectories, which contains, in general, less information than a reaction-based description. Here, we show that an alternative formulation of the LNA that retains the reaction-specific information of trajectories can accurately describe the trajectory mutual information for large systems. We illustrate the consequences of different trajectory descriptions for two common cellular reaction motifs and discuss the connection with Berg-Purcell and Maximum-Likelihood sensing. Introduction. Accurately responding to time-varying signals is essential for many natural and engineered systems, ranging from neural and biochemical networks to electronic circuits. The central measure for quantifying information transmission via time-varying signals is the information transmission rate, also called trajectory- or path mutual information rate shannon1948mathematical ; PhysRevLett.102.218101 ; fano1961transmission ; duso2019path . Mathematically, it is defined as the rate at which the path mutual information between the input and output signal trajectories increases with the duration of these trajectories in the long-time limit. For systems without feedback, the path mutual information is identical to the history dependent transfer entropy PhysRevLett.85.461 . In contrast to other information theoretical measures, such as the instantaneous or time-lagged mutual information PhysRevE.81.061917 , the path mutual information not only captures the accuracy of the instantaneous input-output mapping, but also the effect of temporal correlations within the input and output signals. Cellular signalling networks show that the encoding of information in trajectories can be highly non-trivial. These systems transmit information via chemical reactions between discrete molecules. In the limit that these systems are well mixed, they are appropriately described as discrete Markov jump processes. Yet, it is commonly believed that continuous, Gaussian approximations become accurate when the reactions are linear and the copy numbers are large PhysRevE.82.031914 ; 10.1371/journal.pone.0001077 ; 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000125 . They can indeed accurately predict the instantaneous mutual information, even when the copy numbers are as small as 10 PhysRevE.82.031914 . For this reason, a Gaussian approach like the Linear-Noise Approximation is frequently used to compute the information transmission rate vankampen ; PhysRevLett.102.218101 . However, it has recently been shown that this Gaussian approach not only significantly underestimates the information rate, but can, in some situations, also lead to qualitatively different behaviour, even when the copy numbers are large and the instantaneous mutual information is correctly predicted Moor ; PhysRevX.13.041017 . This observation raises the question how information is encoded in trajectories and how this information can be quantified. In this work, we introduce the notion of reaction- versus state-based descriptions of trajectories. We show that the common formulation of the Linear Noise Approximation (LNA) entails a state-based path description, where information is transferred via copy number/concentration fluctuations. Yet, in cellular systems the information on the input is encoded in the sequence of reaction events of the output. The discrete trajectories of the Markov jump processes capture this encoding by the reaction events, while the state-based LNA does not. The discrete reaction-based trajectories contain, in fact, more information than the corresponding continuous state-based trajectories, explaining why the Gaussian model significantly underestimates the rate for any copy number. This observation naturally leads to an alternative formulation of the LNA, the Reaction-based LNA (RNLA), which is a continuous description but explicitly keeps track of the individual reaction events (see Fig. 1 ). We show that this description accurately predicts the path mutual information rate for linear chemical systems at large copy numbers. In the large copy number limit the principal difference between the commonly employed state-based LNA and the Markov jump process is indeed not the discreteness of molecules but the encoding of information in reaction events rather than concentrations. Finally, we demonstrate that the distinction between reaction- versus state-based trajectories has ramifications for information transmission in cellular systems, by analyzing systems that can harness the information that resides in the reaction events. Stochastic Reaction Dynamics. We consider a well-mixed reaction system of size \Omega , consisting of M chemical species \mathrm{Z}_{1},...,\mathrm{Z}_{M} . These species interact via K distinct reaction channels. The state of the system is denoted by the vector z(t) which contains the copy numbers of the respective species at time t . To each reaction channel k , we associate a rate function h_{k}(z(t)) and define h(z)=(h_{1}(z),\ldots,h_{K}(z))^{T} and H(z)=\mathrm{diag}(h(z)) . For sufficiently large systems, we can make use of the approximation z(t)=\Omega\hat{z}(t)+\delta z(t) , where \hat{z}(t) is the macroscopic mean concentration of z(t) and \delta z(t) is a random fluctuation that scales with the square root of the system size \Omega^{1/2} vankampen . For stationary systems, the dynamics of \delta z(t) satisfies \begin{split}\mathrm{d}(\delta z(t))=SJ\delta z(t)\mathrm{d}t+SH^{1/2}\mathrm{d}w(t),\end{split} (1) where S is the stoichiometry matrix with dimension M\times K , J is the Jacobian of h(z) evaluated at the macroscopic mean \hat{z} and \mathrm{d}w denotes a K -dimensional noise vector of independent, standard Wiener processes, with each element \mathrm{d}w_{k}(t) reflecting an individual reaction channel (see Supplementary Material (SM) A). Reaction- Versus State-based Path Descriptions. The main difference between a reaction- and state-based path description lies in whether trajectories are defined using a K -dimensional reaction noise vector, or an M -dimensional vector describing the effective copy number noise. In Eq. ( 1 ), the matrix SH^{1/2} transforms the K -dimensional reaction noise vector \mathrm{d}w into the M -dimensional species-level noise \mathrm{d}\xi=SH^{1/2}\mathrm{d}w , summarising the net contribution of reactions to the effective change in copy numbers. Since the linear combination of two Gaussian processes is again a Gaussian process, \mathrm{d}\xi remains a vector of standard Wiener processes with a modified covariance structure. For instance, the sum of two independent Gaussian increments a\mathrm{d}w_{1}(t)+b\mathrm{d}w_{2}(t) results in a single Gaussian increment \sqrt{a^{2}+b^{2}}\mathrm{d}w(t) . This projection leads to the commonly used state-based formulation of the LNA, for which trajectories are defined as \tilde{z}_{0}^{t}=\left\{\mathrm{d}\xi(s)\mid 0\leq s<t\right\} . Importantly, however, while the effective noise on a species contains the effect of all reactions that modify a species, the information on the input trajectory is, in general, contained only in a subset of reaction channels. The remaining reactions act as a source of uninformative noise which hampers information transfer. This observation leads to formulating the LNA based at the level of reaction channels, which we refer to as Reaction-based LNA (RLNA). In this formalism, each path is described by the individual reaction events, i.e. z_{0}^{t}=\left\{\mathrm{d}w_{k}(s),k\in\{1,...,K\}\mid 0\leq s<t\right\} , and hence,

Read the complete text