Measuring Social Influence with Networked Synthetic Control
Ho-Chun Herbert Chang · 2025
Read Measuring Social Influence with Networked Synthetic Control by Ho-Chun Herbert Chang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13334.txt.
Introduction
Chang measured social influence with synthetic controls in this paper from twenty twenty-five. Claiming someone swayed others is hard without a counterfactual world where they stayed silent. A recent measure, social value, builds that stand-in world with machine learning. It predicts an outcome from an outside signal, then splits credit across a network.
Chang derives how the measure behaves under plain and interacting linear models. Lattice, power-law, and random networks each get a theoretical treatment. A shortcut trims the computation for any ensemble of models. Simulations confirmed a generalized friendship paradox: in some settings, your friends are on average more influential than you. The paper grounds a new tool for political behavior research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ho-Chun Herbert Chang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13334
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Measuring Social Influence with Networked Synthetic Control Ho-Chun Herbert Chang Abstract Measuring social influence is difficult due to the lack of counter-factuals and comparisons. By combining machine modeling and network science, we present general properties of social value, a recent measure for social influence using synthetic control applicable to political behavior. Social value diverges from centrality measures on in that it relies on an external regressor to predict an output variable of interest, generates a synthetic measure of influence, then distributes individual contribution based on a social network. Through theoretical derivations, we show the properties of SV under linear regression with and without interaction, across lattice networks, power-law networks, and random graphs. A reduction in computation can be achieved for any ensemble model. Through simulation, we find that the generalized friendship paradox holds— that in certain situations, your friends have on average more influence than you do. 1 Introduction Understanding the effects of interventions, events, or individuals on social behavior remains a central challenge in computational social science. In the absence of randomized experiments, researchers often rely on observational data to construct counterfactual scenarios—what could have happened—posing what is often a challenge of “speculative fiction.” Traditionally, random field experiments were a principle way to produce direct causal evidence. Beyond randomized experiments, comparative case studies are often used to demonstrate what "could have been," should an event not happened. For instance, studies have investigated the role of Cuban migration in Miami compared to other southern cities ( Card 1990 ) or examined the effects of terrorist conflict in Basque Country against other Spanish regions ( Abadie and Gardeazabal 2003 ) . However, case studies provide a very limited sample size. To address this limitation, synthetic control methods evaluate the effects of policies in absence of such comparisons, by constructing synthetic control groups through weighted combinations ( Abadie et al. 2015 ) . For instance, Beckley, Horiuchi, and Miller (2018) constructed a "synthetic" Japan to simulate conditions had the United States not formed an alliance ( Beckley et al. 2018 ) . Growth in the predictive power in machine learning, such as gradient-boosting trees ( Natekin and Knoll 2013 ) and deep learning ( LeCun et al. 2015 ) , has made synthetic control more feasible and accessible. In particular, advances in large-language models such as ChatGPT have enabled interpretable and linguistically advanced modeling of human subjects ( Noh and Chang 2024 ; Park et al. 2024 ; Li et al. 2024 ) . However, for social network analysis, the use of synthetic methods presents another methodological challenge, the computationally extensive nature of pairwise relationships. A network of just 100,000 nodes may have up to 10 billion edges. Additionally, existing quasi-experimental approaches often target nodes and edges, rather than the attributes themselves. Simulation-based method such as "knockout" experiments which simulate changes to network structure should certain nodes be removed. For instance, Chang et al. (2023) knocked out wealth managers in offshore financial networks to demonstrate the critical role of intermediaries, and to simulate sanctions on wealth managers ( Chang et al. 2023 ) . However, these results are interpreted in terms of the network structure, rather than targeted dependent variables. Recently, a new framework for calculating social influence ( Williams et al. 2023 ) called social value (SV) has been proposed. By removing social co-variates in predicting the behavior of others, the aggregated change in a person’s neighbor’s behavior encapsulates social influence. In this sense, it combines pairwise synthetic control with network science to produce a metric for social influence, leveraging the inclusion-exclsuion principle. This method has since been used to disambiguate individual contributions—i.e. their social value—toward political communication ( Yang and Williams 2024 ) , online attention, purchasing behavior ( Williams et al. 2023 ) , and ideological change. While the method has received usage, the method’s theoretical and mathematical properties have yet to be established analytically. This paper generalizes social value by formalizing how three fundamental components interact computation of social influence— network , model , and distribution . We make three contributions. First, we provides a unified framework for computing social value from synthetic control and networks. Second, we derives analytical results for linear, interaction, and ensemble models across standard graph families. Third, we shows SV’s compatibility with the generalized friendship paradox ( Eom and Jo 2014 ) . 2 Related Literature 2.1 Centrality Measures and Their Limitations Centrality metrics have long been foundational tools in social network analysis (SNA) for assessing the structural importance or influence of nodes ( Freeman 1979 ; Jackson 2011 ) . These measures quantify how embedded an individual is within a network, based on graph-theoretic properties such as connectivity, path length, and position in flow or communication structures. There are a few common measures of centrality. Degree centrality, the most basic measure, counts the number of direct connections a node has. While it serves as a direct measure of popularity, it fails to capture the broader structural context. Closeness centrality measures a node’s average distance to all others in the network, thereby identifying the immediacy of its interaction with other nodes. Betweenness centrality captures the extent to which a node lies on the shortest paths between other nodes, and is typically seen as the measurement for brokerage ( Brandes 2001 ) . Despite their widespread use, these centrality measures are fundamentally structural: they reflect a node’s position in the network topology but not its effect on actual outcomes or behaviors ( Borgatti 2005 ) . Studies that have introduced these centrality measures are limited ( Benyahia and Largeron 2015 ) . Moreover, these centrality measures are global and computationally intensive; for instance, computing betweenness centrality requires examining all shortest paths in the network, leading to O(N^{3}) complexity for unweighted graphs ( Brandes 2001 ) , which is often intractable for large online or dynamic networks. 2.2 Causal Inference for Social Networks In tandem, growth in causal inference has reshaped statistical research especially as applied to the social sciences ( Angrist and Pischke 2009 ; Hernán and Robins 2020 ; Imbens and Rubin 2015 ; Morgan and Winship 2014 ; Pearl 2000 ; Rosenbaum 2002 ) . Techniques that have attracted attention include randomization tests ( Basu 1980 ) , matching estimators ( Abadie and Imbens 2006 ; Ho et al. 2007 ) , regression discontinuity ( Imbens and Lemieux 2008 ; Cattaneo and Titiunik 2022 ; Lee 2008 ) , difference-in-differences ( Card and Krueger 1994 ) , and crucially, synthetic control ( Abadie et al. 2010 ) . This growth in causal inference has perhaps resisted integration into network science, due to the complex nature of graphs. Some work has attempted to bridged network analysis and causal inference. Pseudo-causal methods like knock-out experiments have been employed in economic sociology, and successfully measured network fragmentation across the offshore financial network of democratic and autocratic countries ( Chang et al. 2023 ) . However, since the measured attributes are still global, which resists individual-level analysis. Generative models like exponential random graph models (ERGMs) and stochastic actor-oriented models (SAOMs) ( Hunter et al. 2008 ; Steglich et al. 2010 ) , attempt to integrate the individuals within network formation. ERGMs model the probability of observing