On the stability analysis of cooling functions Journal: ApJ
Amanda Stricklan, Tim Waters, James Klimchuk · 2025
Read On the stability analysis of cooling functions Journal: ApJ by Amanda Stricklan, Tim Waters, James Klimchuk (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13178.txt.
Introduction
Gas in the sky cools by light and crash, and the cool curve can tip the gas to break up or to hold. Amanda Stricklan, Tim Waters, and James Klimchuk map where that tip lives in a 2025 study. Their map is built on a famed cool bar, set by a past rule for the ill's edge, and stretched to count heat spread.
No full map of the ill's space for off balance gas had been made. Their map gives one, and shows a twin ill, the crash cool ill, can rule where the old ill is held by heat spread. Loop sims of sky rain bear it out: rain loops sit in the crash ill's zone, not the old one's. The map is a guide for all thin gas sims.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Amanda Stricklan, Tim Waters, James Klimchuk |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13178
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the stability analysis of cooling functions Journal: ApJ Amanda Stricklan, Tim Waters, James Klimchuk Abstract To model the temperature evolution of optically thin astrophysical environments at MHD scales, radiative and collisional cooling rates are typically either pre-tabulated or fit into a functional form and then input into MHD codes as a radiative loss function. Thermal balance requires estimates of the analogous heating rates, which are harder to calculate, and due to uncertainties in the underlying dissipative heating processes, these rates are often simply parameterized. The resulting net cooling function defines an equilibrium curve that varies with density and temperature. Such cooling functions can make the gas prone to thermal instability (TI), which will cause departures from equilibrium. There has been no systematic study of thermally unstable parameter space for nonequilibrium states. Motivated by our recent finding that there is a related linear instability, catastrophic cooling instability, that can dominate over TI, here we carry out such a study. We show that Balbus’ instability criteria for TI can be used to define a critical cooling rate, Λ c \Lambda_{c} , that permits a nonequilibrium analysis of cooling functions through the mapping of TI zones. We furthermore extend Balbus’ criteria to account for thermal conduction. Upon applying a Λ c \Lambda_{c} -based stability analysis to coronal loop simulations, we find that loops undergoing periodic episodes of coronal rain formation are linearly unstable to catastrophic cooling instability, while TI is stabilized by thermal conduction. show][email protected] I Introduction The radiative and collisional heating and cooling rates of both neutral and ionized gas have been extensively studied within the astrophysics and solar physics communities ( M. A. Dopita & R. S. Sutherland 2003 ; M. J. Aschwanden 2004 ; E. Priest 2014 ; B. S. Ryden & R. W. Pogge 2021 , for a textbook account, see e.g.) . Estimates of these rates are essential inputs for MHD codes capable of modeling condensation phenomena. The common practice is currently to calculate these rates up front as a function of temperature and density using plasma codes with atomic databases such as CHIANTI ( K. P. Dere et al. 1997 ) and APED/APEC ( R. K. Smith et al. 2001 ) , MAPPINGS ( R. S. Sutherland & M. A. Dopita 1993 ) , SPEX ( J. S. Kaastra et al. 1996 ) , XSTAR ( T. Kallman & M. Bautista 2001 ) , and Cloudy ( G. J. Ferland et al. 2017 ) . In studies of the interstellar medium (ISM), even the most sophisticated efforts to model heating and cooling processes for hydrogen self-consistently using a chemistry network ( R. P. Nelson & W. D. Langer 1999 ; S. C. O. Glover & M.-M. Mac Low 2007 ; S. C. O. Glover et al. 2010 ; M. Gong et al. 2017 ; M. Gong et al. 2023 , e.g.) still rely on tabulated cooling functions for incorporating rates from heavier elements ( Y. Wang et al. 2014 ; J.-G. Kim et al. 2023 ; D. Robinson et al. 2024 , e.g.) . The phase diagrams associated with ISM cooling functions typically reveal that there can be multi-temperature solutions at the same gas pressure ( F. H. Shu 1992 , see, for example,) . The well known linear instability associated with these cooling functions, thermal instability (TI), can serve as the mechanism causing such ‘multiphase’ solutions to appear when solving the MHD equations. The overall cooling and heating rates are sensitive to the elemental abundances and to the radiative and collisional processes taking place ( C. Xia et al. 2011 ; S. P. Moschou et al. 2015 ; V. Jerčić et al. 2024 , e.g.) , but for a given parcel of gas cooling at a specified rate, the stability analysis of the parcel is rather simple, depending on only two thermodynamic derivatives ( G. B. Field 1965 ) . The nonlinear outcome of TI is to trigger catastrophic cooling, a runaway radiative cooling process in which gas cools rapidly to a new thermal equilibrium state. In his comprehensive study on the linear theory of TI, G. B. Field 1965 showed that the eigenmodes found by E. N. Parker 1953 , in the first paper on the subject, are not self-consistent solutions to the equations of gas dynamics because they were derived from the heat equation alone. However, he neglected to point out that both his and Parker’s eigenmodes agree in the zero wavenumber limit where the evolution becomes truly isochoric. We recently showed that this special eigenmode—because it comes from the heat equation alone—is actually the thermal mode of an entirely separate instability (see T. Waters & A. Stricklan 2025 , hereafter referred to as 93 ) . After presenting results of a very general nature about TI, we will turn our attention to the relevance of this catastrophic cooling instability to solving a longstanding problem regarding so-called thermal nonequilibrium (TNE), a cyclic process commonly observed in global coronal loop simulations ( S. K. Antiochos & J. A. Klimchuk 1991 ; S. K. Antiochos et al. 1999 ; J. A. Klimchuk et al. 2010 ; C. Froment et al. 2017 ; C. Froment et al. 2018 ; C. D. Johnston et al. 2019 ; P. Antolin 2020 ; M. J. Schlenker et al. 2021 ; G. Pelouze et al. 2022 ; R. B. Scott et al. 2024 ; T. Yoshihisa et al. 2025 , e.g.) . We mentioned both ISM and coronal loop modeling to point out a gap in how these research fields, which together encompass the majority of the early TI literature, have traditionally approached the stability analysis of TI. The ISM community has long utilized phase diagrams to identify thermally unstable parameter space ( E. Vázquez-Semadeni et al. 2000 ; A. G. Kritsuk & M. L. Norman 2002 ; M. G. Wolfire et al. 2003 ; S.-I. Inutsuka et al. 2005 ; J.-G. Kim & W.-T. Kim 2013 ; E. Saury et al. 2014 , e.g.) . This type of analysis is rarely used in coronal loop modeling, not even in the study of prominences and coronal rain where TI is often invoked as the underlying formation process ( J. T. Karpen 2015 ; P.-F. Chen et al. 2020 ; P. Antolin 2020 ; P. Antolin & C. Froment 2022 , see the reviews by) . This is likely because numerical models often utilize a position-dependent heating term that would make phase diagrams functions of height and hence difficult to analyze ( J. A. Klimchuk & M. Luna 2019 ; P. Kohutova et al. 2020 ; N. Brughmans et al. 2022 ; X. Li et al. 2022 , e.g.) . Instead, such studies typically only show the cooling curve, which is a plot of the radiative loss function versus temperature ( P. Kohutova et al. 2020 ; T. Williams et al. 2021 ; S. Daley-Yates et al. 2023 ; D. Donné & R. Keppens 2024 , e.g.) . Neither of these research communities has utilized TI zones, identifiable regions within a phase diagram where the gas is thermally unstable that follow mathematically from the stability criteria identified by S. A. Balbus 1986 . TI zones have proven very useful for understanding