Linear analysis of I-C-Love universal relations for neutron stars

Zexin Hu, Yong Gao, Lijing Shao · 2025

Read Linear analysis of I-C-Love universal relations for neutron stars by Zexin Hu, Yong Gao, Lijing Shao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13110.txt.

Introduction

Zexin Hu, Yong Gao, and Lijing Shao study why some relations among neutron star traits hold for almost any inner makeup, in a research paper from 2025. Neutron stars squeeze more than a sun's mass into a city-sized ball. Their inner matter is poorly known, yet certain links between spin, compactness, and tidal pull barely depend on it.

The team gives a new linear analysis that splits the small deviations from these relations into two multiplied parts. One part reflects how two candidate inner-matter models differ. The other depends only on the star's background structure. The smallness of that second part explains the near-universal behavior, they argue.

Catalog record

CREATORZexin Hu, Yong Gao, Lijing Shao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13110

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Linear analysis of I-C-Love universal relations for neutron stars Zexin Hu, Yong Gao, Lijing Shao Abstract Neutron stars (NSs) are excellent laboratories for testing gravity theories as they are strongly self-gravitating bodies and have rich observational phenomena. However, strong-field gravity effects in NS could be degenerate with their equation of state (EOS) which is largely unknown. Fortunately, there exist the so-called universal relations among the NS macroscopic quantities that are found to be insensitive to the underlying EOS. Studying the origin of these relations can lead to a better understanding of NSs and the gravitational interaction. We develop a new perspective of view to analyze the I-C and I-Love universal relations for NSs. At the linear order, we separate the deviation of the universal relations into two factors that are multiplied together. One is the EOS difference while the other factor only depends on the background star structure. The smallness of the second factor that does not depend on the EOS difference then indicates the origin of the universality. We discuss the validity of our linear approximation when considering the difference among realistic EOSs. Our study can be regarded as a new frame for quantitative representation of the universality and may provide new insights to the universal relations of NSs. I Introduction Neutron stars (NSs) are extremely compact objects in the Nature. Thanks to their strong self-gravity, large density in the inner region, and abundant observational phenomena, they are ideal laboratories for studying fundamental physics, including the strong-field gravity and nuclear physics [ 29 , 44 , 16 ] . For example, the mass-radius relationship of NSs strongly depends on the supranuclear matter equation of state (EOS), which is the relation between the matter density \rho and pressure p . Thus, independently measuring the mass M and radius R of a NS can provide valuable constraints on the EOS at the high density regime that is unachievable with terrestrial nuclear experiments. The observations of heavy pulsars with masses \gtrsim 2\,M_{\odot} have already ruled out those EOSs that are too “soft” for supporting a large mass NS in the general relativity (GR) [ 14 , 10 , 3 ] . Current X-ray observations with the NICER satellite can measure the mass and radius of a pulsar to \sim 10\% accuracy and have also been used to constrain the EOS [ 39 , 36 ] . However, the mass-radius relationship of NSs can be affected by the underlying gravity theory as well. A well-known example is the scalar-tensor theory, while passing all weak-field gravity tests in some parameter space [ 46 ] , predicts large deviation in the strong-field regime with a phenomenon called spontaneous scalarization [ 8 , 9 , 11 ] . Binary NSs were used as excellent testbeds, notably with the observational absence of the gravitational dipole radiation that is otherwise predicted in the scalar-tensor gravity theory [ 15 , 41 , 52 ] . But still, considering a massive scalar field can evade these dipole-radiation constraints [ 38 , 13 , 24 , 47 , 25 ] . The degeneracy between the strong-field gravity effects and the nuclear matter EOS in NSs causes a challenge for studying both aspects [ 43 ] . A test of strong-field gravity can only be done if we assume that we know the underlying EOS or systematically taken into account its large uncertainties, and vise versa. One way to break this degeneracy is provided by the finding of the so-called universal relations among some NS properties [ 50 , 49 , 33 , 5 , 18 , 31 , 42 ] . These relations, for example, the well-known I-Love-Q relation for the dimensionless NS moment of inertia \tilde{I} , tidal Love number \tilde{\Lambda} and spin induced quadrupole moment \tilde{Q} , are largely insensitive to the EOSs but sometimes do depend on the gravity theories or even not universal in theories beyond GR [ 51 ] . Thus, independent measurement of these quantities will enable us to have EOS independent test of gravity theories. In this regard, the I-Love relation will be especially interesting as the tidal Love number of NS can be measured with gravitational wave observations [ 1 ] , while it is expected to measure the NS moment of inertia with the timing observation of the Double Pulsar J0737 - 3039A/B [ 24 , 28 ] . Besides the interesting applications of these universal relations, studying themselves also provides us better understanding of NSs and gravity theories. The origin of the universality, which can be as good as \lesssim 1\% level in the I-Love-Q relations, is still in discussion. In literature, it is proposed at the beginning that the universality may come from the similarity of the different EOSs in the low density regime or it is the remnants of the no-hair theorem [ 49 , 50 ] . Considering that some relations like I-Love-Q even hold among NSs and quark stars (QSs), which are composed with quark matter that has a completely different EOS behavior in the low density regime, it is then proposed that the universality may come from the emergent self-similarity of isodensity contours inside NSs [ 48 ] or the realistic EOS is “close” to the incompressible limit [ 40 , 27 ] . There are also analytical calculations of these relations based on series expansion of the star’s compactness and assuming an incompressible EOS [ 6 ] or Tolman VII model that phenomenologically describes the density profile inside NSs [ 26 , 30 ] . Most of the studies on analyzing the NS universal relations take some specific parametrization of the EOS or assumptions of the NS configurations, and the relations are also often expanded around the Newtonian limit. These attempts may reveal the possible key ingredient that preserves the universality, but also may lead to questions that why these configurations hold for various EOSs. Though there are a limited number of studies using different approaches, Chan et al. [7] showed that the I-Love relation in the incompressible limit is stationary at the leading order of EOS variation and star’s compactness. In this work, we analyze the NSs’ I-C and I-Love universal relations from a new perspective of view. Rather than parametrizing or expanding the EOSs or NS structures, we consider the linear response of the universal relation under any EOS perturbations. With this approach, we are able to separate the deviation of the universal relation caused by EOS perturbations into two parts that are multiplied together: one is the difference in the EOSs and the other factor only depends on the background star solution. As one can have almost arbitrary EOS difference if the universal relation holds, the smallness of the second factor fully accounts for the universality. Our approach also does not assume an expansion in the star’s compactness thus is applicable for both Newtonian and GR configurations. The remaining part of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we display the basic equations for calculating the I-C universal relations, and we introduce our concepts and approaches in Sec. III . We apply our approach to a simple case that can be solved analytically in Sec. IV , and we apply

Read the complete text